Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

How does my relationship with my parents sound to you?

23 replies

Unsuredaughter · 16/07/2021 09:45

So it's probably going to be a long one.

My whole life I have felt like my parents prefer my sister. My mum in particular.

My mum is a very strong character. ALL my life she has been loving yet with a very strong personality. For example if I liked something as a child, which she didn't she would rather harshly tell me so, for example. She criticises others heavily. She criticises my Dad and he has always put up with it. She almost prides herself on her temper. I often feel she looks down her nose at me for not being as much of a snob as her. I send my kids to state school whereas she wouldn't have wanted to do that....she looks down at people, their homes, etc whereas she actually lives in a part of the country where your money goes much further. Therefore, in her eyes we own a "very ordinary" home but in reality it costs us an awful lot.

I was born healthily and straightforwardly after a previous stillbirth. My sister came after me and with life threatening prematurity. She made it through. I think she has always been preferred. I have often squared it away as her being the one who overcame severe health issues and just extreme relief on my parents part.

My sister was slimmer and pretty all through childhood and adulthood. I was chubby from about 7-12 and felt desperately unhappy. At about 14 I developed anorexia and has a sketchy few years with that. I think looks are very important to my mum, particularly how her girls looked. She almost saw it as a compliment if men leered at us on holiday when we were teens, it confirmed us as beautiful to her. My mum used to tell us about how slim she was when she was younger. She kept some of her clothes, we didn't really bother wearing them though and I think she liked that they were a little tight on us. No wonder I was messed up. She always told me how my sister had low self esteem. I think I must have done too. She's tell me off for not putting lipstick on, as it made me look "better".

Other issues that happened in my teens.....my sister ran away. When she eventually came home they bought her a brand new convertible car. I couldn't believe it. They had bought me one too which used to make me feel so embarrassed. I'd rather have had a bit of an old banger....but I had also been so trouble free. I was upset my sister had caused so much trouble over the years and still be treated the same way as me. In fairness they have always been financially generous during our teens and childhood. Private school, pets, ponies,es, cars-I guess looking back, all outward show, partly for other perhaps? That stopped after University. I haven't had any money from them since then and I feel more comfortable about that.

Never the less, years have gone by. I have two children my sister has recently had a baby. My parents look after my sisters baby two days a week and it seems to be a long term, permanent thing. They have never done anything like that for me. They can't really because I live further away so it wouldn't be possible. However I feel quite hurt. I can't believe they are doing this for her and not me but most of all, I wish they'd just acknowledge it to me. Well my Mum acknowledge it really...she rules the roost. My father is just a grumpy old man who lets himself get bossed around.

I have always felt my mum has a preference for girls. I have two boys and yes, surprise surprise...my sister has a girl. When we found out my no.2 was a boy, she said "oh....it's another boy" and she had been looking at baby girl clothes, saying to my sister how nice it would be for me to have a girl. She has odd, two dimensional ideas around boys a lot of the time. I'd like to point out that I love my two boys, haven't madly craved a girl and just find myself enjoying my amazing sons as people. I think she views me with some pity.

My sister has tended to change jobs every three years or so. Within this time my mum starts to refer to all her colleagues by name and gets to know all the dynamics of the office etc. We have to sit enraptured listening to tales of her job and follow all the office politics.

She barely knows the ins and outs of my work, (my sisters job is much more similar to the area my mum worked in) and when I do talk about my work (which is rare) I get shut down quickly and doesn't seem to want to entertain it in the glowing way she does with my sister.

There is so much more to it than this, as there always is with families, but these are some examples I could think of this morning.

Does it sound like my sister is the favourite?
How should I deal with her behaviour? I do love her but not in the way I used to. I feel like I am the adult now, who needs to deal with her a little like she is a boundary-less toddler. She won't change but I can.

There really won't be any point in talking to her about any of it.

OP posts:
2ndtimemum2 · 16/07/2021 09:57

I actually dont get a sense of favoritism from your post op I get a sense of jealousy of your sister. It sounds like your mum was all about appearance and trying to buy your love.

If talking to your mum would be pointless maybe putting some distance between you would be good? It might also be a good idea to build a better relationship with your sister independently of you mum

Cloudninenine · 16/07/2021 10:03

I feel you’re a little unfair about the childcare - if your mum can’t provide it for you because of distance, she’s not being unfair by helping you sister and not you. It’s just a consequence of your practical circumstances.

In respect of the other stuff, however, it does sound like you get a raw deal. It sounds like your mum has never got over the need to baby your sister after her difficult start. You don’t mention any other living siblings so I assume she’s the youngest as well as having been so ill. Both of those probably contributed to your mum feeling like she needed babying, and then it became a habit she didn’t move on from.

You sound quite mature about it tbh - you should be proud of that. As you say, you can’t change her behaviour so you have to accept it, but it’s hard. The reality is our parents are flawed, messy individuals who get things wrong and don’t know how to see their own faults. Your mother clearly loves you in her way, she’s just bad at expressing it and being fair to both of you.

