I've never been AI, but I do understand what people say and that the 'easy' factor is worth a lot when you only have 2 weeks away in a year.
Yes, in lots of ways AI is the lazy option, but why not if its your holiday. There's no merit in suffering and no points for doing worthy stuff if it's not what you enjoy.
I get that turning up and finding everything is there for everyone is very liberating....good, activities and stuff to keep everyone happy. An actually, keeping everyone of a variety of ages happy isn't always easy. Yes it's expensive and you are paying for convenience etc, but for lots of people it's worth it.
As a very small drinker and someone who doesn't actually eat that much either or want to constantly pick, I feel it's not good value for me personally, but I think it would be worth trying once.
I've been the typical person against things like Disneyland and most things that aren't basic self catering, but having tried DIsneyLand Paris for 4 days in one of their hotels, I was surprised at how much I enjoyed it. AI is enjoyed by so many, I suspect I'd enjoy it too. It doesn't have to be either camping in a basic field, or self catering in basic cottage or full scale AI. I Could probably enjoy all of them.
Perhaps we should try it before the kids don't want to come on holiday anymore with us, I'm sure they'd like it. And there is certainly some truth that when the kids are having a ball, everyone enjoys themselves...and that applies to all ages.
With older teens now, I feel the years if family holidays aren't endless. I think I need to push myself to spend bigger and not worry about it, because there aren't endless years to get to try these things.