Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Dilemma! : Relocate back closer to family or stay for the good jobs and opportunities?

35 replies

JessinEdinburgh · 16/05/2024 07:12

We moved up to Edinburgh 13 years ago from the midlands for our graduate jobs & further study, built our careers, got married up here and recently started a family.
But we find ourselves 300+ miles away from all our other family, we have an 11 month old and another baby on the way now later in the year (yes 2 under 2! 🙈).
Plus our sis in law is also pregnant, so cousins are on the way as well which is exciting.
Our parents aren't getting any younger and we'd like our children to know their family well. This isn't even about needing childcare but yes the odd night off would be welcomed too!

Really swithering as to whether we move back south to be closer to family.

The main concern for us is that hubs has a longstanding brilliant job in Edinburgh. My own job isnt all rosy so im willing to find a new opportunity elsewhere - but his company are amazing as the salary, nice team mates, 1 year paternity leave, plus other perks like bonuses, away days and the high percentage paid by the company into his pension etc are just far too good to give up in a way. It has essentially afforded us this life we have and the employers are headquartered and only located in Edinburgh.

Family is absolutely important of course, but hubs is convinced he will never find another job/ company that even comes close to what he has currently, and we are trying to second guess what the hybrid/ remote working policy will be come next year after his company move to their new offices.
It also might not be feasible even for us to move further south but him travel up on the train for say 2-3 days a week in the office in Edinburgh. I feel that the cost of trains and hotels, commute timings and him being away from us a lot will make it not worth doing almost. It would be a huge risk to move and then be told he can't do remote work/ live elsewhere too.

Plus we love our area, family community feel etc - there's just so much going on up here in and around Edinburgh too. The opportunities for the children in future, access to spectacular scenic countryside, beaches and activities, schooling etc far exceed what is available nearer family. Then again that's what we grew up with, and we were happy enough as kids as we knew no better.

We've just absolutely been spoilt with the "good" life up here but our parents aren't getting any younger and we'd love our kids to grow up knowing their family and new cousins on the way! It's just so tricky giving up what we have grown/ built up here.

Has anyone else been in this tough situation and could help shed any light/ give a different perspective on things?

Feeling so torn, just wish we could move our family closer.
Sick of being on the road going up and down the A1 all the time 😅 but would certainly miss Edinburgh life massively if we moved back down south permanently. I don't want to move back, or even a bit nearer to them, to somewhere we don't really know, and then seriously regret it.

Grateful for any advice 🙏 thank you for reading 😅

OP posts:
Tiredmumof6 · 19/05/2024 22:33

Bizarrely; we have just done this !
lived Edinburgh for ten years, moved south for 4 years. Sporadically saw family but it wasn’t how we thought it would be tbh. Visits were good but genuinely, it wasn’t worth the upheaval.
we don’t have high powered jobs; so diff in that sense, but we moved back to just outside Edinburgh ( 4 weeks ago ! ) and the relief being back is immense !!!
I miss family, but for the majority of the time, it was us initiating contact :/
for us, never moving back south !

Doone22 · 20/05/2024 15:50

You have time. You're not working to a deadline here. Just wait and see

SassyOpalDuck · 21/05/2024 23:13

It’s such a tough choice, especially with how great your husband’s job is! I can understand the difficult decision 100%.

We moved back, away from my dream job that I loved, to be near my family and it was the best thing I ever did, I lost my dad three years after moving home and I cherish those memories I had with him so, so much. I honestly don’t know how I’d have coped if I had stayed away and missed out. We are a very close family and I’m in and out of my mum and sister’s pockets, my children and their cousins are all very close and I don’t think I would give that up for anything - BUT, only you know your family and your dynamic. How often I see my family or how much time our kids spend together and our relationship together may not be the same as yours, so it would be unfair to pass judgement and tell you what I think you should do without knowing you/your family/your life in Edinburgh…but I still hope it’s a little helpful hearing another person’s experience.

I agree that there is no rush, especially if your husband gets such a great paternity package, I’d definitely take advantage of that again!

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

Xmasbaby11 · 21/05/2024 23:17

I’d stay in Edinburgh. You sound v happy there and it’s a great place to bring up your kids.

Alwaytired44 · 22/05/2024 11:01

JessinEdinburgh · 16/05/2024 07:12

We moved up to Edinburgh 13 years ago from the midlands for our graduate jobs & further study, built our careers, got married up here and recently started a family.
But we find ourselves 300+ miles away from all our other family, we have an 11 month old and another baby on the way now later in the year (yes 2 under 2! 🙈).
Plus our sis in law is also pregnant, so cousins are on the way as well which is exciting.
Our parents aren't getting any younger and we'd like our children to know their family well. This isn't even about needing childcare but yes the odd night off would be welcomed too!

Really swithering as to whether we move back south to be closer to family.

