Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Buying first car. Tell me the best and worst cars you've owned

156 replies

MyRabbit79 · 24/01/2024 13:42

As the title says, I need to buy my first ever car. But I'm clueless.

So to give me a start, please share what the best car you've ever owned is and also if there's been a car you've hated.

Particularly if they've been good or bad in terms of reliability and ease of use.

Thank you!

OP posts:
Shade17 · 29/01/2024 10:17

jasflowers · 28/01/2024 08:03

Maybe look at Fleet News?
Toyota number 1, with the remain top 5 places filled by German cars, BMW was no1 for the last 8 years! VW is now no2.

Anecdotally, we ve had company cars from Toyota, Ford and Skoda (300 plus) the Fords and Skodas were the most reliable and nicer to driver.

Anyway, with 2nd hand, how the car has been serviced, driven etc is far more important than surveys on from new cars.

OP needs to take an experienced car with her for the test drive.

Now, that’s interesting and goes against every other reliability index out there but I think the criteria are slightly different. Most fleet cars are fairly new, the majority will be under 3 years old. Most other reliability surveys consider cars up to 5 years old or sometimes older. That suggests to me that German cars are quite reliable during their warranty period and then that falls quite significantly as they start to age. My point still stands though, if you want to buy a 3 year old car, don’t buy German.

MissConductUS · 29/01/2024 11:02

Shade17 · 29/01/2024 10:17

Now, that’s interesting and goes against every other reliability index out there but I think the criteria are slightly different. Most fleet cars are fairly new, the majority will be under 3 years old. Most other reliability surveys consider cars up to 5 years old or sometimes older. That suggests to me that German cars are quite reliable during their warranty period and then that falls quite significantly as they start to age. My point still stands though, if you want to buy a 3 year old car, don’t buy German.

BMW is notorious for using plastic engine parts, which quite predictably fail in a few years. Then they make more money by selling you plastic replacement parts.

https://bavarianmachine.com/embrittling-experiences/

Embrittling Experiences - Bavarian Machine Specialties

By Mike Perkins BMW CCA/Houston Chapter Technical Advisor Owner – Bavarian Machine Specialties There are times I believe all of my new customers are predestined to end up on my doorstep due to an angering experience with their BMW. In this particular i...

https://bavarianmachine.com/embrittling-experiences

jasflowers · 29/01/2024 17:10

Shade17 · 29/01/2024 10:17

Now, that’s interesting and goes against every other reliability index out there but I think the criteria are slightly different. Most fleet cars are fairly new, the majority will be under 3 years old. Most other reliability surveys consider cars up to 5 years old or sometimes older. That suggests to me that German cars are quite reliable during their warranty period and then that falls quite significantly as they start to age. My point still stands though, if you want to buy a 3 year old car, don’t buy German.

TBH Company cars get hammered & will do super hi mileages, most firms now string them out to 4 years, at 3 years old, my German based car had done 80k miles, treble what most would do.

I bought my company Skoda off Lex when i was made redundant, its now almost 8 years old, 120k, has had replaced the standard cam belt and water pump, electric over run water pump and a £43 ABS sensor, did ourselves, read the fault code with a OBDEleven reader for 35 euros, battery is now showing up as Amber :(

Will need some new discs and pads soon, full set of Bosch OEM ones for under £200 and partner can fit himself.

I'm not saying Toyota aren't reliable too but they are v expensive to repair and parts for Japanese Asian cars are often hard to get with long waits for parts.

VAG ones have huge followings and companies like Autodoc and carpartsdirect can get pretty much anything within a day or two from multiple oem manufacturers in Europe.

MyRabbit79 · 16/03/2024 19:06

Popping back in to update that I am picking up a fiesta tomorrow. Absolutely bricking it about driving it home from the garage as it's a route I've never done before. Am even worried about driving it off the lot in front of all the salesmen! Will report back!

OP posts:
Fluffycloudsfloatinginthesky · 16/03/2024 19:39

I have a Honda jazz. It's boring but very reliable.

It's 11 years old and so far has had no issues other than usual wear and tear items.

Shade17 · 17/03/2024 07:56

MyRabbit79 · 16/03/2024 19:06

Popping back in to update that I am picking up a fiesta tomorrow. Absolutely bricking it about driving it home from the garage as it's a route I've never done before. Am even worried about driving it off the lot in front of all the salesmen! Will report back!

Is it a 1.0 Ecoboost? If so just be aware of potential cambelt issues and if it’s anywhere approaching 10 years old budget £1-1.5k for replacement.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page