Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Morbid topic, sorry, posting for traffic, would anyone proofread a eulogy for an individual with special needs?

24 replies

princessDGAF · 11/01/2023 13:09

Would anybody mind reading a eulogy for a person with special needs?
My concerns are it might not be personal enough, is perhaps too focused on disabilty, too morbid and that the bit about being a carer is making it more about us? is there something i should add/remove?
Opinions/feedback would be appreciated, I just want it to be right, she deserves the best, but obviously my heads a mess and i dont want to read it back after and have regrets we didnt do her justice iykwim.
Aged late 50s, natural causes, learning difficulties from birth.
Thanks x

I'd like to say Julie would be so happy to see so many of you here today but honestly, she'd probably just be annoyed at missing, what she used to call, the 'after party'.

There's a quote by Anna Anderson which I think is apt for today.
She said, "The idea is to die young, but as late as possible." Julie could have lived to be 200 and today would have still come too soon.
Her child-like innocence, her absolute adoration for life, her complete dedication to being a full time messer.

She could act the aul granny when she wanted - woe betide you if you didnt get her socks laid out in the right order and she was forever grumbling about 'noisy silly kids' outside.
But, her special needs meant she was truly a child at heart and always our baby no matter how old she got.

We're taught that people shouldnt be defined by their disabilities and thats true of course, but in reality, Julie was somewhat defined by them.

Many of us are blessed with abilities and burdened with ingratitude - we have good health but take it for granted. We can walk but we don’t know which way to go. We have arms but we dont always reach out.
We have voices but we dont say the right thing.
Not so for Julie.
Sure, there were things she couldnt do, but the things she could do? She could smile, she could laugh, she could feel unbridled happiness. She could love without condition and she could show her love without ever saying a word. She could express herself with a look, a grin, a squeeze, and to those in her inner circle, even an insult!
She found joy in the simplest of things - a walk, an ice cream cone, a puzzle book or bus ride.
In reality, Julies disabilities gave her abilities most of us can only dream of.

And of course taking care of Julie was tough at times.
Taking care of anyone with special needs is not easy - it takes hard work, it takes complete dedication, it takes its toll.
But, as more than a few of you here will know, it gives far far more than it takes.

Julie gave us the drive to work harder by overcoming her own challenges every day.
She taught us about strength and perseverance by battling her every limitation.
She gave us perspective by reminding us, when we too often forgot, to savour the sweet, beautiful moments in every day.
She gave us kindness, patience, a depth of love required to nurture another so completely.
Through her vulnerabilities, she made us see what we ourselves were capable of, how strong we could be, she showed us parts of ourselves that we might otherwise have never known.

Imagine there is a day when you have big plans but you get up in the morning and it’s Ireland so its raining. The sky is dark and gloomy - why did it have to rain today, you ask. It's not what was supposed to happen.
But, the longer you look, the more beauty you find in it all. When you look out at the rain, you may see puddles and storm clouds, you may see grey skies and raindrops.
But eventually you will see how the rain nourishes the earth, how it settles the seeds and gives them roots so they can grow. You see how the water flows from the sky to the earth to the sea and back again to the sky in a great cycle that never ends. You look up to the heavens and you see the rainbow and you remember that it is only because you endured a storm that you get to see such beauty.

Through the darkness, through the adversity, through the challenges, it shines through, filled with colour and light.
For all the ways Julie taught us about life, for all the ways she inspired us to be better, and for all the love she gave while she was here - remember when skies are grey, to look past the clouds and see the rainbow.

OP posts:
Shekissedagirlandshelikedit · 11/01/2023 13:27

Oh op that brought a tear to my eye. It's perfect. Julie was obviously a beautiful person who brought so much love and joy into your life and your words really reflect that. So sorry for your loss 💐

ItsRainingPens · 11/01/2023 13:31

Well, I think it's absolutely perfect. Beautifully and sensitively written.
Sorry for your loss

Thereisnolight · 11/01/2023 13:33

It is lovely and you clearly cared about her and were very fond of her.
Perhaps it doesn’t give a sense of who you were to her. Family? Friend? Who were her family and was there anyone eg a parent who truly loved her and deserves to be mentioned?

baublingon · 11/01/2023 13:34

I think it's lovely and very moving, but I can understand your concerns. (I always hope that if someone gave a eulogy about me, it wouldn't come with caveats and qualifiers (I always imagine them saying 'Despite her stubbornness/prickliness/neuroses/ to sulk very nice" 😂).)

In your situation, I imagine it's not straightforward and there are lots of complex feelings. But these are the bits I would change:

But, her special needs meant she was truly a child at heart and always our baby no matter how old she got -->

But she was truly a child at heart and always our baby no matter how old she got.

(I don't think it's necessary to mention the special needs here - it's addressed immediately after and presumably everyone will be aware anyway).

I'm also not sure about this paragraph, because of the emphasis on how hard it was for you:

And of course taking care of Julie was tough at times.
Taking care of anyone with special needs is not easy - it takes hard work, it takes complete dedication, it takes its toll.
But, as more than a few of you here will know, it gives far far more than it takes.

Could you simplify it a bit? Maybe something like:

Looking after Julie wasn't always easy, but it gave us far more than it took.

CharlotteFlax · 11/01/2023 13:34

That's a lovely eulogy and makes me want to have met Julie. You've done a great job.

baublingon · 11/01/2023 13:35

'Despite her stubbornness/prickliness/neuroses/tendency to sulk, she was very nice' - sorry!!

