Well being as opiates are not indicated for chronic pain and benzos are not indicated for long term management of anxiety or muscle spasm then I would certainly want to detox prisoners from those. There are lots of other effective medications to manage those conditions which are not addictive, and actually it's really irresponsible of GPs to prescribe these medications long term.
But you do understand that benzos and opiates become less effective over time and more difficult to stop? I would never advocate the use of opiates for non cancer pain for long term management,
I've been on long term opioid therapy for 19 years so far, for chronic pain due to a spinal injury, under the care of a pain clinic
I saw my pain consultant yesterday in fact - we agreed to my first dose increase of my modified release meds for a long time, which is of course due to the downregulation of opioid receptors that occurs over time as tolerance builds. I was taking my max dose of breakthrough oxycodone IR daily, so my GP referred me back to see my pain consultant to see if my MR oxycodone should be upped.
They are very, very effective for managing my pain
We have tried many different therapies with limited success
Interventional pain procedures: steroid injections and radiofrequency denervation
Anti inflammatories: both NSAIDS and COX-2
Neuropathic pain meds: pregabalin, gabapentin, amitrypitline, oxcarbazepine
Opioids: codeine, dihydrocodeine, tramadol, oxycodone MR and IR, morphine and fentanyl patches
The opioids allow me to have a very functional life - I work, pay my taxes, go to the gym, have a social life
I came off them completely whilst undergoing IVF and during my (sadly unsuccessful) pregnancies and the difference was stark - I couldn't work, I was sleeping about 2h a night, the pain preventer me from functioning. I didn't have any physical withdrawal (I've only ever had withdrawal once, when I came off fentanyl too quickly, which was horrible), but my uncontrolled pain was beyond awful
I have tolerance
I have limited dependence
I am not addicted
I have done pain management courses, practice meditation, undergo regular physiotherapy, and utilise a range of pain management strategies
The opioids are clearly not ideal but they make the difference between being able to function and not
My pain consultant is happy with my regimen and keeps me under regular review.
Opioids shouldn't be used unless necessary and clearly the prison population is a specific case in and of itself. But for certain people and certain types of pain (nociceptive, non neuropathic, non inflammatory(, they can be very effective.
My GP will only prescribe my pain meds under the direction of my pain consultant. They will not make any dose changes without his say so. So I don't personally believe they're irresponsible for following the advice of a consultant who's one of the country's leading pain specialists.
Yes, tolerance builds. Yes my dose has and will change over time. But as with anything, it has to be considered on a case by case basis.