Not comparable at all.
3 types of meds, 2 types will work almost immediately, there’s no weaning off period if they need to be changed. It’s actually some of the most basic medication available.
A more appropriate example is this.
My niece has a form of muscular dystrophy. So she uses lifts to get to the next floor. In theory, technically, she could use the stairs.
If she made it to the top, it would have taken her around 30 mins, caused physical pain and mental distress.
The most likely scenario is that she falls, and a fall almost certainly results in a nasty break of one of her leg/foot bones, and numerous other injuries.
So, does my brother say “Use the stairs, because in theory, you can, even though it’s harder” or does he say “Don’t be daft, of course you use the lift.” ?
Don’t make a child’s life harder when there’s no good reason to. Don’t fuck with their physical or mental well-being, their sense of self, their future.
The prevalence of severe MH issues in women with undiagnosed untreated ADHD is well documented. This child has a Dx and therefore should be trying medications under medical supervision.