Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Parental announcement: 'This will be your last birthday party.'

50 replies

letsgomaths · 21/12/2019 15:09

(I'm not looking for sympathy, or saying my parents were wrong - I'm just sharing my thoughts on this.)

The declaration "this will be your last birthday party" was made by my parents, shortly before my 7th birthday, with emphasis on the word 'party', rather than 'birthday'. They made that "last" party into a good one, and my slightly younger brother was allowed one more "party" after this as well. What they meant was no more parties with lots of friends round, and games. Everything else remained - presents, cake, singing Happy Birthday, but from then on it was strictly "birthday tea", usually with other family members, and I could have one friend round for this. Also they never prevented me from going to someone else's party, unless we already had something planned (which did happen once: a massive disappointment when you're only six years old).

At the time, the "no more parties" announcement was somewhat devastating to hear: when you're only seven, a year is a long time, "never" is a big word, and birthdays feel precious. It must have taken them a fair bit of courage to make such a declaration. Some years later they explained that when they saw the kinds of parties we were sometimes invited to (whole class invited to McDonalds, disco, swimming pool etc.), they didn't want us to feel that this kind of thing was expected; organising such a party was certainly more than they could afford, or were prepared to organise.

To this day, I'm not sure how I feel about it. Sometimes I feel sad for the parties I might have had, and for the stark way they announced it, but I'm also well aware that at age I struggled with social occasions, which might also have been part of their reasoning. It also means that I now say very readily "I don't do parties" or "I don't do Christmas cards", or "I don't go to weddings of people I barely know" when lots of people grudgingly say "I was invited, I suppose I ought to go". Is this a positive thing?

I was reminded of this by all the recent threads about cancelling Christmas, or at least scaling it back to make it less stressful for she who has to do the real work: lots of people are saying, if you don't want to host a big Christmas dinner, then don't; simple as that. Perhaps it was the kindest way my parents could think of to manage my expectations of birthdays. I very much understand their reasoning, but I remember it was a shock to hear it at the age of six.

OP posts:
GreenTulips · 21/12/2019 17:58

I think your parents were bff toward thinking.

These parties have gotten out of hand and companies and making so much money for must have entertainers, Hugh cakes rather than a supermarket or homemade one. All the balloons and table wear.

My kids had a few friends round for tea and games. One year we had a big summer party in the garden. Some still had class parties as the parents believed that made their kids ‘popular’.

I don’t think you missed out. I think your parents opted out.

ohwheniknow · 21/12/2019 18:02

I don't think what you're describing was courageous or done for your benefit. It was selfish and done for their benefit.

I find the knock on effects you describe pretty sad.

MyNewBearTotoro · 21/12/2019 18:04

I had my last big party at 8 and after that my birthdays were celebrated with just two or so friends coming around for birthday tea. I wasn’t told the year before but at 9 when I asked about a big party I was told I was too old for a big party. Birthdays weren’t a massive thing in my house, never had big parties at 16/18/21 etc like some families do.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

AnchorDownDeepBreath · 21/12/2019 18:06

I never had a party. My older sister had two and my youngest sister had one every year after she was born but I never had one.

I think you're overthinking it.

PanannyPanoo · 21/12/2019 18:30

I think it was the announcement that was disappointing and unecessary. If for your eighth birthday they had you can choose 6 friends to come to tea and play some games, you wouldn't have even noticed the end of parties as you know it, it certainly wouldn't be a memory that followed you to adult hood.

RowenaMud · 21/12/2019 18:38

I also find it very rude to not host a party yet accept invites from others.

Ah I hope others don’t feel this way.

My children have whole class parties. I’d hate to think some of their friends wouldn’t attend because they don’t reciprocate. Some of eldest child’s best friends have never had a party/invited her to their party if they have had one. It doesn’t make any difference to her.

73kittycat73 · 21/12/2019 18:39

I've never had a Birthday party ever. :(

JockTamsonsBairns · 21/12/2019 18:46

I also find it very rude to not host a party yet accept invites from others.

I don't like this kind of thinking. Both my DC's had classmates whose parents struggled either financially or emotionally, and couldn't have organised a party. To say that their DC's should therefore never get to go to a friend's party is really cruel.
My DC's just invited their friends, regardless of who reciprocated, or who didn't.

katewhinesalot · 21/12/2019 18:51

I said this but the kids were older.

Before that they were given the choice between a better present or a smaller present and a party. Ds worked out that he'd get a lot of presents from the guests if he had a large party, probably totaling more than the extra we'd spend If he didn't, so he continued having parties longer than dd. Hmm

imnotarunnerivetried · 21/12/2019 19:14

If that's your biggest childhood shock you were very lucky

danmthatonestakentryanotheer · 21/12/2019 19:19

I also find it very rude to not host a party yet accept invites from others

Depends on the reason not to host a birthday party Sometimes there's no point as you know hardly anyone will turn up because it's the busiest time of year for family stuff..

Aderyn19 · 21/12/2019 19:37

When DD was little her entire class (including us) did whole class parties. She had one other whole class party when she was about 8 or 9. I think that's enough tbh - families don't want to spend 30 weekends of the year attending kids' parties at soft play or the local swimming pool!

A child isn't deprived if they have a birthday celebration with just one or two friends!
Big parties are expensive and can be stressful for parents.
DD concluded that she would rather go on a shopping spree and then to McDonalds with one friend with the money I would have spent on a party, than have the big party.

letsgomaths · 21/12/2019 19:46

Thanks everybody who has replied. I do realise that there are far greater earth-shattering announcements that parents can make, such as "we are going to have to play at being poor for a while", or "you're going to a lovely new school, a long way from here", or "mummy and daddy don't love each other any more". I think it wasn't so much the message itself, but the way it was delivered.

