Rank these chocolate tins from best to worst

[Lelophants]

Roses, Celebrations, Miniature heroes, Quality Street

That's my order btw. According to my DH I am very wrong.

Hotel Chocolat.

Ok. That is totally not the point.

Roses are terrible. Another thing ruined by Cadbury’s.

Quality Street have improved.

I buy the tub of Sainsburys own now. They are as good as any.

@HollyBen

I am surprised no one has got the order correct yet! Clearly it is Heroes Quality Street Roses Celebrations

Agreed, though it's very close between Quality Street and Roses for me

@Lottieskeeper

Usually it would be: Quality Street Rose's Celebrations Heros.

But because of the very special and beautiful Emma Bridgewater tins this year its:
Roses
Roses
Roses
Roses.
In this house

Fair enough, the tin is cute.

But I would rather eat the tin than the palm-oil infested, over-sugared, horribly wrapped chocolates.

@DobbyTheHouseElk

Roses are terrible. Another thing ruined by Cadbury’s.

Quality Street have improved.

I buy the tub of Sainsburys own now. They are as good as any.

Sainsbury's Own M&S Own

V Good.

Heroes are the best by a mile
Followed by Roses, then celebrations, then qs

Heros
Celebrations
Roses
Quality street

I miss Mingles

Heroes then celebrations , not even going to rate the other two !

Quality street toffee pennies and toffee fingers
Heroes
Celebrations
Rest of Quality Street

Roses. (Disgusting now)

Celebrations
Roses
Heroes
QS

Not sure which I prefer out of Roses or QS but they’re 1 and 2.

Celebrations and Heroes are really boring, just buy the actual chocolate bar instead.

heroes, celebrations, roses, quality street

Yes Mingles were great, it’s a pity they stopped them.

Roses are awful and taste like wax, others are all on a par!

Quality st. love the strawberry & orange
Roses
Heroes
Celebrations

Heroes
Quality Street
Celebrations
Roses

Heroes
Roses
Celebrations
Quality street

Heroes
Celebrations
Quality Street
Roses

Heros
Celebrations

Don't know because I don't eat quality street or roses.

Miniature Heroes
Roses
Quality Street
Celebrations

Heroes lovely
Celebrations really nice
Quality Street only toffee ones
Roses urgh

Celebrations
Heroes
Quality Street

Roses (which I just don't buy any more because I'm sure they're made of wax now)

Roses, Miniature Hero’s, Quality street and then Celebrations.

Heros, then the rest in no particular order; I would need to see which had the better tins to differentiate.

Celebrations
Heroes
Roses
Quality Street (not envy)

However if Roses still did the delicious green coffee one they would be at the top of the list. I’m still devastated that it’s gone.