Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Parents who refuse to pursue a diagnosis for their children

546 replies

emilybrontosaurus · 01/12/2024 10:55

I am just wondering if teachers or others express a child may have neurodiversity and the parents just sort of sit on that information - why? And could this be considered neglectful?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
NameChange30 · 01/12/2024 14:21

TheWayTheLightFalls · 01/12/2024 12:25

To all the “don’t see the point” parents - if your children are at/near teenage years, why not involve them in the conversation and make a decision with them? It’s their life after all. The path of “functions or excels at school, all goes to shit at uni / the workplace” is a very well trodden one for ND folk.

I sought out diagnosis as an adult after feeling frankly odd or malfunctioning for most of my life, and usually taking it out on myself. My parents, school, work colleagues, friends, acquaintances would all tell you that I am lovely, smart, able etc - because I hid how I felt and worked 12 hours where others worked 8, to cover how inadequate I felt and how long things took to do. Oh, and self harmed on a massive scale. Including at home, as a teen. Always in places on my body where others wouldn’t see. I was in my late 30s when I sought out diagnosis. That’s over 30 years of feeling dumb, less than, malfunctioning, panicky, stressed, tripping over basic tasks. My parents didn’t and don’t have any idea.

I wish someone at home or school would have taken me aside and pointed out that I was good at a,b,c but seemed to battle with x,y,z, and let me know that it was ok and there were strategies we could try to help, let alone medication. That would have been very unlikely in my Commonwealth school in the 1990s, but hearing people say the same about their kids in the UK in 2024 is frankly heartbreaking.

Flowers
selffellatingouroborosofhate · 01/12/2024 14:22

FriendOrNo · 01/12/2024 13:51

If you don't suspect you are a zebra and no one around you has an issue with your zebraness why would that person need confirmation of being a zebra?

no one around you has an issue with your zebraness

This does not exist. As soon as you interact with non-family, people have an issue with your zebraness.

PocketSand · 01/12/2024 14:23

You absolutely have to collect medical evidence, including diagnosis at the earliest opportunity. There are backlogs and delays. Don't add to delay.

If DS2 had not been diagnosed his access to support (illegal as access is supposed to be need led) would have been delayed and he would not have had an EHCP whilst still at primary. As well as ASD and ADHD he had speech delay and was written off as biddable but stupid. Primary called in EP expecting low IQ but it turned out he was 99.8 level.

Without an EHCP, He would not have had priority access to secondary schools.

When secondary failed he, without an EHCP, would not have had access to internet school and tutors funded by the LA. He would not have achieved 11 GCSEs with good enough grades to progress.

Without an EHCP he would not have been entitled to support and extra time at 6th form college and achieve A*, A A in maths, further maths and physics.

Without his EHCP, medical history and previously supplied support he would not be entitled to DSA and extra time at uni.

Support at school is crap. But it gets better if you can navigate that. You need medical evidence to do that. Don't let schools convince you it is of no value.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

trivialMorning · 01/12/2024 14:24

emilybrontosaurus · 01/12/2024 14:10

Definitely not even close to needing specialist provision. If, and it’s a massive if, he is ND, he’s very high functioning.

I asked advice on a FB group about some challenging aspects of behaviour and I guess so much of the ‘standard’ advice just doesn’t work and got told he is definitely ND and why haven’t I seen my GP yet … which I take with a pinch of salt but still. I think even if he is there’s nothing to be gained in pursuing a diagnosis.

Transition to school or age/great school demands may make it clearer.

Till then I'd adapt to the child you have - one of mine needed one step instructions and to say it back - needed count downs to changes in activities - and needed a lot of outside time and struggled with sleep so tried many things to help - and lots of repetition and scaffolding - breaking down task - to manage and to learn - standard advice like reward charts didn't work - another child struggled massive with textures and noise we helped as much as we could.

Tittat50 · 01/12/2024 14:25

@selffellatingouroborosofhate this is so true. I felt sick to my stomach trying to understand what was happening and why others were having issues with my son. It was the feeling I got from other parents. I'm sensitive to other people and it was horrible what I could feel. I needed to understand it. Because I'm a single parent I just didn't fully realise outside of our bubble.

