Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

9 year old, 7 year old and a newborn? Can anyone tell me how this age gap would be please?

47 replies

ItalyBound · 21/03/2023 16:59

I have a 9 and a 6 (nearly 7 year old). I’m considering trying for another baby and would love to hear from others who have similar age gaps. What’s it like? What are the relationships like between the older children and their younger sibling? Is it hard to entertain all children/plan family days out etc?

Thanks :)

OP posts:
Forever42 · 21/03/2023 19:22

Not quite the same but my DSS was 10 when my eldest DC was born. It was always tricky to manage things to do altogether. Also, now my own DC have reached the teen/pre-teem years there are a lot of emotional issues that I personally would have found harder to deal with if I had a toddler to contend with too.

LadyCassandra · 21/03/2023 19:27

DS1 was 9.5 and DS2 was 6 when DD was born. It was great, DS1 and her adore each other and he was unbelievably helpful in the early days. DS2 and DD get on we’ll too.
It’s extended the hard bits but also the fun bits. At Christmas the boys (now 14 and 10) would probably have not got too excited but they were with her around.
Days out and holidays are slightly difficult trying to please everyone, but it does work.

NewtoHolland · 21/03/2023 19:29

I have 8, 4 and a suprise baby. Obviously it's a big thing making the bigger ones feel seen too. I think you make the gap work because you need to. Babies can tag along, but also still making time for 1:1 time with the elder ones when you can. Making them feel involved in the care of the baby and part of the team. Making sure they each know they still have their space in your heart, nuturing their bonds too. I think whatever gap you have you can have difficulties in sibling relationships. Personally for me I liked a bit of a gap.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

csla · 21/03/2023 19:39

mine were 8 and 5 (nearly 6) when DD3 arrived. She's now 3. They adored her and still do. Personally I find larger gaps easier as you can deal with one set of issues at a time (eldest is now nearly 13) Family holidays haven't been a problem as we tend to go away with extended family so other nieces and nephews or all inclusive so there's things for everyone to do. There can be some logistical issues in pleasing everyone and occasionally we'll take one or two each but it's not a major issue and they enjoy having that time. Any cons have been outweighed by the benefits of another sibling, the older two both say they're glad dd3 came along .

JudesBiggestFan · 21/03/2023 19:53

Sad to read the negativity on here. My children were 9 and 6 when their little brother arrived. They have always adored him, never resented him. They're 14, 11 and 5 now and so close...sometimes I find the youngest snuggled up in bed with the eldest, working on Minecraft creations together. Earlier tonight my middle one was teaching my youngest press ups, giggling g uncontrollably together. They all go out and play football together...it's lovely to see the older ones coach the baby together. They have a different relationship with him because it's not at all competitive...sometimes it's like he has four parents not two! I actually worried a lot before we had him what we might be taking from the older two, but they've only gained. It might be that they're all boys? But they're genuinely the best of friends. My husband and I with really hard to make sure they all do clubs, have play dates and have lots of time with us, but for us it's been a great age gap.

FlyingPandas · 21/03/2023 20:29

I had 8.5, 3 and newborn. I would never have planned those age gaps but we had fertility issues and had always wanted three.

There has never been any jealousy with ours, DC1 tends to do his own thing and not spend much time with the younger two but I can never work out how much of that is the age gap, how much individual personalities and how much is impacted by his autism. Younger two are really close.

The baby stage with DC3 was fine. It got a lot harder once he was a toddler and eldest was a preteen. Probably at its absolute hardest when they were 14, 7 and 3. Got easier once DC3 was at school and has continued to get easier ever since.

It is undeniably hard juggling the very different needs and stages and I do feel that at times DC1 missed out because, as others have said, we often had to plan activities based on what the youngest could do. But there was never any major resentment - we just had to divide and conquer a lot, DH with one, me with the other two.