There’s a quote I’ve read about how life is easier if you learn to accept an apology you never received. It sounds a bit trite, but I think it can be helpful to make a conscious effort to treat your relationship as having had the benefit of an apology from your mum, and try to move on as if in light of that. It requires a lot of grace from you, but it’s a habit you can practice. It might be worth trying to see if your life feels better for it Flowers

Horehound · 16/07/2021 10:11

I don't get a sense of unfairness either op.
You seem to be acknowledging they wouldn't be able to do childcare for you yet are so hurt and "can't believe" they'd do it for your sister...why?! It's normal.
It sounds like they treated you very fairly with regards to stuff bought/opportunities in your childhood.

Your mum sounds shallow.
I don't know why there's a big deal about your sister getting a car when you also for a car? Just because she ran away you think she shouldn't have a car? Maybe that was something your parents thought would make her happy?

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

Horehound · 16/07/2021 10:13

I agree with pp..you sound jealous of your sister.

It sounds like your sister and mum have more in common. It's not a big deal really about the work stuff although I do think it's a bit shit they don't listen about your work but I expect it's more about her/them not understanding it.
My granny always talks about my aunt's work but doesn't have a clue what my dad did (recently retired) and it was like she just didn't have the capacity to even try and understand it.

Unsuredaughter · 16/07/2021 10:43

Maybe I am jealous. I will need to reflect on that. Yes I think I might because she is treated more favorably by my parents. Yes, in some ways my Mum and sister do have a lot more in common. So that might be it, the love is the same but the enjoyment of each others company is different perhaps?

Regarding the childcare, I see that as £100 p/w my sister is saving by having my parents look after her child. So essentially a lot of both financial and childcare help. My parents always seemed anti being weekly child care grandparents, but now they are doing it for my sister.

OP posts:
Unsuredaughter · 16/07/2021 10:46

@cloudninenine thank you for your idea of an apology that you never received. I am really going to try this.

OP posts:
Unsuredaughter · 16/07/2021 10:52

Really interesting that everyone has picked up on a sense of jealousy.

I really am going to have to examine that within myself

I suppose when she ran away it was all tied up in drugs, challenging behaviour etc etc. I felt I had been the good girl and not caused any issues, worked hard and then there were no sort of consequences. I just came home from work.one day to find they'd gone out and seemingly rewarded her for the months of shit we had been thru. I was the one who found her 'note' to tell us she had run away and I felt the bottom fall from my stomach, I can remember it so clearly. I was devastated and frightened and it affected me a lot. I suppose maybe at the time I needed more support with it. On the outside looking in, it felt like she could do anything she wanted and get whatever she liked and all my efforts were really in vain.

Like I said, I'll have to have a think about that. We are friends, possibly even best friends, but I don't feel I can bring up any of this with her as it would upset her and I don't want to do that.

OP posts:
ahoyshipmates · 16/07/2021 10:58

I don't really think it is conscious and deliberate favouritism from your mum's side. Perhaps it is more to do with you and your sister having different personalities, and maybe she is more like your mum in some ways, so they tend to click. Your sister does sound slightly manipulative though, and likes to get her own way.

You need to spend more time with your dad I reckon.

HoppingPavlova · 16/07/2021 11:00

Regarding the childcare, I see that as £100 p/w my sister is saving by having my parents look after her child. So essentially a lot of both financial and childcare help.

I don’t understand. Are you saying they should either not look after your sisters child, or look after your sisters child and send you 100 p/w as compensation?

I think the childcare piece is absolutely moot as you don’t live near them, childminding is not possible. Your sister does and it is. That’s not an ‘unfair situation’, it’s just logistics and what is practically possible. If you both lived nearby your parents and they babysat for her but refused to do so for you I would understand why you are upset, but the scenario you have they physically can’t do it due yo distance so not sure what you are after there?

bringincrazyback · 16/07/2021 11:03

I'm amazed people aren't seeing favouritism here. I definitely did pick up a sense of favouritism towards the sister.

Unsuredaughter · 16/07/2021 11:08

@HoppingPavlova

I suppose it's my inner child feeling rather put out at the situation!

From what I am reading here, perhaps it is a moot point and I need to work on developing an attitude of neutrality towards it. I'm not a raging ball of fury about it at all, just sometimes it does bother me. I'm only human. I'd love some family help with childcare and I've never had any

OP posts:
CatrinVennastin · 16/07/2021 11:13

Same @bringincrazyback I can see why you think they prefer OP’s sister. It’s very similar to the dynamics in my family only my Dad is the dominant force there.

My sister has gone off the rails several times and has been in massive debt but she can do no wrong in their eyes.

When we were teens I wasn’t allowed to do even mundane things like go to the cinema with friends I had to stay in and study.

From age 14 my sister was out clubbing!

I have had a lot of criticism from them over the years especially when I gave up my job to go freelance and they are very hard to please in general so I just stopped trying to please them and got on with my life.

