Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

If you had the choice, would you live in York, Bath or South Manchester?

63 replies

GoldPaperStars · 26/03/2019 10:13

We’re living in the SE at the moment and might have the option coming up to move to one of those places.

I know Bath well and it’s beautiful, but potentially a bit parochial? I don’t particularly want to live somewhere gritty, but I also want a bit of stimulation!

York and South Manchester I don’t know well at all, but I feel like they might be a bit more interesting to live in.

When we moved we’d probably have a 1/2 year old and I do worry about making friends, so we need to pick somewhere friendly with opportunities to meet people.

WWYD?

OP posts:
liitlepenguin · 26/03/2019 21:01

I'm northern but have spent a lot of time in Bath ! For me it would be Bath hands down !!! Such a beautiful city! Good commuter links to Bristol and London!

needsleepzzz · 26/03/2019 21:07

I'm in a village outside York with a 2.5yr old. Good transport links, can be at the coast in an hour taking the route via Malton which avoids the A64 so we do that a lot in nice weather, the Wolds for walking, Yorkshire wildlife park and Flamingo land zoo.
York mumbler is a good site to check out

RunningNinja79 · 26/03/2019 21:40

Born and bred in York. Family still live there. I went to Uni in Manchester. Never been to Bath.

I dont live in York anymore and really can't see me ever moving back. DH thinks the same. As PPs have said, it is all planned around tourists and now also students. Every new business is either a coffee shop or bar. Lots of expansion for student living too. Also the traffic. We often visit York to see family (my parents and MIL) and always know when we are within 30 miles of York due to the sheer volume of traffic. Where I live now is a town, but not much difference in size and there is so much less traffic.

Last time we left York I said to DH I wonder how many people who are within the city walls on any given Saturday say at 4PM were actually from York. IE lived in York, but not there as a student. Its full of stag/hen parties, big birthday weekend, tourists, students. Of course they all bring lots of business to the city, but most people who live in York try to avoid the town centre on a Saturday where possible.

Manchester - it was 1998-2001 when I was a student there so can't really comment a lot, but I liked it. I think Id rather live there if it was one or the other. Although Leeds would be my first choice.

GoldPaperStars · 14/04/2019 16:34

I just wanted to thank everyone who replied to this. I’ve been thinking about your comments a lot. The notes about York being so touristy did put me off a bit, as did Bath being boring and Manchester not being that safe! I’m not sure that I’m all that much further along...

I do keep gravitating towards Manchester for some reason. I need to take a visit up there and see how the city feels. Any tips on the best place to visit for a (dog friendly!) short trip to the city centre would be gratefully received. My DH is a real country lover, so I need to seduce him with the cool and independent side of Manchester to try and offset that. Grin

OP posts:
SlappingJoffrey · 14/04/2019 16:50

If he likes the countryside there's no shortage of semi-rural places in and close to Greater Manchester, particularly if you're not restricting yourself to the southern half. Depending on budget of course. Roughly how much are you looking at?

TheFirstRuleOfFightClub · 14/04/2019 17:11

Yes, Greater Manchester is FULL of countryside! I never, ever get bored of Manchester, I adore the place. I was in York last weekend actually and noticed the sheer amount of tourists, but still love it there (for a day trip).

If you are talking a 30 minute commute on the train from Manchester, then this throws your options wide open. There are some beautiful places, equally some not but show me a big city without deprivation.

RedToothBrush · 14/04/2019 17:43

Didsbury is fine for when you are young, and its ok when you just start a family but its young and its more 'going out' orientated than some of the other parts of South Manchester. Once you hit your mid thirties you'll start to feel it. Its also relatively expensive for the NW. Prices in Didsbury have shot up in recent years. I know a number of people who have moved out after starting a family, because its both expensive and not necessarily for older families.

Altrincham now has a really good trendy market area, so its in someways the 'next step' if you are into that lifestyle and have kids. The schools have a particularly good reputation. Hale is its more upmarket neighbour and Sale has nice patches and good schools, but also bits that are not quite so great - but can be slightly cheaper.

Slightly further out from Didsbury you have Cheadle and Cheadle Hulme. It tends to be a bit more 'grown up' and a bit more suburbia. Its nice, but not necessarily everyone's cup of tea. I think parts 'lack a bit of soul' for want of a better phrase.

Further out still you have Wilmslow or even Knutsford. They both have trains into the city but are much more rural feeling. They are both small towns with their own character. You'll find more country style pubs out this way.

Most places in that band along the M56 between Cheadle and Knutsford and onwards as far as the Grappenhall area of Warrington are relatively nice. Some are more pricey than others, and even with a South East budget for a house, you can find it going less far than you might have anticipated. There are a large number of people who have moved up from the South East in the last decade or so. Its a lot more like being close to London than it used to be.

And as such, you should be able to find an area out of that lot which suits your taste. The only thing you should be aware of, is that public transport, whilst good in places, still leaves a lot to be desired at times. The lifestyle is still a lot more dependant on cars. Particularly if you are not going into the city centre.

I would also warn that the city centre is not necessarily the nicest of places at the moment. I love the city but the homeless and spice problem has got a lot worse in the last 18months. There are a couple of places that I would have gone a few years ago, which I'm becoming a lot less happy to be in - particularly in the evening. This is something I've never previously had an issue with or thought much about and always felt very safe.

I'd argue that if you want to get an idea of what its like to live in the area, staying in the city is not particularly reflective of life either. It has the nightlife and cultural centres but its more what you do if you are visiting. If you are coming to get a feel for living in Manchester, stay further out and drive - its the only way you'll get around more than one area anyway, otherwise you'll be more restricted in what you can do - and you can still do the city centre too if you really want.

RedToothBrush · 14/04/2019 17:49

and Manchester not being that safe

Its safe.

Chorlton has good bits and bad bits. Its regarded as the 'up and coming' bit, for people who can't afford Didsbury. Its the bit thats in the process of gentrifying to an extent. The city centre is currently rough in places, but don't be put off by it. Just be sensible. But the suburbs are very safe relatively speaking. Someone from Hale or Altrincham would probably glare at you with a complete lack of comprehension at the suggestion it wasn't safe!

Radioactivespider · 14/04/2019 18:25

Don't forget to look at schools. South Manchester gives you the option of the 11+, but the state secondaries are not brilliant. There are loads of great independent schools both single sex and co ed though.

GoldPaperStars · 17/04/2019 09:41

Thank you everyone for your replies. Really useful and I’m really grateful for how generous you’ve been with your knowledge.

The hunt continues!

OP posts:
TSSDNCOP · 17/04/2019 09:48

Bath

Japonicaflower2 · 17/04/2019 09:48

Not Bath, over-rated, polluted, full of gawping tourists and very expensive housing.
I live near Bath and avoid it as much as possible. Much prefer Salisbury or Bristol.

TapasForTwo · 17/04/2019 09:54

Why those three? Can I throw Leeds into the mix?

My sister lives near Bath, and I love the city to visit, but I don't know what it would be like to live there. I know York pretty well, but again the tourism angle could be off putting. I have visited Manchester several times and I just don't get the love for it. We have friends there, and DD has been to 2 separate open days there and just didn't like it at all. It is just too big and too busy for us.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread