Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Breaking up with someone over this? Am I being too critical?

70 replies

Sunshinelarder · 19/09/2020 09:54

I know any reason is ok to end a relationship if it’s your reason etc etc but I am wanting to know in general if others find this silly or if they would feel the same.

Im with a lovely man. He is great to me, really wants the relationship to progress. In many ways he’s fantastic, patient, understanding, kind. He really does want what’s best for me. But these are the things that bother me..

  1. Now and then I feel a bit patronised. I can’t really explain it but he had an ex gf who worked in the same industry as me and him, but in a small town...i work in a city and without going into detail the job is hugely more competitive in the sector I am in that the sector he and she worked in. He sometimes says she earned x and that her job (he is a manager in her sector) was the best sector to be in etc etc. This is hard to explain without detailing the work but suffice to say that the sector I am in is renowned for being the most competitive in this industry especially in comparison to what his ex did and he does - albeit he is a manager so has done very well. I feel so petty writing this and I never expected him or needed him to think I was some Wonder Woman at work, but it almost feels like he is manipulating me to move away from the city I worked in to live with him and go into a different sector. I also feel frustrated that he sees to have such a narrow minded attitude about this industry that he also works in - he’s never been city based and seemed to have a chip on his shoulder about it, at one point even commenting that the work I did was full of arrogant intellectuals who don’t actually know much. he didn’t include me in this of course.. I was the exception. 🤔
  1. He earns a huge amount of money and nearly always pays when we go out at his election. I mostly drive to his which is an hour or so away so I guess I have all the travel costs (I like being away from the city, he would come to me if I asked). However, when we had an argument from time to time about something unrelated he often says ‘you expect me to pay for everything too!’ This is not true and while he has a lot of money I am quite ok without someone with money and had never and would never expect him to pay - he would always insist and/or be the one wanting to go out. This feels like a nasty thing to say in an argument unrelated to money.
  1. He often says I am quite weird but he has become fond of it. To be fair I probably am a bit weird but I always feel this is a bit of a dig. Maybe I’m too sensitive.
  1. Last week he bought a new rug for downstairs and I took up the original rug to make space and there were two unopened condoms under it. I laughed and said where are these from?! Expecting him to tell me they were there hoping we’d have sex one even on the floor or that it was from ages ago before we met when he was dating...or whatever funny story it was. Instead he got defensive and said he didn’t know why there were there...I pushed it and said oh come on jokingly and he became even more defensive and was adamant he didn’t know why they were there. He’s in constant contact with me (too much sometimes!) and I have never had an inkling that he’s cheating... I’m certain it’s not that but what bothers me is the fact he can’t be honest and laugh about it? Am I being over the top here or would this bother you too? I even said look I’m not angry I think it’s funny but it’s weird you are pretending you don’t know when you live alone in the house!
  1. I suggested we have a weekend apart as it felt very intense over a particular couple of months. He said he would do that if that’s what I wanted but he would lose feelings fast for me because that’s just what he is like, either all in or all out. I get where he is coming from here but it made me feel confused that someone who was so loving and professed to want to be with me and loved me would then say he could just click his feelings off? Again maybe I am being sensitive.
  1. When I asked for a break a while ago he reacted saying he didn’t do breaks and that to him would be a break up... fair enough. He then said if I broke up with him I would regret it and he would move on and wouldn’t wait around. I guess that’s fair enough in many ways but it felt like he was angry at me for suggesting it rather than actual upset if that makes any sense.

He is great to me and I know he wants us to be together and he is very invested in us. In sooo many ways he is a very very lovely family man who adores his parents but not in a strange way ! And is just a decent man who gets on with his work and lives a quiet life and is generally cheerful. I get the sense that if I was as keen as him then he would calm down a bit on these fronts maybe. I can’t put my finger on whether these things I have said are me being very unfair and critical?

OP posts:
Sunshinelarder · 19/09/2020 11:04

Ahh it’s hard though as he is very nice to me, literally whatever I suggest doing he is enthusiastic about. He’s very lovely to my family, always gets a round in and is friendly and caring towards his family. More than any man I’ve met before. He’ll say nice things to me and compliment me. There’s a lot of good stuff.

I just can’t shame these other issues and it makes me feel distant rather than close with him which is is rubbish and ironically not what he must want either! I don’t feel like he truly loves me for me yet at the same time I do believe he loves me. It’s confusing.

He’s never really let me in I don’t think. He cares hugely how things look, not in a materialistic way but a sort of what’s socially acceptable and looks proper sort of way.

OP posts:
Sunshinelarder · 19/09/2020 11:05

*shake not shame!

OP posts:
Okeydokeypiginapokey · 19/09/2020 11:06

Big red flags! You know something isn't right, so get rid. Imagine living with him, you'd become a shell.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

Sunshinelarder · 19/09/2020 11:06

But then sometimes we will have moments in the car where we are signing along to the same music we are into and just really happy to be together. That list is always there though

OP posts:
Sunshinelarder · 19/09/2020 11:09

People saying I will become a shell if I stay or he will take away all my freedom... it’s only fair I say that i am very strong minded, I sat what I think and I will stand up for myself if needed. I wonder if maybe I have caused his insecurity by being like this? I don’t know.