FriendOrNo · 01/12/2024 14:26

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 01/12/2024 13:36

Because we are surrounded by people labeling us "rude", "aloof", "thoughtless", "arrogant", "know-it-all", "hysterical", "overly emotional", "crybaby", "manipulative", "drama queen" when we get human interactions wrong and no matter how hard we try, we can't get them right?

Because we blame ourselves for not getting social interactions right and it becomes suicidal self-hatred?

Because we miss out on jobs because we didn't know we could ask for reasonable adjustments at interviews?

Because the NT community already roll their eyes when someone says "I'm autistic" because of the number of self-diagnosed people out there saying that and my personal experience of adding "formally-diagnosed" is that their attitudes change markedly and favourably?

Because having a multiple page diagnostic report caused an immediate, substantial, and favourable readjustment in my employer's attitude towards me?

I'm not sure that those labels only apply to people with autism or ADHD though and are you suggesting that people with a diagnosis should exempt themselves from trying not to appear to be rude/thoughtless etc but everyone else should address how they behave if they are deemed to be rude/thoughtless?
When people perceive me to be rude or dismissive and it gets fed back to me (because I won't have noticed otherwise) I will feel bad that I have upset that person if I care about them or I won't care if i dont care about them. For the people I care about I will apologise and either explain that things don't always come out as I would like and try and remember what I was doing/saying that they didn't like and try and remember to change how I do it/say it next time. I'm not sure that process would be any different with or without a diagnosis or make me feel any different.

FoFanta · 01/12/2024 14:27

Jellycats4life · 01/12/2024 11:32

It’s not just about school support though.

The ability to understand why your brain is wired the way it is, why you're socially awkward, highly anxious, why you process information different to your peers, why you have intense sensory issues (I could go on).

Put simply, knowing that you’re not a fucking weird unlikeable failure of a neurotypical person, but instead a very normal neurodivergent person, is absolutely priceless.

Edited

Seeing the difference it has made to my teen daughter's self esteem has 100% made her diagnosis worth it. After a really hard first year at secondary school when we realised our quirky, bright girl might be having a different experience to her peers, and encouraged by a fantastic year head at school, we went for private assessment.

After a period of adjustment while she got used to the idea of being autistic, she is thriving. She is able to be her true self - she chooses to mask sometimes, but she then makes sure she takes time after to settle herself and recover.

After being terrified that we were going to lose her forever, we have a lovely, curious, quirky, empathetic, kind young woman who can advocate for herself and build a future that plays to her strengths. I was so scared of what it would mean if she was labelled as autistic - but that fact it that she IS autistic - diagnosis or not. But the diagnosis means she understands herself better and can accept herself.

Tittat50 · 01/12/2024 14:28

@emilybrontosaurus I didn't see your child's age. Things will very likely change. Once the demands of more challenging social interaction comes into play, things change. You may really wish you had pursued sooner.

Not one single person said to me i should look into it until the end of primary. Even then it was just ' hints '. People are afraid to say what they see because parents get upset, defensive and may react very badly to a teacher suggesting it.

NameChange30 · 01/12/2024 14:30

Kitkat1523 · 01/12/2024 13:06

It can be a gateway to support though….practical support, educational support and financial support….it can also ensure a child can access the correct specialist education ( if needed)…..several of our local primaries have an asd unit attached ..,and the children are able to mix in The mainstream class, as they are able…..without a diagnosis you cannot apply for a place

Yup

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 01/12/2024 14:32

OnlyinBlackandWhite · 01/12/2024 13:28

@selffellatingouroborosofhate my concern is that these types of evaluations will spread not just to Australia but across many countries in the future or that biometric passport may end up including these types of things.

It's hard for us to imagine what types of immigration or health checks will be required in the future- but in the next 70 years, there's bound to be a lot of changes which is why diagnosis at say age 10 might have implications for the future, I don't think it's ridiculous to think these things through if people are more in the grey area of still deliberating.

No one would refuse an assessment for asthma for their child on the basis of a possible future wish to emigrate.

