We have sticky on letters (which don’t get much use), various boats and windy up things that don’t seem to be very well played with. There’s a couple of ducks and squeezy toys and books that also don’t get much use. what do your DC get most play value out of in the bath? I’m running out of ideas. The most played with items are the plastic jug and cups. I’ve looked online and can’t see anything that looks interesting. Any ideas?
We can see this thread is a little old now, but if you’ve landed here looking for recommendations, we’ve recently updated our best bath toys page with lots of great options as rated by parents and their little ones. We hope you find it useful. 
MNHQ