Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Brother or stranger?

7 replies

Redfairy1288 · 17/06/2018 10:45

I have a half brother who is 50 years old. I am 29. He is my Dad's son from a previous marriage. That marriage ended when my brother was about 12 yrs old. A couple of years later my dad met another lady (my mum), who already had a son herself then they married and had me.

Not that unusual of a situation in this modern world?

My half brother's mother (dads ex wife) had some mental health issues (which i think contributed to them splitting up as she was violent to my dad) and by all accounts she may have said some poisonous untrue things about my mum after my dad remarried. My half brother being only 12/13 during these years was affected by a lot of this. Before tgey got married, my dad moved away to live with my mum in another town 200 miles away (where my mum was from). So in my half brother's view his dad was not around much for quite a difficult part of his life.

My parents married and then moved back to my dads hometown. My half brother moved in with them for a bit and my mum always made an effort with him. Then he moved out, my parents had me and life went on. As there is a 21 yr age gap between us, for me he was always an adult in my life and probably felt more like an uncle than brother but that was ok. He married and had kids and we would see them regularly. Over the early years he didn't seem to like my mum much but was civil and over the years everything seemed to get better. They were never best buds but he was able to be nice to her and have a good relationship with Dad and us.

My half brother then moved away (we lived in essex and he moved up north to liverpool) - he got divorced and he also ended up re-marrying and having another child a bit later in life with his new wife (just like my dad did). Due to the distance, visits became less but they did still take place back & forth. Over the last 10 years as my parents have got older and my mum has had a lot of back and hip problems, they have not travelled to liverpool to visit as it is a long hard journey and my brother's visits to us have dwindled. When he did come he would stay at his mother's house which was understandable as he always maintained a close relationship with her, but he would often just come alone or very rarely with his wife and kids.

My parents moved down to the bottom end of the country 5 yrs ago (dorset). In that time my brother has become quite off with my parents. He went through a long stage of not answering my dads calls texts or emails, and only did so when a family emergency happened. Then communication picked up again just over the phone between him and dad until about 2 yrs ago when a silly Facebook post by him was taken the wrong way by my mum. Once it was clarified my mum had no problem but my brother did, and he fell out with them over it, sending dad lots of texts saying how he never visits them and is not a proper grandad to his kids, saying that he does not really know me and referring to my mum as 'that woman' etc.

I think a lot of the issues stem back to him being an impressionable age when my dad divorced his mum and the circumstances around that. However that was all way before I was born.

So over the last few years my brother and dad have not had a good relationship but do text occasionally.

As an adult now myself, I have tried to keep a relationship with my brother and send cards, call or text him occasionally and i have been up to visit him twice. He is always kind and welcoming and calls me 'sis' when i do these things.

However, even though he visits our home county of essex (where i still live) a fair amount, he stays at his mums, no problem - but he never gets in touch with me qhen he is here to see about meeting even for a quick coffee - nothing. Considering he travels from Liverpool to essex to see his mum, you'd think he would make the effort to arrange to see his sister whilst he's here. But several times now, he has not done this. And we know when he is here because he puts it on Facebook tagging himself into places in the town or saying "im travelling to essex". Last time he did this, i messaged him to say 'oh i didn't know you were coming down, I'm free this weekend if you want to meet up' but he did not respond.

This has happened again this weekend - its plastered all over his Facebook wall that he is here & with his mum and her family. I have not heard from him though and this time i have not contacted him myself.

As his younger sister by 21 years i feel as though i make all the effort to keep a relationship between us. He never calls me. He doesn't visit me when he's in town. He's never seen my house. He did come to my wedding but only after at one stage saying he might not come.

I call & text him, I've made the trip specifically to liverpool to visit him twice. I am not getting the same back from him.

I have done nothing wrong to fall out with him so i can only assume he makes no effort with me because i am related to my mum who he doesn't like.

