Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

This is so weird - can anyone shed any light?

31 replies

Leolly · 08/01/2024 16:33

I had a thread sometime last year about a woman who cut me off for no reason at all that I could think of. It really upset me at the time because I liked her very much, thought it was mutual, and thought we were well on the way to becoming friends. I spent weeks trying really hard to think what I could possibly have done.

But, when all was said and done, I'd only known her for about 10 months so I chalked it up to "one of those things". I haven't heard directly from her since but we volunteer for the same organisation so I know that she's doing regular duties, and we are on the same WhatsApp outreach group (again, connected to this charity).

This morning I had a phone call with another woman who works for the same charity. I knew that she and the woman who cut me off were good friends, so I asked her how she (woman who cut me off) was. This morning's woman started crying and eventually was able to tell me that the exact same thing had happened to her. But in her case, they'd been friends for nearly 5 years. Like me, this morning's lady couldn't think of a single thing she'd done - when she messaged to ask, cutting-off woman blocked her. There was also an incident where they happened to meet at the centre where we volunteer, and when this morning's woman said hello to cutting-off woman, cutting-off woman turned her back on her.

This morning's woman was so upset over the whole situation so I told her that, since more or less same thing had happened to me, it wasn't her, it was the other woman.

Anyway, I'm really curious as to why someone would behave like this. I completely get people growing apart or falling out etc, but in neither instance was this the case. Does anyone have any theories as to what could be going through cutting-off woman's mind?! I know that's a big ask, but perhaps you've experienced similar behaviour or have some understanding of personality types? Or something! I've copied and pasted my opening post from my original thread below. Many thanks for any insights and apologies for the length!

Opening post from other thread:

"Some time last year I met a woman at a volunteering activity. We hit it off and quickly became friends.

Since we met we've done volunteering duties together, we've met for coffee, for lunch, for dinner (sometimes alone, sometimes with other friends). In between meetings we've exchanged messages fairly frequently and have discovered we have a lot in common.

So mid April I sent her a message - very normal kind of message for us, asking what she'd been up to and catching up on what's been happening etc. Didn't hear anything for a few days but that's been fairly normal too.

Sent her another message three or four days after that, asking how she was. No reply so after a week I just messaged saying I hoped she was ok, but if not was there something I could do.

Again I didn't hear anything for a week and then got a short message saying "I'm ok thanks". I replied saying I was pleased to hear that and had I done something to upset her?

That was last week. I haven't heard anything and I know I asked "now what?" in my thread title, but I won't message again. I've clearly done something to really upset or anger her - but I honestly have absolutely no idea what it can be. For context, we're in our 50's."

OP posts:
DyslexicPoster · 08/01/2024 19:12

Username123343 · 08/01/2024 18:42

Interesting question. Have you been in my position too? How do you feel about it?

I do wonder about my ex friend a lot and want to know how her kids are getting on. She had some horrible event after ghosting me and I found out by randomly bumping into her. But overall I couldn't trust her again. I would like to stay in touch but not go back to being friends. I met her for lunch and she really enjoyed it, but I was really busy being guarded. All I did was purposely deflect the conversation away from me. Really sad as I think she was possibly the most comfortable person I have ever been around, but it was possibly all fake from the off. Like she didn't really exist? She was never the person I had made her out to be in my head. She constantly put people down towards the end of our friendship and I don't like that trait but ignored my better judgement. She must have been slagging me off to someone else.

One thing that also very telling was one day we met for coffee and a mum from her sons school kept phoning her, and said to me "I don't need to reply, ds is moving school next week". Exactly what she did next to me. I wonder how she copes now her kids are at secondary where it is very hard to befriend your kids mates mums.

Username123343 · 08/01/2024 20:53

DyslexicPoster · 08/01/2024 19:12

I do wonder about my ex friend a lot and want to know how her kids are getting on. She had some horrible event after ghosting me and I found out by randomly bumping into her. But overall I couldn't trust her again. I would like to stay in touch but not go back to being friends. I met her for lunch and she really enjoyed it, but I was really busy being guarded. All I did was purposely deflect the conversation away from me. Really sad as I think she was possibly the most comfortable person I have ever been around, but it was possibly all fake from the off. Like she didn't really exist? She was never the person I had made her out to be in my head. She constantly put people down towards the end of our friendship and I don't like that trait but ignored my better judgement. She must have been slagging me off to someone else.

One thing that also very telling was one day we met for coffee and a mum from her sons school kept phoning her, and said to me "I don't need to reply, ds is moving school next week". Exactly what she did next to me. I wonder how she copes now her kids are at secondary where it is very hard to befriend your kids mates mums.

Yeah, from what you say here and now I’ve gone back and read your first response on this thread where you say what she was like, she sounds as you said too, like her persona was a bit of a fake.

It sounds as though you’ve dodged a bullet there actually, the way you describe how she treats everyone in her life.

The person I’m referring to in my life is very different. She is a humble, warm, genuine and sincere woman. When she explained and apologised, it all made sense in terms of who she is as a gentle and kind soul.

As far as your question to me is concerned, I hadn’t thought about those questions till you asked and I must admit I think if/when we get together I will be like you were with your person - heavily guarded. But I do hope I could feel comfortable to trust her friendship once we’d got over that initial hurdle. If not, at least the question mark of ‘what the heck has happened? Was it something I said?’ has been removed from my head so I can go off and ruminate about something else! 😅

DyslexicPoster · 09/01/2024 12:27

@Username123343 I'm glad you got closure and I hope your meet up goes well. I hope you don't get hurt again either. I thought I really wanted to be friends with my friend again, but once we finally met up in person. I just really didn't feel the same way any more which was sad. But overall for the best.

Username123343 · 09/01/2024 19:22

@DyslexicPoster Thank you 😊

Infusedwithchamomileandmint · 09/01/2024 19:30

Leolly · 08/01/2024 18:38

Thanks so much for the replies and suggestions. Just want to reiterate that I don't spend much time at all thinking about it now - I do occasionally wonder though when I see her name on the rota where we volunteer or on the associated WhatsApp groups. It's only because I found out this morning that she's done something similar to someone else that I started wondering again.

She is divorced and did have a long term partner but in the time I knew her she ended that relationship. I think I would describe her as a complex character - she had a difficult childhood not dissimilar to mine, so I felt that we had a lot in common.

Hmmm this makes me think she might be reevaluating her friendships as part of therapy ?

Once I started therapy I realised that not all my relationships were healthy and so gently moved on.
Currently there is a very odd women at my gym who I was vaguely friendly with she then started to ask me extremely intrusive questions and pick me apart.
CBA so it's head down and avoid!

I really do think it's very self harming to chase after someone
Let them go

Doublebubblegum · 09/01/2024 19:54

It's definitely her, and not you.

My SIL (brother's wife) is like this. Now in her 50s, she has fallen out with her side of the family (siblings, cousins, nieces and nephews) and no longer speaks to any of them. She also goes through periods of having quite close friendships that inevitably end in some sort of falling out. Every person she invited to her and my brother's wedding 15 years ago, she no longer speaks to.

She's a perfectly pleasant person to chat to - a bit eccentric but friendly, smiley and nice. But she is totally incapable of holding down friendships and it's never really clear what causes these fall outs but she is absolutely resolute in her decision to cut people out. I know she had a difficult upbringing so can only assume it all links back to that in some way (although maybe it doesn't, who knows).

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread