Which flooring do you prefer? 2 pics enclosed

[FlamingoAtTheBingo]

So sorry for my messy kitchen first of all! Couldn't be bothered to tidy

Anyway it's between these two for my new karndean floor. Can I ask which you prefer and why? And if neither then please say

We currently have pale grey large tiles which we don't like

Thanks

The 2nd one because the colour of the 1st one looks patchy (not sure how else to describe it sorry!)

Second, the first looks patchy and weird

The first, the colour variations are much more eye catching and will also not be as dark in the room,

The lighter one would go best with your kitchen, but personally I'd go a bit lighter again.

Second! Cleaner look

There's not much difference in colour between the two tbh. As first poster said, the 2nd one is preferable out of the two you've shown, but because it isnt weirdly patchy.
May be worth comparing another that is even in tone, but lighter, so we can compare two distinctly different shades.

I prefer the first. The second looks glum

Second one . The other is too dominant but I'd go lighter unless you have lots of window light.

The first one does look patchy I know but in reality, it isn't so much. (We have quite a few sample 'planks' and it doesn't look like it appears to here!)

We did consider going lighter but our kitchen is so light anyway we wanted some depth. It's also going throughout the whole downstairs - bar the living room

Second, I am not keen on the patchy/burnished look of the first, I’d also think of going lighter as a PP suggested

@pandora206 we have so much light in the room as french doors at other end and loads of light so we wanted a bit of a contrast

I second the 2nd.

2nd one. The 1st is too busy.

The second one

2nd one. The first looks a bit leopard print to my dodgy eyes.

Definitely the second. What is the name of this as it's exactly what I'm looking for.

2nd

How about this one? Wellington oak ..

2nd

I prefer the second

@Shorthairlady it's karndean vangogh range

3rd one - oak

I like third one which you've just posted.

It has more depth than the second but overall it's a lighter effect than the first one, which seems dark and muddy.

2nd one. Not keen on the first.

@teezletangler I think I agree with you. Looks more natural and warmer which is what we are wanting