You've completely missed my point.

Loads of people can't do X Y or Z because of a disability. Loads of people. Yet, for neurodivergent conditions alone, ducking a diagnosis because of a future wish to do X Y or Z is somehow deemed OK.

Do you remember the Lufthansa pilot who flew his aircraft, with hundreds of passengers, into a mountain to commit suicide? Would you accept pilots ducking a depression diagnosis because it would stop them from flying?

Where there is a genuine occupational requirement to be free of a particular medical condition to do a job, ducking the diagnosis puts lives at risk. We don't get to do everything we want to do in life. Denying your children a diagnostic assessment because of possible future restrictions on their jobs or ability to emigrate is selfish and risks others, as well as denying your child the support they will need to live with that condition.

NameChange30 · 01/12/2024 14:36

FriendOrNo · 01/12/2024 13:15

But if you suspect that you are anyway, why does a professional person confirming that to you make a difference? Why can't you just recognise 'yep I'm probably a zebra' for yourself/child and then find out what works for you based on that?

Because some people like certainty. I do.
I feel more confident advocating for my child precisely because a professional has diagnosed him as autistic, and crucially, they take me much more seriously than they did before his diagnosis, when all I could say was that I thought he was autistic.

NameChange30 · 01/12/2024 14:38

Thiswasmeagain · 01/12/2024 13:25

My mother declined an assessment for me in the early 90s and devised her own programme to ‘de sensitise’ me which was basically extreme emotional abuse and traumatic exposure therapy.

I am so sorry. I hope you have been able to live a happier life as an adult.

Attheedgeoftown · 01/12/2024 14:40

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 01/12/2024 14:20

I absolutely see a problem with this. Where did I say that I didn't?

What I have said is that professionals trying to act outside their expertise can cause more harm than good, as I personally found out.

They should have the expertise! That is my point. Why don’t they? Why are they limiting themselves to treating NT children?

But they don't have that expertise and, with the current shit state of NHS funding, that's not likely to change. The staff would have to be trained in how to treat ND children and possibly more staff hired. I absolutely agree with you that this isn't OK. I don't see a way forwards that doesn't involve the govt spending money.

Yeah, but basically saying ‘it is what it is’ doesn’t really help my family really. Or all the others. Especially when you criticise me for trying to access the only ‘help’ available (I appreciate you may have being trying to advise and help but it did come across as a bit critical).

We have no choice but to continue to engage with CAMHS as they prescribe DC’s medication.

NameChange30 · 01/12/2024 14:42

Sunnyandshiney · 01/12/2024 13:29

I never said 'it was a Fucking label'. so please don't pin those words on me!

I said in my posts as and when he needs an assessment we will get one done privately if that's what he wants. He can also get it done as an adult if he wants.

I don't think you realise the waiting lists are at least a minimum of 2 years plus for getting assessed through school. You cannot just click your fingers and get one!!

There's a lot of naivety on this thread about how easy it is to get a child assessed. There is no money and no resources in the state system. Zero. SEN support is literally on its knees.

So people should maybe do some research before judging people about what happened 20 years ago when you were at school or what you've experienced in the workplace

Not many people know about this option, unfortunately, but there is 'Right to Choose' which is NHS-funded assessment and it is usually quicker than the standard route. It's how my child was assessed and diagnosed. Took less than 6 months from referral to diagnosis.

Also, I don't see the harm in getting your son added to the waiting list now - a lot can change in 2 years so by the time he gets to the top of the list, you/he might feel that it's worth doing. What's the harm in getting him on the list? You/he can always withdraw later if you choose.

PocketSand · 01/12/2024 14:44

I forgot to mention DLA and PIP. I used DS2's DLA to pay for private Salt, OT and EP reports that were instrumental in getting him support. The transfer from DLA to PIP is difficult as criteria change but is helped by previously submitted medical evidence.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 01/12/2024 14:44

FriendOrNo · 01/12/2024 14:26

I'm not sure that those labels only apply to people with autism or ADHD though and are you suggesting that people with a diagnosis should exempt themselves from trying not to appear to be rude/thoughtless etc but everyone else should address how they behave if they are deemed to be rude/thoughtless?
When people perceive me to be rude or dismissive and it gets fed back to me (because I won't have noticed otherwise) I will feel bad that I have upset that person if I care about them or I won't care if i dont care about them. For the people I care about I will apologise and either explain that things don't always come out as I would like and try and remember what I was doing/saying that they didn't like and try and remember to change how I do it/say it next time. I'm not sure that process would be any different with or without a diagnosis or make me feel any different.