HoppingPavlova · 16/07/2021 11:15

I'd love some family help with childcare and I've never had any

You can solve this. Move so that you are close to your parents. Your inner child will be appeased. Then it will be logistically possible. Problem solved. If you are not prepared to do this and enact a solution for whatever reason then that’s on you, not your parents or your sister.

Unsuredaughter · 16/07/2021 11:16

One way I can frame the childcare is by flipping it and imagining how it will be when they need us to care for them.

My sister will always be on the doorstep and therefore the first on the scene if anything is needed or goes wrong However I will always make the journey to go and help. I will share the role as much as I possibly can with my sister.

OP posts:
VodselForDinner · 16/07/2021 11:17

OP, life isn’t a rewards system. You don’t get extra points to doing the right thing compared to how you perceive your sister’s actions and behaviour.

From the car incident, my understanding is that you’re older and were gifted a car. Your sister, from your perspective, wasn’t as well behaved as you and was also given a very.
So you wanted her behaviour punished?

I’ve had a life-long issue with eating disorders so I do get it. From reading your opening post, it almost sounds like you’re saying your mother’s attitude caused your aneroxia. Do you think it could be the other way around and your eating disorder meant that your awareness around particular issues (clothes sizes, approval from others on your appearance)?

I don’t get the childcare thing. You make it very clear that you live a distance from your parents so it seems to be a moot point?

I just don’t see huge injustices here.

Unsuredaughter · 16/07/2021 11:21

Thank you for that @HoppingPavlova.

I do realise this but I think the three hr commute for my husband whose job is location specific would be a bit much. Life isn't always black and white and I am entitled to my feelings, however misguided or 'wrong' they are. I was asking for advice so I could gather others opinions and suggestions which may help me reframe my thoughts a little.

Nothing like a bit of light MN bullying to make you reaslise you should never have posted!

OP posts:
staringstepan · 16/07/2021 11:24

Hmm, I'm also sending jealousy here rather than favouritism.

It sounds like you think your sister didn't deserve the car, even though you also got one? It sounds like you want your parents to be angrier with your sister for her childhood issues.

And I don't think you can be cross with your mum for looking after your sisters children if they live close by and you live 3hrs away. Would you prefer your mum to refuse to help your sister so that it's equal?

Unsuredaughter · 16/07/2021 11:25

Really valid points and helpful.....thank you. Yes I do see that perhaps at that age I did see things as a rewards system....I certainly don't now. But I was definitely brought up that way...."be a good girl and you'll get a treat". It obviously lingered into early adult hood and the upset from that is still lodged there.

You are right. There haven't been great injustices. No one in the family is perfect. Perhaps my sister can be a little manipulative, my mum does always say she asks for everything whereas I never asked for anything.

My husband who gets along brilliantly with my family does see the favoritism anf it does bother him sometimes. But, like other have just pointed out....it's not huge. It's not something I dwell on regularly, just sometimes it comes to mind.

OP posts:
Unsuredaughter · 16/07/2021 11:35

No I don't want that @staringstepan.

I guess I get it rubbed in my face a lot over family Whatsapp pics and at the moment we have a bit of a childcare crisis. Which has actually gone relatively unrecognized by my family. So I am feeling sensitive and probably blowing it out of proportion.

OP posts:
Unsuredaughter · 16/07/2021 11:52

Another example of favouritism/my jealousy.

My parents got her into a shared ownership house. They then bought her out of it when she moved into something bigger.

I've not had any help....just sort of got on with it myself.

OP posts:
Horehound · 16/07/2021 11:58

It's worth noting there is nothing actuywrong with feeling jealous! It's a perfectly reasonable feeling and not one of us can avoid it.

I think the thing with childcare and you feeling like you are either due the favour via a monetary thing is wrong. Childcare is childcare and if your parents are happy to do it that's up to them but they certainly don't owe you anything to do with that.
I have a child and my parents look after him one day a week. My brother has no children, I know he wouldn't be expecting some kind of favour on return to make it even.

Was it your decision to move away/not live near them?
I do understand it must be hard to accept the shitty behaviour your sister put you all through to then be rewarded with a car but they mustve thought doing that would help her?
I also understand it is shit to not be seen as Interesting enough to warrant a proper conversations around your job...that is obviously going to make you feel bad.
But no parent is flawless. Of you luck any family each sibling would have some hang up about the parents and likely they'd be different per child and based on their outlook

Maybe you should try some talking therapy? That's always helped me in the past

Horehound · 16/07/2021 12:00

Yes I do see that perhaps at that age I did see things as a rewards system....I certainly don't now.

See I think you do because that's what comes across in the childcare thing where you highlight the cost it is saving your sister.

Horehound · 16/07/2021 12:02

@Unsuredaughter

One way I can frame the childcare is by flipping it and imagining how it will be when they need us to care for them.

My sister will always be on the doorstep and therefore the first on the scene if anything is needed or goes wrong However I will always make the journey to go and help. I will share the role as much as I possibly can with my sister.

So just don't go! Or don't go as much as you would? Because to me that seems like you run for them in the hope they will be better to you
New posts on this thread. Refresh page