The main concern for us is that hubs has a longstanding brilliant job in Edinburgh. My own job isnt all rosy so im willing to find a new opportunity elsewhere - but his company are amazing as the salary, nice team mates, 1 year paternity leave, plus other perks like bonuses, away days and the high percentage paid by the company into his pension etc are just far too good to give up in a way. It has essentially afforded us this life we have and the employers are headquartered and only located in Edinburgh.

Family is absolutely important of course, but hubs is convinced he will never find another job/ company that even comes close to what he has currently, and we are trying to second guess what the hybrid/ remote working policy will be come next year after his company move to their new offices.
It also might not be feasible even for us to move further south but him travel up on the train for say 2-3 days a week in the office in Edinburgh. I feel that the cost of trains and hotels, commute timings and him being away from us a lot will make it not worth doing almost. It would be a huge risk to move and then be told he can't do remote work/ live elsewhere too.

Plus we love our area, family community feel etc - there's just so much going on up here in and around Edinburgh too. The opportunities for the children in future, access to spectacular scenic countryside, beaches and activities, schooling etc far exceed what is available nearer family. Then again that's what we grew up with, and we were happy enough as kids as we knew no better.

We've just absolutely been spoilt with the "good" life up here but our parents aren't getting any younger and we'd love our kids to grow up knowing their family and new cousins on the way! It's just so tricky giving up what we have grown/ built up here.

Has anyone else been in this tough situation and could help shed any light/ give a different perspective on things?

Feeling so torn, just wish we could move our family closer.
Sick of being on the road going up and down the A1 all the time 😅 but would certainly miss Edinburgh life massively if we moved back down south permanently. I don't want to move back, or even a bit nearer to them, to somewhere we don't really know, and then seriously regret it.

Grateful for any advice 🙏 thank you for reading 😅

I would suggest your husband talks to his employer and gets a firm position regarding remote working, perhaps offer 2 days a month in the office and the rest of the time at home. For those 2 days, he could stay in a premier inn which wouldn’t cost a lot.

If they like him and don’t want to lose him then they may be amenable to doing whatever it takes to keep him.

I only live 15/20 mins away from my parents but it does bother me that my brother and his family (who live down the road from them) do see them more frequently than we do so I understand where you’re coming from.

Good Luck!

Imbusytodaysorry · 22/05/2024 19:29

Don’t do it. They have all built up there own lives while You have been away . The idea of what you think it’s like never matches the reality.

You have a good life which has taken you years to build up don’t give it up .

isitme111 · 22/05/2024 19:51

Not me but a friend did something similar. The expectation of how family relationships/contact would be has not lived up to the reality. It's great that your SIL is expecting a baby but as with siblings there's no guarantee your children and hers will enjoy each others company. You life in Edinburgh sounds lovely. Is there any chance you can do more frequent visits to family back south.

ellabellaaaa · 28/07/2024 01:26

@JessinEdinburgh I came across your post when looking online for advice about whether to move closer to family, and couldn't believe how similar our situations are (myself and DH have been in Edinburgh for 10 years with both our families down South). Have made any decisions about whether to stay in Edinburgh or move? I'm also so torn.

JessinEdinburgh · 28/07/2024 12:21

@ellabellaaaa oh hi! How funny we're in the same boat!
Have to admit we haven't made any decisions as yet, going to wait til baby #2 arrives and see how we feel about life a few months after he's here!
I'm back home in Lincolnshire at the moment seeing friends n family, and the weather here is tempting me back i can't lie 😅 they get proper sun down here, none of this sunny but cloudy, sometimes windy and often humid nonsense we get in Scotland.
Also things have changed for us both on the job front in Edinburgh as his is no longer as rosy as it was (few redundancies and people jumping ship before it sinks) and my directors both just resigned so no idea what shape we will all be in come next October when my mat leave will end. Probably prime time to move south then if we did want to consider it properly to be honest!
Hopefully you'll be able to take time to process and figure out what works best for your family! It is such a hard dilemma when Edinburgh and the surrounding area is so great and full of things to do for kids!

OP posts:
ellabellaaaa · 28/07/2024 14:32

@JessinEdinburgh Thank you so much for replying! Sometimes it feels like we’re the only people in Edinburgh with no family nearby, it’s comforting to know that’s not the case even if we are both thinking about a move ☺️ It sounds like your maternity leave is a good opportunity to think about what’s best for your family particularly if things with both of your jobs aren’t great. We’re struggling to find any jobs that offer the pay and flexibility of our current roles (we’re both keen to avoid commuting into London if we can) and feeling a bit overwhelmed with the logistics of it all. I definitely need to focus more on all the positives of Edinburgh life, rather than on dwelling on what we might be missing out on at home! Hope you have a lovely time in Lincolnshire - enjoy the sun! And good luck with baby #2 ❤️

New posts on this thread. Refresh page