The Four Main Confectionery Tubs

[EineReiseDurchDieZeit]

Roses:

Best

Hazel In Caramel

Worst

Strawberry

Quality Street

Best

Green Triangle

Worst

Toffee Penny

Celebrations

Best

Malteaser

Worst

Bounty

Heroes

Best

Crunchie

Worst

Eclair. The Eclair is the worst sweet in any tub and shouldn't be there !

Agree?

Exact same for me xx

Best: All the fondant ones, followed by fudges then caramels. All the others are just so much chocolate bin fodder as far as I'm concerned.

When you're right, you're right

Sorry that was for @DJL19

Best obviously!

Exclusive to John Lewis. I may have half-filled my refill tin with coffee creams.

None are worth the calories anymore. However a big bar of Lidl own chocolate is a different matter

NEW INFORMATION! I doubt I will get near John Lewis this week though!

Quality Street Best: strawberry cream
Quality Street Worst: green triangle

Roses Best: strawberry cream
Roses Worst: I can’t remember

Celebrations Best: Mars
Celebrations Worst: Galaxy Caramel

Heroes Best: Fudge
Heroes Worst: Cream Egg and Caramel tied

I love the strawberry ones ! Them and rhe oranges are by far my favourite in Roses.

Wading in to ask where everybody is seeing these tubs, because where I am (mid-Wales) I haven't seen any at all and I've been looking

Not to derail, but the price of the tubs these days makes me flinch , and I'm positive they are a lot smaller than they used to be. You used to be able to get a tub for a quid on Xmas eve - and I'm not even that old!

You're very confused @EineReiseDurchDieZeit Totally incorrect in most of your choices.

Roses
Best - Golden Barrel
Worst - Orange creme

Quality Street
Best - Green triangle
Worst - Strawberry Delight

Celebrations
Best - Galaxy Caramel
Worst - Twix

Heroes
Best - Wispa
Worst - Crunchie

Éclair is elite chocolate and should be included in all tubs, even those not made by Cadbury.

I love toffee pennies. My family once had a tin of just toffee pennies (probably 40 years ago) and I’m pretty sure I ate every single one.

Best: éclairs, coconut quality street, snickers

Worst: creme egg ones and anything featuring strawberry/orange flavour

My favourite is the orange cream I work in a secondary school so in January when we go back I scour staff areas and offices and gorge myself most people hate them.
I'm sure there is a dark chocolate version but I can't find it.
I put a massive box of dark chocolates from M and S on the Xmas ocado order so I'm hoping it's in there. Unless I just hallucinated it. I hate it when I just imagine things.

Tesco £4.50 Sainsburys £6

I got mine in a small Tesco Express , but I only got 2, the others I have boxes as gifts

@HunterHearstHelmsley

Well we are agreed on the Green Triangle !

I’ll swap you my green triangles and Galaxy Caramels for your strawberry and orange creams?

Are we still going?

No one has said the big purple one! Yum. Almost as yum as the Bounty.

I got mine in Tesc when they were on offer for 3 quid a tub before they hiked them up for Halloween and then xmas
<twirls>

Big purple has always had its full title in this house! They can hardly call it big purple now it's clearly been shrunk!

Roses:

Worst

All of them , too sweet and I swear they messed with the chocolate

Quality Street

Best

Green Triangle

Worst

Again all too sweet but the orange one is the worst by far.

Celebrations

Best

Malteaser

Worst

All are ok

Heroes

Best

Crunchie

Worst

Double decker

Oh lordy

Fun sponge alert!

Just popped on to say I love eclairs

I am genuinely surprised at my disdain for eclairs being controversial