Positives: you are so much more relaxed with DC3 because you're so experienced. I always felt that the baby days were like being a first time mum with loads of time with the baby (because older ones were at school/preschool) but none of the stress. I can genuinely say that I have enjoyed the early days with all three of mine because I was never frantically juggling tiny babies and very young toddlers. I love the dynamics of having three, even though you do realise that the world is set up for families with only two! Both DC1 and DC2 have matured into sensible considerate teens and I'm sure that is partly because they both had the experience of being older brothers, whilst DC3 has definitely benefited from having those older brothers, too.

Negatives - there are definite moments of weariness at going through each educational stage again, third time round (can vividly remember thinking "Christ, I can't believe I'm still on fucking 'Big Cat'!" when trying to simultaneously do early reading practice with DC3 and help DC1 with an essay on Macbeth). I can only imagine how over it I'm going to be when poor DC3 is into the GCSE/A level/UCAS years, having done it all twice before...

That said, though, a surprising positive when you have big age gaps is never really feeling sad and nostalgic at leaving certain stages behind - mainly because you've been doing them for so bloody long that you're delighted to finally ditch them (i.e. I read a bedtime story every night for 16 years and God, the absolute JOY of not having to do that now DC3 is 10 is indescribable. Whereas I have friends with classic '2 with a 2 year age gap' family who still kind of mourn that loss. No mourning going on here, I was delighted, I can tell you Grin).

Overall having three with larger gaps is far more positive than negative but I would caution anyone against having a third child because they're keen to experience the baby days again. You have to want to have three children, three teenagers, three actual PEOPLE to parent in your family. The baby days are gone in the blink of an eye!

Robin233 · 21/03/2023 20:51

I had this - sort of.
Step son we're 10 and 9 when baby brother arrive.
They were both really great with him.
He's late 20's now and they are all very close even though they live many miles apart.
Definitely go for it.

ForYouManImADoomBoy · 21/03/2023 20:56

my older brothers were 9 and 7 when i was born and im very close to my oldest brother. i get on fine with the next brother but the oldest is the one i have the biggest bond with. possibly because i was born just before his birthday and he said i was the best birthday present

NewNormalLife · 21/03/2023 21:22

my friend had two siblings 5 and 7 years older than her. the older ones resent how she was spoiled as the family had less money when they were young and all time and money went on her - presumably as others have said because the parents catered to her activity needs at the weekends over the older children. the oldest had left school when she started and she was like an only child from about age 12. she still doesn't have a good relationship with them.

CountingMareep · 21/03/2023 22:36

I’m the youngest in this sort of age arrangement. Love my DBs to bits but being the only girl as well, I spent a lot of my teens feeling like an only child. It’s also hard when you’re the youngest to develop your independence and ‘grow up’, because no one believes you’re not just the kid sister any more. 😂

It’s also not a combination that works well for activities like hiking. Little me was always frantically scrambling to keep up with DF and DBs.

Oh, and board games were a dead loss with that sort of age gap, being designed for 2-4 players at the same sort of level. Might have been just us though I did enjoy beating DBs hollow at Scrabble.

SuperBored · 21/03/2023 22:54

I don't have this age gap with my dc but come from a family that has a similar age gap. I didn't feel like my mum was there for me after the baby arrived and probably only resurrected my relationship with her in my twenties.

My DC attend various clubs as they are getting older and need taking here there and everywhere in the evening/weekends and I know some of the mums who have a big age gap struggle with this as it interferes with the babies bedtime/naps and I have seen the older ones miss out as a result.

RampantIvy · 22/03/2023 06:54

Some good points raised by @FlyingPandas. One of my friends has 4 children, and by the 4th child she was so done with playgroups and soft play that she hardly took her to any. She says she felt guilty that her last child missed out.

Remmy123 · 22/03/2023 08:15

i have similar ages but eldest two are now teens and I am still restricted looking after a 5 year old - he is like an only child as older two do their own thing!

