Question about classical music

[UsingChangeofName]

Why isn't it the done thing, to applaud the performers in between movements ?

I had to go to a classical concert recently and it seemed a shame that the orchestra didn't get more applause, when there was clearly a natural break, time for them to shuffle and the audience to wriggle, but no-one is allowed to show their appreciation.

It is considered one whole piece. Like a story with chapters. It's unfinished.

Also you risk breaking the musicians' concentration by applauding in the wrong place. They will be waiting for the cue from the conductor to commence the next movement.

Thank you for your reply.

However, if I go to the theatre, the play (or musical) is one complete story, but you still applaud at the very least, at the interval, but, in the case of a musical, usually after each song.

Because what happens between movements isn't an interval.

OK you of course do not have to accept any explanation offered and are free to continue being perplexed that the practice of applauding mid-movement isn't common. HTH

In my opinion it depends on where you go.

I went to an outdoor opera in Verona one summer and was austounded - the audience whistled, stamped their feet, shouted Brava, Bravo, Bravi at various points during the performance.

The conductor noticed a particularly racus applause after a duet in the middle of an act and turned to the audience and asked if they wanted it again.

It was AMAZING and felt like the proper way to appreciate the wild emotional ride of an opera. 😁

Bit of an odd response @AmbleInAnnBoleyn

I know it doesn't happen, I was just wondering if anyone could explain, historically, why it doesn't happen. Not sure why you feel the need to be snarky.

@chocolatebunnybop 's reply makes absolute sense, but I am just having a late night ponder as to why - in one form of the 'music telling a story' it is okay to show your appreciation after a great song or even dance to a piece of music (musicals), yet in a symphony, it would be considered really bad form. Just wondering if anyone knew the reason for the difference, beyond "that is what is the done thing".

That's interesting @IamSTARVING