We get called those labels no matter how hard we try. Not making eye contact, not smiling, not understanding the rules even when someone tries to explain them. Getting confused by contradictory rules.

My stock example of contradictory rules is how our parents tell us to tell the truth, but then when someone asks me if I like their dress/haircut/etc and I truthfully say that I don't, I'm now in the wrong. In that circumstance, I am deemed rude for hurting the other person's feelings by being truthful as I was taught to be, but no one considers her decision to fish for compliments to be rude and no one considers my view that fishing for compliments and coercing people into lying is appalling behaviour.

Other autistic people have described the differences between autistic and non-autistic people as akin to a cultural difference. If it was treated as a cultural difference, people would know that autistic people are likely to resent being coerced into lying and would know not to fish for compliments with us.

emilybrontosaurus · 01/12/2024 14:47

NameChange30 · 01/12/2024 14:42

Not many people know about this option, unfortunately, but there is 'Right to Choose' which is NHS-funded assessment and it is usually quicker than the standard route. It's how my child was assessed and diagnosed. Took less than 6 months from referral to diagnosis.

Also, I don't see the harm in getting your son added to the waiting list now - a lot can change in 2 years so by the time he gets to the top of the list, you/he might feel that it's worth doing. What's the harm in getting him on the list? You/he can always withdraw later if you choose.

I think the harm could be in a few ways.

My main concern is that something like autism or ADHD has a number of traits and while combined with a lot of them in isolation some of them are just, well, people. DH for example hyper fixates but I genuinely don’t believe he has autism (with the usual disclaimers no one really knows) - he just has this trait. So I do think it is possible once someone has said ‘autism is a possibility’ to have a sort of ‘seek and ye shall find’ thing.

It isn’t like standing in a queue to get an ice cream and changing your mind and then letting someone else in your spot. It’s a big deal.

OP posts:
BarkLife · 01/12/2024 14:51

A lot of children I know have 'half' a diagnosis i.e. they're AuDHD but only have the 'Au' bit diagnosed. Their lives could be transformed if they were medicated for ADHD. I guess the problem is waiting lists.

Parents who don't at least try the meds treatment for ADHD are very baffling. You'd treat your child for diabetes, right?

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 01/12/2024 14:52

Sunnyandshiney · 01/12/2024 13:29

I never said 'it was a Fucking label'. so please don't pin those words on me!

I said in my posts as and when he needs an assessment we will get one done privately if that's what he wants. He can also get it done as an adult if he wants.

I don't think you realise the waiting lists are at least a minimum of 2 years plus for getting assessed through school. You cannot just click your fingers and get one!!

There's a lot of naivety on this thread about how easy it is to get a child assessed. There is no money and no resources in the state system. Zero. SEN support is literally on its knees.

So people should maybe do some research before judging people about what happened 20 years ago when you were at school or what you've experienced in the workplace

The waiting lists are longer for adults, over three years for me, and in many areas there is no NHS adult assessment for autism full-stop. Delaying now may slam the door shut for him forever. When I looked at private assessment for myself, the waiting lists for private assessment at Lorna Wing were closed. It's not a given that private assessment will be available for adults.

With two year waiting lists for children, you can't afford to wait until things get difficult for him to get him on the list.

Plastictrees · 01/12/2024 14:56

BarkLife · 01/12/2024 14:51

A lot of children I know have 'half' a diagnosis i.e. they're AuDHD but only have the 'Au' bit diagnosed. Their lives could be transformed if they were medicated for ADHD. I guess the problem is waiting lists.

Parents who don't at least try the meds treatment for ADHD are very baffling. You'd treat your child for diabetes, right?