OP posts:
Lardlizard · 19/09/2020 11:10

Yuk you’re spidery senses are right to ditch him
Sounds like he’s envious of you work wise and trying to put you down
Keep you in your place type thing
And as for the insisiting in paying and then complaining
Yuk

Btw everyone whats negging ? Not heard that expression before ?

bitheby · 19/09/2020 11:10

4 and 5 made me exclaim out loud. That doesn't sound normal at all. And even if that's how he is, why would he say it to you? Threat? Relationship on his terms or not at all?

Someone who loved you I don't think would say things like that. It's totally normal to have some time apart.

AllPlayedOut · 19/09/2020 11:11

It doesn't matter how strong you think you are, these men can still fuck with your head and control and manipulate you. It has nothing to do with strength, and he's already having that effect on you. You're already questioning if you are to blame for his actions, and no, you're not. Things will only get worse.

AntiHop · 19/09/2020 11:12

He sounds annoying. I agree with @Shutupyoutartn, trust your instincts.

VickySunshine · 19/09/2020 11:15

Somebody needs to this guy he is over investing in this relationship. Ultimately, if you are going to end it , just do it. Don't let him think he has a furure with you.That is just wrong. He will , of course, want a reason ?.

VickySunshine · 19/09/2020 11:16

needs to tell this guy

VinylDetective · 19/09/2020 11:17

Even if there weren’t any red flags, he sounds far too much like hard work to me. The condoms incident sounds utterly ridiculous.

Sunshinelarder · 19/09/2020 11:23

What annoyed me about the condoms was why he couldn’t just laugh about it ... why did he think I would believe him that he didn’t know why they were there in that place in his own house! It’s just annoying

OP posts:
IWantT0BreakFree · 19/09/2020 11:24

So many red flags. So many.

Particularly the intensity and the refusal to allow you any distance or opportunity to mull things over alone. This is the emotional equivalent of locking you in a bear hug so you literally can't move away from him.

The comments about money, but then insisting that he pays all the time. He wants you to be beholden to him.

The digs about your career which seem like an attempt at negging.

I'd chuck this one back. You don't want to look back in 5 years and wish you'd listened to your gut at the start.

LeahDownTheLane · 19/09/2020 11:25

You say you’re strong minded but he’s already breaking you down. I hope you realise before you can’t get out.

Othering · 19/09/2020 11:25

@AllPlayedOut

It doesn't matter how strong you think you are, these men can still fuck with your head and control and manipulate you. It has nothing to do with strength, and he's already having that effect on you. You're already questioning if you are to blame for his actions, and no, you're not. Things will only get worse.
Couldn't agree more. I'm the strongest, most willful, strong minded, independent woman you could meet and it's happened to me. Never, ever thought or imagined it could or would. Thought I'd be the last person on earth but it did.
LouisBalfour · 19/09/2020 11:29

It sounds like both of you are settling and would be better off apart.

dudsville · 19/09/2020 11:29

Your original post says enough. You're not living together, not under the pressure pod raising children together, this should be easier and more comfortable. Your later posts strongly defend him and the relationship and let us know how much you're torn, but we're all pretty much of a like mind on this - it may be better than you've had before, but it's not a good relationship.

WinterAndRoughWeather · 19/09/2020 11:29

Even if he’s not manipulative or abusive or whatever, he does sound really annoying and no amount of singing in the car is going to change that. You have too many doubts and questions to make this work (even blaming yourself for being “too strong” - come on!).

If it was right, you wouldn’t be here. Don’t waste your time.

WinterAndRoughWeather · 19/09/2020 11:30

Oh and PS don’t imagine he will / can change. He can’t and won’t.

Heffalooomia · 19/09/2020 11:32

He sounds controlling 👀
warning you that he might go off you if you don't constantly dance to his tune.....
Urghh😕

Hoppinggreen · 19/09/2020 11:33

He’s love bombing you. Very carrot and stick
He’s great to you but if you need space he will go off you? He’s conditioning you very slowly to get his own way.
He’s good, I will give him that but not good enough that you can’t spot it if you know what to look for

Heffalooomia · 19/09/2020 11:34

@Sunshinelarder

People saying I will become a shell if I stay or he will take away all my freedom... it’s only fair I say that i am very strong minded, I sat what I think and I will stand up for myself if needed. I wonder if maybe I have caused his insecurity by being like this? I don’t know.
This makes you an interesting challenge...it's more of a 'win' to get in control of and dominate someone who sees themselves as independent and strong minded
CaraDuneRedux · 19/09/2020 11:37

I'm seeing more red flags than a communist party convention here.

Wants to get you to move, and give up a job and career you're bloody good at.

"Negs" you - dismissive about your career, calls you weird.

Controlling.

Nope, no matter how nice he pretends to be, this is not a nice man.

bluebird243 · 19/09/2020 11:37

You can be as strong minded as you like but this awful man is already breaking your barriers down. I don't know how you can attribute kind, patient, cheerful and 'very, very lovely' qualities to someone like this.

Such controlling, demeaning, critical and manipulative behaviour would have me running for the hills in a heartbeat. And I had an exH who cared more about outward appearances to the world than to us and our relationship and our wellbeing and happiness. So I got out before the damage eroded us.

Get out OP, please listen to what everyone is saying, re read your post. There are so many danger signs and no one in a happy healthy relationship would write what you have written. Please be very aware of what is actually going on, and don't kid yourself. You are not being too critical, just seeing the light.

Swipe left for the next trending thread