Does he want to be my brother?? He is not acting like it. But family is important to me and id like to stay in touch as well as see my nephews (his sons). But i dont get to speak to my brother unless i ring him and i don't get to see my nephews unless i visit liverpool. They must barely know who i am. If he made the effort to contact me when he visits here then i would be happy to continue to do a couple of visits a year to where he lives too. But in any relationship whether friendship or family, it has to be 2 way. If i contacted him as much as he contacts me, we would never talk and i don't think id ever actually see him. It makes me sad. I feel hurt because im his baby sister but he doesn't seem to want me to be. And i worry for my dad as i know he is hurt by all the issues they have had too.

Any advice on how I should manage this going forward? I am starting to feel that he wants to be a stranger to me and not a brother.

Sorry i know this is very long, it had to be to give you full context.

Look forward to any responses xxxx

OP posts:
Solopower1 · 17/06/2018 11:14

Hello, Redfairy. I think you should phone/text him to ask if you can visit him in Liverpool. Keep it short - along the lines of 'Wondered if I could come and see you? It's been a while, I've got a couple of days' holiday. Would stay in a B & B.' Chances are, he would appreciate the effort you have made, and you would then be able to gauge how he feels about you.

I would go alone (or with your husband, except that might inhibit your bro), but without your dad, as you and your brother are the innocent victims of what went before, and your bro may well still have issues with your dad. Also, your mum might not like you going with your dad but not with her.

The worst case scenario would be if your bro said No, but at least you would know where you stand, and could take it from there.

Family is important, and ime every little effort you make is rewarded 10X over by the reaction you get. Be brave, try it and see, is my advice.

Good luck.

Redfairy1288 · 17/06/2018 11:58

Thankyou for your advice 😊 i have visited him a few times in recent years alone and with hubby. But he comes to essex often and doesn't contact me to meet up. Right now he is 30 mins down the road from me but hasnt contacted me to see if im free to meet before he goes home. I feel that as he is not making an effort with me, im not sure i want to make another visit to him it is a long journey to make and at the moment i am 7 months pregnant. There is no give and take - ive already visited him and called him often but im not getting it back. Xx

OP posts:
Solopower1 · 17/06/2018 14:16

Really disappointing and hurtful for you.

You seem to be saying that you think it is a lost cause, and if so, there's nothing to be done. For reasons of his own, he has decided not to contact you.

But if you think there is any hope at all, maybe you could call him, one more time while he is so near, and suggest a meeting? You'd lose nothing by doing that, and if he says No, at least you would know you had done everything you could.

It's such a shame for you, but you have a happy event coming up soon, so you can turn your attention to that, and hope that one day he will come to his senses. And when your nephews are adults, maybe you could contact them directly, but let your bro know of your intentions?

All the best.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

Petalflowers · 17/06/2018 14:28

Some people are better at doing ‘the family stuff’ then others. Maybe his mum doesn’t like him visiting you when he’s down or he feels he has to spend his time with her.

Just because he doesn’t visit, it doesn’t mean he doesn’t care.

I think if you want to maintain a relationship, you will have to accept that you will probably have to put more effort in.

Redfairy1288 · 17/06/2018 14:30

Yes i suppose it does feel a bit of a lost cause really as I've already tried so hard with him. But i guess it makes me feel angry and i don't want to carry that around. 'There's one in every family' they say hey.

His eldest kids are older now. One is an adult and is living abroad at the moment and the other is just finishing school. The youngest is 7 and is just a gorgeous little thing.

I'm trying to think it isn't personal to me but i think he's just got A LOT of issues with the paternal side of his family and this is just one symptom of it. I don't know really.

Yes he will have a little neice or nephew very soon. I do wonder if they will ever meet.

OP posts:
picklemepopcorn · 17/06/2018 14:43

You have to accept the relationship other people are offering, and decide how much effort you want to put in accordingly.

All you can do is as much as you want to do- the rest of the relationship is down to him.

It would be perfectly reasonable and inoffensive to let him know that due to family/pregnancy/new baby you won't be able to travel far now, so won't be going up to Liverpool for a while. You'd love the cousins to have a relationship, so would love to see him when he is in the area.

Redfairy1288 · 18/06/2018 07:59

Thank you yes i think that's good advice xx

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread