Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

DD (7) and friendships

12 replies

HepburnKNotA · 28/01/2020 11:19

How can I help her?

She had 2 'best' friends, will call them Alice and Bryony.

DD particularly keen on Alice ( less so on Bryony, they squabble quite a bit which is v unusal for DD; she usually just goes along with more dominant characters).

For two whole terms the 3 of them have played only with each other.

I spent a good deal of those 2 terms encouraging her to sometimes play with others that she likes in the class as it was pretty obvious it was getting too intense, especially when squabbles began in their threesome, and I am obv keen for her to keep her friendship group as wide as possible. DD, though, I think has enjoyed the 'security' of knowing she has this tiny group and knowing she always had a ready-made solution for playtimes. She hasn't managed to play with anyone else for 2 whole terms.

Cue the last couple of weeks, quite obviously this was going to happen eventually - Alice has branched out and found a new friend, will call her Carrie.

There was a tiny bit of typical cruelty once (Alice deliberately told my DD she likes Carrie more than her) but that seems to have settled down. But now it's quite clear that Carrie is Alice's first choice to play with at playtimes and she's kind of left DD and Bryony behind.

DD is obviously a bit hurt and bewildered as she thinks of Alice as her best friend - I think she almost feels jilted, bless her!

But what seems to be happening is that DD and Bryony are now playing only the two of them together, narrowing DD's friendship group even more! And they're not massively sympatico in all honesty, there is a LOT of 'storming off' and all that nonsense. Bryony a lovely girl but they rub each other up the wrong way.

Plus there is v much the sense that Alice is picking and choosing when she comes back and plays with her old, now second-choice friends, at which point (sigh) DD will be delighted that Alice has come back and 'chosen' her again.

DD seems incapable, despite my gentle entreaties, of playing with any of the other girls in her class - she just seems locked in to this habit of only playing with Alice (when available) and Bryony, with whom she squabbles a lot.

Last week she came home having ended up sitting by a tree (her words!) several playtimes in a row.

She's an only child; for this reason we do try to work hard on her relationships as she often needs a bit of guidance on how children interact in larger groups.

She now says she doesn't want to go to school as she hates playtimes.

Obviously in one sense it's all a storm in a teacup, she's only 7.

But in the long run I want to help her navigate these issues. She is ALWAYS 'that' child that will wait to be picked up or dropped by someone she really likes. She doesn't have the kind of confidence either to go up and ask to join in with another group, which is probably why she got so locked into this secure and slightly claustrophobic threesome in the first place.

Basically, TELL ME HOW TO HELP HER NAVIGATE GIRLS' FRIENDSHIPS, PLEASE??? I sense I have years of this to come...

OP posts:
Quirrelsotherface · 28/01/2020 11:28

In the nicest possible way, I think you need to relax a little bit. It all sounds very dramatic and if you make a lot of this situation so will your DD.

Could you invite some different friends for tea or a playdate after school so she can widen her friendship net a bit?

HepburnKNotA · 28/01/2020 11:34

Quirrel - no, you're absolutely right, it did all get a bit dramatic this morning which is probably why I'm sounding a bit nuts (re-reading my post!) DD sobbed on the way to school and so I've started the day a bit thrown. Horrible sending her in knowing she's worrying about who to play with :(

We've been doing that (the playdates etc) and she gets on well with lots of others, she just doesn't seem able to turn it into anything in the playground.

But yes, I do recognise it all sounds very dramatic - I'm not normally! This morning really threw me. DD had such a hard time making friends in Reception so today I feel like I'm doomed to forever be worrying about it!

OP posts:
Woollycardi · 28/01/2020 12:27

Do you notice anything similar in how you interact with other women or do you tend to be more dominant? If you are more confident, maybe it's worth really including your DD in your relationships with your friends so she can see you model confidence, self-reliance, self-esteem. If you struggle with this a bit too, it might be worth trying to find out what is going on for you and as you build yourself up you can help your daughter with it too.

Also, this is one area of her day, one part of it that she is struggling with, try and take emphasis off these friendships as although of course they are important, they are not the be all and end all of the day. That's in my opinion anyway. If we focus or hone in too deeply on one area I find that's when I tend to go a bit nuts, or I have that with my kids anyway.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

memberofseven · 28/01/2020 13:25

Your overthinking this. Just arrange more play dates / out of school activities with Alice and other children.

HepburnKNotA · 28/01/2020 13:34

I’m massively over thinking it. A break of a couple of hours and a coffee and I can see that. Was just upset by DD’s (genuine) upset this morning.

Woolly; I’m pretty confident in my relationships with other women... nowadays! I grew up exactly like DD is now, very hesitant in asserting myself within friendships. The difference (an improvement, for her!) is that I was happy enough to just be told what to do and bossed around. DD IS bossed around, but doesn’t really like it! That’s good, she’s probably less passive than I was (not difficult...) but she’s still quite easily controlled.

I will persist with the play dates and the gentle encouragement.

Appreciate the advice and the pointing-out that I was obsessing a bit... genuinely huge thanks. I feel more like myself; it helped to get it out and get it into perspective.

OP posts:
stressbucket1 · 28/01/2020 13:54

My DD is like this. Speak to her teacher and see if the lunch time supervisors can keep an eye on her and make sure she isn't left alone. Does she go to any after school groups? Brownies is good for kids that struggle to join in they do group activities and organised stuff. Maybe see if she can develop some friendships outside of school too.

SeansNiece · 28/01/2020 14:41

Oh OP I have the exact same problem with my DD5. It's heartbreaking to see her upset going into school but I've spoke to the teacher who does also see the issue and she is working on putting her in different groups with similar children who struggle to make friends.
DD isn't my first child but she's the only one who struggled like this so it's all new to me too. I was a confident child who made friends everywhere I went and was very popular but now am a shy adult so feel like if it gives me nerves going somewhere where I have no close friend then I know exactly what DD is going through. I try to fake confidence though so DD sees that you just have to get on with it.

Quirrelsotherface · 28/01/2020 15:51

Hope it gets sorted. Sometimes it is easier said than done to not overthink and I appreciate it is heartbreaking to see your DC so upset Flowers

MustBeDueSomeBetterFeet · 28/01/2020 16:02

I'd set up some playdates with other children (boys or girls) in the class, or having a few over, etc, so she broadens her social circle.

HepburnKNotA · 28/01/2020 16:20

Thanks again everyone.

We’ve done the play dates (she took a long time to find her feet in reception so I got quite used to exploratory play dates) and are continuing to do them... not sure I can do much more than keep doing the same really!

OP posts:
Itstheprinciple · 28/01/2020 18:36

Signing her up to some out of school clubs is a good shout. Ones that maybe some other girls from her class go to but different children as well so she doesn't feel all her friendships are in one basket. Brownies is a good idea or gymnastics, dance etc.

dameofdilemma · 29/01/2020 15:01

Some good suggestions on this thread. Its a difficult time as girls start to grow up (and often way too fast). It is normal for them to test friendships, flex their muscles so to speak but it can be depressing to watch.

Lots of activities with different groups of kids, mixed genders, one on one playdates (3 rarely works for long).

And don't beat yourself up about being bothered - I've known women who suffered terribly at school while parents just shrugged it off. It didn't necessarily help in the long run.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page