CurlyWurly1991 · 09/03/2024 22:08

@ItalyBound old thread but I wondered what you decided in the end? TTC and we would have an 11 year gap if successful…

LorlieS · 09/03/2024 22:13

@CurlyWurly1991 My kids are 16, 13 and 3. All planned, third with second husband (his first and last!)
I find on days out/holidays the two boys are happy to go off and do their own thing and meet us at intervals throughout.
Love my crazy crew! ❤️

BertieBotts · 09/03/2024 22:32

I have 15, 5, 2.

It is lovely going back to the start again. Feels like such a privilege to get to relive that stage again. I do feel like it improved my relationship with eldest too by reminding me of him at that age.

OTOH it is tricky dealing with preteen/teen stuff when you're knackered from dealing with (a) little one(s) all day and/or not much sleep. The younger one needs you all day, and then the teens come out of the woodwork in the evening and want to talk about stuff or connect and my brain is mush. It's OK if you're prepared for that double end thing. I think it can cause resentment if you push the older one(s) aside for a little one.

I also found it tricky to do much reminding/cajoling for homework etc because the time for that was right around the little ones' bedtime so I was occupied. But if you're happy to do homework after school then you could potentially combine homework + little kid dinnertime, with adults'/bigger kids dinner after LOs in bed, or do kids' dinner, then homework, then the older ones get free time while you put the little one(s) to bed.

10 years was a good gap in a way because we could cart a baby/toddler around to all kinds of stuff and he didn't care, he was quite happy. Then by the time the middle one was starting to become a bit of a pain at the teenage stuff, he was a bit more able to get himself around to things anyway or stay at home if he didn't fancy a little-kid-thing so that was fine. You won't have that aspect as much with a younger one too (but they might be able to stay at home together if you're happy with that).

Mummyme87 · 09/03/2024 22:40

I’ve got 9.5, 6 and 9week. So far they love their baby brother.
there is no right and wrong way to this. It will have its challenges

LorlieS · 09/03/2024 22:47

@BertieBotts Similar gaps! Try my absolute best to give quality time to all three (as well as working). Do you work too?

CurlyWurly1991 · 10/03/2024 08:13

@LorlieS@BertieBotts@Mummyme87 thank you for sharing your experiences. I worry about it as the gap gets bigger - we have been TTC almost a year with a missed miscarriage along the way. In some respects I think it could be easier as I have done it before and am more financially settled with flexible work etc. On the other hand being older and having the preteen daughter to think about will make it more complex.

@BertieBotts very helpful to hear your thoughts about logistics around things like homework and emotional needs. At 10 my daughter does of course need me emotionally with friend stuff etc and I imagine this will just ramp up as she goes through her teens. Like any parent planning a sibling of course you want to make time for the other child(ren). So like for example while I exclusively breastfed my daughter maybe trying to introduce bottles etc with any new baby so that I can get away and give her some 1:1 time.

One of the things I read (and upthread) is just how challenging days out and holidays can be with this sort of age gap. I am also thinking about things like bedtime, a newborn waking in the night and disturbing sleep of a preteen/young teen. I guess it’s just like any new baby in the house really, just thinking about how everyone needs to adapt and what practical things can be changed to make it work best.

BertieBotts · 12/03/2024 15:44

Currently no but I do struggle with ADHD which makes the basics hard enough! I would like to work but when I have I've just been even more exhausted. I will try again over the next year or two as am more stable on medication now.

We haven't found days out/holidays to be too much of an issue because before about age 3 the little one(s) can tag along with anything really and then once the younger ones need entertainment of their own, a 13yo is fine to stay at home on their own if they don't fancy it or sometimes, conversely they secretly love that excuse to run around a soft play area, farm park, swimming pool etc.

GlitterBall91 · 12/03/2024 15:48

I have a 6 year old and a baby and it’s lovely

Chipsahoy · 12/03/2024 20:11

Well we are 6 years in and loving it. Eldest two are teens now. We are outdoorsy so tend to do activities that suit all.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page