The problem is there is no diagnostic test for ADHD in the same way there is for diabetes. It doesn’t show up on blood tests, for example. The diagnostic process for ADHD is based on observable behaviours, but there is a lot of diagnostic overshadowing with trauma and types of anxiety as it is essentially poor executive functioning and impaired fight or flight response, leading to dysregulation. I conduct ADHD assessments but I understand why parents are cautious about medication.

There are many alternative options besides medicating your child.

BarkLife · 01/12/2024 15:01

@Plastictrees

Anxiety is an ADHD symptom, though, the dopamine issues literally cause it (and trigger the HPA cortisol response, if I'm not mistaken). We could measure cortisol? I'm convinced it's raised significantly in ADHD people.

When I was a stressed and anxious child, I would have loved to have taken a pill to stop the terror.

NameChange30 · 01/12/2024 15:01

emilybrontosaurus · 01/12/2024 14:47

I think the harm could be in a few ways.

My main concern is that something like autism or ADHD has a number of traits and while combined with a lot of them in isolation some of them are just, well, people. DH for example hyper fixates but I genuinely don’t believe he has autism (with the usual disclaimers no one really knows) - he just has this trait. So I do think it is possible once someone has said ‘autism is a possibility’ to have a sort of ‘seek and ye shall find’ thing.

It isn’t like standing in a queue to get an ice cream and changing your mind and then letting someone else in your spot. It’s a big deal.

I think you're still in the denial phase.
You seem to have bought into the (very damaging) narrative that autism/ADHD diagnoses are given out on demand. They are not. There are strict diagnostic criteria. Some people don't get diagnosed. (My child was assessed for both and diagnosed with autism but not ADHD.) Someone who just has "traits" but does not meet all the diagnostic criteria will not be diagnosed.

I had my lightbulb moment when DS was 4, just before he started school. I did doubt myself for a long time, largely because of all the gaslighting, but also because I'm not a professional and I didn't know much about autism at the time, but from then on I educated myself as best I could. The more I learned, and the more I observed DS with that knowledge as he grew older and struggled with various things, the more sure I became. DH didn't want to believe it, though, and only accepted it at last when we had the actual diagnosis. He was upset about it, but at least he was honest about his feelings, rather than hiding behind excuses like "I don't want to label him" or "a diagnosis won't change anything". Actually a diagnosis has helped us a lot.

MarliaST · 01/12/2024 15:02

DreamyDreamy · 01/12/2024 11:57

What I don’t get about the ‘label’ thing: even after a diagnosis, it is your choice to disclose it or not.
A PP mentioned career limitation, how??

My experience: since DS has been diagnosed with high functioning autism, what used to be considered ‘bad behaviour’ at school, resulting in warnings etc, is now treated as challenges and the school staff work with him to find strategies. Minor things such as not assigning him a desk next to the window as it was too distracting.

We are now looking at secondary schools, St Paul’s head’s speech: « we have diversity at our school: neurodiversity! ». Similar at Westminster.

Severely curtailed a young adults plans to join the Armed Forces (occupation dependent), for instance.

footballmum25 · 01/12/2024 15:03

as the child of a parent who didn’t seek a diagnosis for me - it made my teenage/adult life absolute hell. took me 2.5 years to get a diagnosis and that was only once i had worked out myself that i had an issue

Plastictrees · 01/12/2024 15:06

BarkLife · 01/12/2024 15:01

@Plastictrees

Anxiety is an ADHD symptom, though, the dopamine issues literally cause it (and trigger the HPA cortisol response, if I'm not mistaken). We could measure cortisol? I'm convinced it's raised significantly in ADHD people.

When I was a stressed and anxious child, I would have loved to have taken a pill to stop the terror.

I’m unsure what dopamine issues you mean. I’m skeptical of dopamine hypothesis in general, as many have been proven to be incorrect such as in depression. Cortisol can be raised for many reasons so I don’t think that could be used as a marker of ADHD.

I’m sure, or other strategies to manage anxiety? I would be very cautious of children taking medication for anxiety without trying alternatives first, in terms of fostering a long term dependency.