Maybe a good way to frame this is to think about other things that have a normal range -e.g. height, how many balls you can catch in a minute
There are extremes, and being at an extreme may be indicative of a problem. Most people will be within the normal range. If you are within the normal range, one measurement within that range doesn’t make you more normal than another.
Being extremely short or extremely tall can be associated with health issues in the right clinical context. But there are also very tall and short people who just happen to be their height.
You could even think about a big tube of smarties. Having nearly no red smarties, or nearly all red smarties would be unexpected. It might be an issue with one of the machines in the factory (or indeed it might just be a random blip). But you wouldn’t worry if one pack had 10 red smarties and another had 15 - that could just be due to chance.
I hope that makes sense and helps give you some reassurance.
I would also say that, with regards to the Ca-125, really please do not worry. You are well within the normal range. 5 does not make you more normal than 19 where the upper limit of normal is 35.
Even had it been just above the ULN, as a lot of people have said above, moderately raised levels are often seen in the absence of cancer. All investigations are just an additional piece of data that help put together the picture, and should be interpreted in the context of the clinical picture (and if necessary, other information).