I think my brother was more put out than I was: he was much more of a social animal, and he cried when they said the same to him. As a teenager he insisted on sleepovers (limited to about three friends), but I had no interest in having one myself. Twenty years later, his children do have parties - big ones.

I didn't have the dilemma of "I can't host a party, so I can't go to anyone else's". The only time I noticed anything of that sort was in the first Famous Five book, when highly principled George refuses point-blank to accept an ice cream from Julian, because she doesn't have any pocket money with which to return the favour.

One reason I feel rather conflicted about this is because even though I do now have the freedom to have a big party if I want one, I find I just can't get excited about parties, whether they're my own, or someone else's. My DH loves big occasions such as Christmas, weddings, birthdays (especially those which end in 0), and feels they should always have all the trimmings; we're on the same page about many things, but not this one. While he's planning big things months in advance, getting himself into a froth worthy of AIBU about every small detail, making sure that everything is perfect, I'm the fun sponge saying "is all this hassle and expense really necessary?", echoing my parents' views. I usually leave it all to him, as he loves to be the centre of it. He's arranged some really lovely things for me sometimes, which I've appreciated and enjoyed, and I try to do similar for him, but I find it hard to get excited about them. Sometimes I feel proud of my "sensible" views, at other times I find it's lonely being the frugal one!

OP posts:
MyNewBearTotoro · 21/12/2019 19:56

Your brother loves big parties and he also had his parties stopped at 7. I think this shows your preference not to celebrate occasions with big parties is probably due to your personality rather than due to your parents not throwing you big parties for your entire childhood.

I think you’re being unreasonable to say that you’re upset about not having more parties as a child because now you don’t like them and you wish you did - do you honestly think one caused the other and if so why don’t you think the same happened with your brother?

Aquilla · 21/12/2019 20:07

Whoops, I said the same thing to my 7 year old this year! Hope I'm not scarring him for life!

BackforGood · 21/12/2019 20:08

I agree with MyNewBear ^ in terms of you can't really put your attitude to parties and big celebrations down to this, as your brother loves them.

I really think you are over thinking this. Fairly normal for parties to turn into birthday tea or another 'calmer' celebrations from about 8 years old. Your parents seem pretty much in sync with many other parents. Not sure it needed a big announcement, but it wasn't like they stopped celebrating your birthday. Confused

Kungfupanda67 · 21/12/2019 20:14

@IceCreamAndCandyfloss I’ve seen the view that it’s rude to accept invitations without throwing a party several times on here, I just don’t get it. You don’t throw a party in the hope that you’ll be invited to their parties, you have a party to celebrate your own birthday. The reciprocation from the party invitee to the birthday child is in the form of a present surely?

My husband didn’t have a 30th birthday party, but lots of his friends did - should we have declined their invitation because we didn’t have a party for his birthday?

And I don’t know about you but my 7 year old would have been gutted if his best friend didn’t come to his party this year because he isn’t going to have a party for his 7th birthday.

Griefmonster · 21/12/2019 20:15

I have done this with my DC - told them 8 is their last party. They have had a sleep over or cinema or dinner out or whatever with a couple of friends but no more group parties. I thought I was a genius when I came up with that. Didn't consider it might have been a devastating blow Shock

Griefmonster · 21/12/2019 20:24

It sounds like you are more introverted and your husband an extrovert. So he gets energy from organising and hosting, it takes energy away from you to do these things. I would really recommend the book "Quiet" by Susan Cain. It might give you a different view on all this.

BackforGood · 21/12/2019 20:40

Totally agree @Kungfupanda67

Nat6999 · 21/12/2019 21:03

I never had birthday parties beyond infant school, after that it was a couple of friends around for tea or taking a friend to the cinema & tea out somewhere. Ds had birthday parties for 5th & 6th birthdays, before this it was family parties, his 5th & 6th were whole class parties at a local soft play arena who did all the catering & I just had to provide a birthday cake & party bags. After that he chose to invite a couple of close friends for tea, I did pizzas, garlic bread, chips & salad with ice creams, cake & buns afterwards. He is a teenager now & prefers to just go out with me & my mum for a Pizza Hut meal & have a larger present instead.

RowenaMud · 21/12/2019 21:19

It sounds like you are more introverted and your husband an extrovert. So he gets energy from organising and hosting, it takes energy away from you to do these things.

This fir the most part.

There is a part where your upbringing shapes you. I grew up in a house where there was little enthusiasm for anything - I cant remember ever having a birthday party or going to more than a couple and for reasons known only to my parents, I was not allowed do much or go anywhere. Obviously this impacted on my social skills.

Now as an adult I really have to work at being enthusiastic about social events. If I had grown up surrounded by them, I would almost certainly be more at ease with them but I doubt I’d ever have been the life and soul of the party.

Stevienickssleeves · 21/12/2019 21:25

You were lucky (four yorkshiremen voice) I never had a birthday party, not one. The only thing we would do is sing happy birthday and have a sponge cake after dinner.

Natsku · 21/12/2019 21:27

I've told DD that there's no more parties after she turns 10. She gets to pick a friend or two to do something fun like bowling or cinema or sleepover but no more parties. She seemed ok with the idea (told her when she was 7, she's nearly 9 now)

lifeisgoodagain · 21/12/2019 21:36

Mine was at 7 too, no announcement though, just switched to trips instead

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread