Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Those fucking book club questions at the end of books

58 replies

LookAtMyTinyGameBoy · 14/05/2024 08:10

Not posting in AIBU as I know damn well I'm being unreasonable because I could just choose not to read them. But somehow I feel compelled to, even knowing how wrist-gnawingly banal, patronising and superficial they've been every time I've come across a book that has them, and how they'll potentially spoil whatever last impressions and thoughts the book left me with, by making me feel like I'm back at junior school answering comprehension questions.

When I say "patronising", just one example: a question at the end of a book I just finished instructed the reader to look up the definitions of a couple of words which were used in the book as names for particular tech widgets, and then think about why those words might have been chosen. Cause it definitely wouldn't have occurred to me to look them up myself before answering the question, if I didn't happen to know. (Which I did, because it was "flotsam" and "jetsam", which might not be the kind of thing you can just assume someone will have happened to come across, but it's not some arcane terminology beyond the ken of any common reader.)

And… well, every time I come across these crappy book club questions at the end of a book, even something I enjoyed or thought was interesting or clever or elegant, somehow my brain immediately tries to bump it across into an "okay so basically like Jodi Picoult then" category, because that's where I first came across them. Just having book club questions there does something strange to my perception of genre, quality etc. even when I've just read the bloody thing.

Does anyone else hate these questions/suggested discussion topics, but find themselves unable to stop reading when the book ends?

OP posts:
WimseyofBalliol · 14/05/2024 20:08

LookAtMyTinyGameBoy · 14/05/2024 20:05

Mortifying. Isn't there some kind of law on cruelty to authors?

No. Covers alone prove this.

AlienEncounter · 14/05/2024 21:07

This is how shallow those questions are: I joined a book club, and went to my first session not having read the book (a Jodi Picoult one, as it happens...). From the group discussion I got an idea of what the book was about, and could answer all the questions at the back without reading it!

Screamingabdabz · 14/05/2024 21:16

I must be book-clubbing wrong. Our questions are usually designed to draw out wine soaked debate so we can all have a laugh and enjoy the night. Pretentious literary analysis is the last thing you leave the house for, surely?

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

ZaraWebsiteGivingMeTheDoubleRage · 18/05/2024 12:40

I read Of Mice and Men this week, many, many years since reading it at school. I was disappointed not to find bookclub questions at the end that might jog my memory as to what the questions would have been in my English exam 😄

WimseyofBalliol · 18/05/2024 12:44

ZaraWebsiteGivingMeTheDoubleRage · 18/05/2024 12:40

I read Of Mice and Men this week, many, many years since reading it at school. I was disappointed not to find bookclub questions at the end that might jog my memory as to what the questions would have been in my English exam 😄

In my limited experience of ‘book club’ questions at the end of books, they’re very different to school exam questions about themes and imagery etc.

Unopenedpackofmenssocks · 18/05/2024 12:50

LookAtMyTinyGameBoy · 14/05/2024 08:28

I'm not looking for a full-on supervision grilling me on the finer points of literary theory as they relate to whatever I've just read. Just having questions there at all disrupts my own post-novel haze, because my own lack of self-control means I read the questions that weren't put there for me but for the scenario you describe, and I start thinking about whatever they're telling me to think about.

Part of why it's so annoying is that I have only myself to blame.

Edited

Outed yourself as a Cantab there.

WimseyofBalliol · 18/05/2024 13:03

Screamingabdabz · 14/05/2024 21:16

I must be book-clubbing wrong. Our questions are usually designed to draw out wine soaked debate so we can all have a laugh and enjoy the night. Pretentious literary analysis is the last thing you leave the house for, surely?

The very last thing dimwit bookclub questions at the back of books are is ‘pretentious literary analysis’!

LookAtMyTinyGameBoy · 18/05/2024 14:40

Unopenedpackofmenssocks · 18/05/2024 12:50

Outed yourself as a Cantab there.

🤣 Or someone who's met one…

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page