Whataretheodds · 11/01/2023 13:35

This is beautiful. Well-written, personal, heartfelt, and I'm sure will elicit a chuckle from those who knew Julie.

The passage about the impact she had on others is great - eulogies are as much about legacy as they are about the life of the deceased.

Are you readinf it yourself? If so, make sure you read at a relaxed pace, give yourself time to breathe, and for the congregation to laugh at your jokes and nod in remembrance.

Good luck and sorry for your loss.

SomethingLessIdentifiable · 11/01/2023 13:37

I wouldn’t change a thing, it’s lovely.

Gawdimold · 11/01/2023 13:38

I prefer the wording additional needs rather than special but it’s a beautiful eulogy

Whataretheodds · 11/01/2023 13:38

@baublingon I respectfully disagree! The best eulogies Ive heard acknowledge the times the deceased was unreasonable/infuriating/precious.

And the sentiment of what OP got from caring for Julie is clear - don't water it down.

justgettingthroughtheday · 11/01/2023 13:38

baublingon · 11/01/2023 13:34

I think it's lovely and very moving, but I can understand your concerns. (I always hope that if someone gave a eulogy about me, it wouldn't come with caveats and qualifiers (I always imagine them saying 'Despite her stubbornness/prickliness/neuroses/ to sulk very nice" 😂).)

In your situation, I imagine it's not straightforward and there are lots of complex feelings. But these are the bits I would change:

But, her special needs meant she was truly a child at heart and always our baby no matter how old she got -->

But she was truly a child at heart and always our baby no matter how old she got.

(I don't think it's necessary to mention the special needs here - it's addressed immediately after and presumably everyone will be aware anyway).

I'm also not sure about this paragraph, because of the emphasis on how hard it was for you:

And of course taking care of Julie was tough at times.
Taking care of anyone with special needs is not easy - it takes hard work, it takes complete dedication, it takes its toll.
But, as more than a few of you here will know, it gives far far more than it takes.

Could you simplify it a bit? Maybe something like:

Looking after Julie wasn't always easy, but it gave us far more than it took.

I agree with this.

It's a beautiful eulogy

I'm sorry for your loss

SomeoneSomewhere21 · 11/01/2023 13:39

I think that’s a beautiful honest heartfelt eulogy. Sorry for your loss OP. 💐

AlwaysGinPlease · 11/01/2023 13:42

It's beautifully written and I cried reading it. I am sorry for your loss OP 💐

bloodywhitecat · 11/01/2023 13:43

But, her special needs meant she was truly a child at heart and always our baby no matter how old she got -->

This is the bit I would change too, I think the reference to her special needs is not needed as those who knew her, knew. "But, Julie was truly a child at heart and always our baby no matter how old she got.." puts her at the front and not her disability.

MoreTeaLessCoffee · 11/01/2023 13:44

I think it's lovely, and I really got a sense of her. In addition to what @baublingon said above I'd take out this part:

"We're taught that people shouldnt be defined by their disabilities and thats true of course, but in reality, Julie was somewhat defined by them."

Partly because I think it's unnecessary because you go on to talk about how her disabilities affected her, but also I think nowadays many disabled people (learning disabled and non-learning disabled) reject the idea that they are not defined by their disabilities. It's an old-fashioned idea - a bit like when people say "I don't see colour" about race.

But overall, just right.

Kentlassie · 11/01/2023 13:49

Agree with @bloodywhitecat’s comment. Apart from that it reads beautifully. DH did the eulogy for dd who had many additional needs, and getting the balance right is tough, but you’ve done a great job. Sorry for you loss, Julie sounds wonderful.

parietal · 11/01/2023 13:51

In the eulogy for my dad, we made sure to mention all the people and places there were important to him. Also because that gives the listeners a personal mention.

So maybe add how much she loved lunches with auntie Mary or trips with the group from mencap or playing with nephews or whatever. Mention all the people who were part of her life.

Mamoun · 11/01/2023 14:02

I think it is absolutely lovely and wouldn't change what you are saying about her needs. She had special/ additional needs. Saying it isn't a slur and I see no reason why it shouldn't be explicitly mentionned.

If there were other people caring for her I would nod at them somehow in the eulogy.

FlowersFlowers

princessDGAF · 11/01/2023 15:11

Thank you so much fellow mumsnetters. We come here for chat and gossip and advice so for you to read this and take the time to respond, with no benefit to you other than being made a bit depressed this afternoon, (!) I really do appreciate it.
The comments have been very helpful and exactly the kind of feedback I was looking for; I've tweaked the parts mentioned and added more of her relationships with family, friends and carers.

There is obviously so much in our heads right now, feeling reassured that I am getting the eulogy right/appropriate for Julie has given me a great sense of relief and comfort in a very difficult time. Thank YOU all for that.

OP posts:
Prinzesa · 12/01/2023 17:09

💔

SomethingNastyInTheBallPool · 12/01/2023 21:32

I’m so sorry for your loss. A beautiful eulogy for very special person. xxx

Just2MoreSeasons · 12/01/2023 21:37

I think it's a wonderful eulogy and very loving. RIP Julie x

sunshinealwayscomesback · 12/01/2023 21:45

It's beautiful. What a lovely, lovely testament to someone who clearly meant the world to you.

2018SoFarSoGreat · 12/01/2023 22:57

I think it's beautiful and so full of love. I would remove the 'special needs' as it is not needed, but that's all.

So sorry for your loss 💐

New posts on this thread. Refresh page