Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Preferential treatment: cricket

7 replies

Tibbytab · 27/08/2019 03:58

Hello,

I’m feeling really disheartened and flat - it’s my first time posting on mumsnet.

I have two sons who are passionate cricketers. They play for a local club and when they are in the under 13’s in a few years they can try out for county. My eldest in particular is very determined to be a professional cricketer. I’m not just saying this but both boys show talent - my eldest has to work hard for it and is happy to put in all the hours god sends. My youngest has natural ability.

Anyway they play for a local side and have done for two seasons. This season, however, it’s become abundantly clear that:

  1. coaches children receive awards and preferential treatment in respect of matches and high quality training. I know this isn’t unusual but it was the end of season awards ceremony yesterday where coaches said, “and now the best player..... goes to my son!”
  2. Unless your child goes to the private school nearby, forget any support or acknowledgement of your existence whatsoever.

I don’t usually ever have problems mingling and getting to know people, even in the tightest of cliques. But this club is a real ‘us and them’. Literally we are shoved to wherever there is a gap in a big field so conversation with the other parents is not possible because they are across the other side of the field.

Basically if your child goes to state school - forget it. 95% of the players are privately educated and I’m sure there is a link between certain families and the head coaches I just don’t know what. Certain players are beyond any doubt favourites - even when ability is lacking. I am sure money exchanges take place - whether the parents sponsor the club somehow or take coaches out to dinner etc. I think I’ve figured out that the head coach has a teenage son who attends this particular private school so I assume they talk at the school gates etc. These wealthiest parents definitely invest a lot of money into the club - we just can’t afford to do that. It really feels like the red carpet is rolled out for these families whereas anyone who has a child who comes from an ordinary school is treated with a sense of, “are you still here? This is our club”

Moving to another cricket club is an option but the problem with that is the scouts tend to not visit village clubs and they definitely visit our current club. My huge concern is because the boys are constantly overlooked in favour of the privately educated children, they aren’t getting the same level of training and match experience.

A few weeks ago I did send an email expressing my sons passion and ambitions for the game. I also pointed out that they are not given the opportunities other players have. I even said if they aren’t ‘good enough’ tell them / me what they need to improve on because they are happy to work. They just said they were fine and then literally walked off to go and stand with the privately educated families! You could draw a line between the ‘in’ families and the ‘out’ families and it matches perfectly with this particular school.

So I’m fed up and can’t sleep. What can I do? I don’t have the money to pay as much as these families, I can’t talk to them because I’m on the opposite end of the field with the other state kids, I’ve emailed them, I’ve spoken with them, I don’t feel moving clubs would be right because of the talent spotting issue.... I’m trying to find a private coach in Kent but struggling a little bit.

It just feels like if you go to the private school, you are seen as someone with drive and tip end ambition. If you go to a state school, you are seen as just someone to does a bit of cricket on a Sunday.

I know some England players didn’t go to a private school. Maybe their parents had the same difficulties or it might just be at this particular club. Has anyone got some practical advice please whether to improve the boys prospects or how to get ‘in’.

OP posts:
Belgravian · 27/08/2019 04:10

They’re only young so worrying about them being scouted is a long way off.

Let them play for the enjoyment and move to a friendlier club as nothing you say or do is going to make your face fit in this one.

You sound like you have a chip on your shoulder and it may be that which is alienating you at the club.

snitzelvoncrumb · 27/08/2019 04:55

Move to a better club, it's not worth the stress.

summerdown · 27/08/2019 05:32

I have 2 dc in the county system. But it sounds like it works a bit differently here. Is the only way to get into county through a scout rather than trials?

I’d move clubs -it sounds like your dc are young and you aren’t happy there and in my experience the club is not a factor in selection. Plus they change a lot as they grow, the most important thing is to enjoy playing at their age. One of my dc also wants to pursue this as a career, if I’ve learned anything it’s to be less emotionally involved it will do neither of you any good. The ones that shine when they are small are unlikely to be the ones that shine at
12 or 16 or older.

I agree with you about the huge number of kids in private school though. I don’t think it’s bias, but private school kids get a lot more opportunity at school, often 8 + hours of coaching / week. Plus it’s an expensive game (and county is even more expensive) and most successful dc have a lot of coaching. Our county are trying to provide additional training and opportunities for those not in private schools but there is still a long way to go.

The MCC also run various free coaching courses for dc at state schools. So might be worth trying to find out about that.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

summerdown · 27/08/2019 05:33

Btw where are you in Kent? Not my county but not far away. Feel free to pm me as might have some suggestions

countingto10 · 27/08/2019 07:49

Thought you were talking about my DS’s club until you said Kent and not Sussex. We are dealing with similar, very cliquey, and DS is noticing too, and he is of an age now where he is beginning to get vocal about it. Most of the players started at a very junior level from the local prep school so it’s a bit like the school gate and PTAHmm

TBH we don’t like spending much time up there so tend to dump him and run so probably doesn’t help the situation.

Tibbytab · 10/08/2024 16:44

It has been lovely reading the replies from so long ago. An update, if it helps anyone else who may find themselves in a similar situation, is that we did stay for a few years - and the situation continued but we were worried about leaving. Well! We have left now and found such a lovely club - similar size, similar opportunities but no politics and lovely people. I don’t think that club will ever change - they have lost so many members recently to other clubs. It was a lesson learnt, and an experience, but now we have moved on. Good luck to anyone else who finds themselves in a similar boat

OP posts:
Darksideofthemoonshine · 12/01/2025 00:40

@Tibbytab how are your boys getting on? I found this thread after a search, my dss are 10 and 8. It’s quite an agonising sport to watch them play isn’t it?!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread