Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

PayPal shuts Free Speech Union account

109 replies

ResisterRex · 20/09/2022 21:50

Big Tech overreach in the Telegraph:

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/09/20/paypal-shuts-accounts-free-speech-union/

"PayPal has shut down the account of the Free Speech Union, an organisation which defends gender-critical academics and opposes Drag queen story hours in schoolss_.
The US payments company shut down the accounts of the Free Speech Union, its founder Toby Young, and his opinion and news website the Daily Sceptic with no clear explanation last week, The Telegraph can reveal.
Mr Young said he suspected the action was driven by political motivess_ and was a “sinister form of cancel culture”.
...

The Free Speech Union, founded by Mr Young two years ago, has recently called on the Government to ensure children aren't politically indoctrinated at school, citing the teaching of “radical gender theory” through Drag queen story hours in schools.
The organisation has helped to defend people who claim they have lost work for expressing opinions, for example Gillian Philip, the author who said her contract was terminated because she stood up for JK Rowling on Twitter amid a row over transgender rightss_. It has also challenged universities that have “no-platformed” gender-critical academics.
...

Mr Young said: “Withdrawing financial services from dissidents and non-conformists and those who dare to defend them is the new frontline in the ongoing war against free speech.
“The Free Speech Union will be lobbying the Government to put new laws in to prevent companies like PayPal demonetising organisations and individuals because their employees disapprove of their views.”"

FSU tweet:

twitter.com/speechunion/status/1572323227040358401?s=46&t=Q_pYlcOXOni-UQ61agbaRw

OP posts:
DysonSpheres · 23/09/2022 08:56

TheBeardedVulture · 23/09/2022 08:11

Isn’t the guy who founded PayPal Peter Thiel? He’s the one who financed Hulk Hogan’s lawsuit against Gawker, which bankrupted the site. He did this because Gawker outed him as gay years previously.

www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2018/02/hogan-thiel-gawker-trial/554132/

I thought Elon Musk originally founded Paypal?

That story with P.T vs Gawker is deeply concerning. One person has enough money to shut down an entire platform of free speech because he doesn't like what they said, albeit indirectly.

But we've already seen something like this happening with mainstream journalism. They have wealthy sponsors and they will not report on subjects that upset those sponsors. You can see with some of them that they compromise by not allowing comments or removing comments after a certain time.

It also stands to reason that if their sponsors can prevent certain topics being reported on, they can tell them what subjects to include and report on. Distrust of the msm is at an all time high quite rightly.

Cashless will bring that compromise into your daily life.

beastlyslumber · 23/09/2022 08:55

I'm currently in Croatia, where cash is still the favoured way to pay. It us changing though. You can pay contactless in many places now, although a lot of places also stipulate cash only.

Just reading the FSU newsletter. It is really very worrying indeed.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/09/2022 08:30

I've always not been in favour of going cashless for exactly this reason.

ResisterRex · 23/09/2022 08:17

This whole thing has made me think again about going totally cashless. I agree they're probably waiting for transactions to reach a certain point.

What can we do? Not much, maybe. But where you can pay cash, I'm going to. And where it's a well known coffee shop saying they're "trialling going cashless" while there's a homeless person outside who's even further disenfranchised because now no one carries money, but there's a small independent that does still do cash, it's making me think - well, even more reason to use the small independent. I will make sure to carry cash again.

I also worry going totally cashless will teach children that money is abstract. Just numbers on a screen. They won't have the relationship with money that we'd have had growing up if they get money transferred into an account then they tap a card to buy something. What is money when you understand it like that? It's not real. It does become abstract - and it becomes subject to someone else's whims and values.

This turn of events with PayPal is really, really concerning.

OP posts:
TheBeardedVulture · 23/09/2022 08:11

Isn’t the guy who founded PayPal Peter Thiel? He’s the one who financed Hulk Hogan’s lawsuit against Gawker, which bankrupted the site. He did this because Gawker outed him as gay years previously.

www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2018/02/hogan-thiel-gawker-trial/554132/

DysonSpheres · 23/09/2022 08:02

But how would you resist it?

I always objected to the Oyster Card Scheme. Refused to use one for years. And when it was initially introduced, there was a weak, diluted attempt by various human rights charities to grab peoples attention to the fact that by choosing to use a top-up card to travel, once enough people had taken it up, it would be used as justification to phase out cash use when travelling and your privacy would be compromised (it records every journey) and it would eventually be no longer a choice but mandatory to use it. Nevertheless people jumped onboard with using them. Now every journey whether you use an Oyster or your bank card or online Gpay is recordable.

I'm afraid people will simply 'slip' into a cashless society, in exactly the same way they have with cashless travel. And every transaction you then make will be recordable. People you're 'allied' with be open to scrutiny. I think it's inevitable.

They're just waiting for the volume of cashless transactions to get past a certain critical point and then cash will be phased out. Then you'll really be screwed when your opinions aren't liked by whatever payment provider or vendor you're with. And Bitcoin is as transparent as fuck and withdraws payment options to businesses when they are deemed 'unfavourable' or lent on.

And thanks to the democracy that is Canada, we all now know that crowd funding sites will share our info in a heartbeat and the banks will positively leap to give the government all our transaction details over anything it says is a threat, even if there isn't one.

Plurality of options in a market that is dominated by just a few big players is what's needed.

beastlyslumber · 23/09/2022 07:11

2Rebecca · 22/09/2022 22:03

I'm a GP and I find the treatment of the Covid vaccine odd.
All vaccines have side effects, all vaccines kill a small number of people usually by anaphylaxis. The Covid vaccines may cause myocarditis.
Most vaccines including Covid are more beneficial to the population than not vaccinating. If they weren't governments would spend the money on something else and doctors and nurses would refuse to give them.
I think that all governments behaved very weirdly in not discussing the pros and cons of Covid vaccination with the public like adults but pretending it was a miracle vaccine with 100% efficacy and no side effects.
I had all my vaccines but can understand why some young fit people particularly those who'd had Covid chose not to bother.
This is different to nutters who think Bill Gates for some reason spent a fortune microchipping the vaccines but Toby Young is not a conspiracy nut.
Many people in to homeopathy refuse all vaccines. That's their choice, I think they are wrong and homeopathy is pseudoscience but they should not be refused financial services because of their beliefs which are not against the law
Lots of people believe weird things hence the large ( but shrinking) number of religions.
Paypal are very very wrong here.

Thanks for this comment. I've not been vaccinated but I'm not antivaxx. I just wanted to wait a little while when they were first offered as I have an anti immune condition and wondered if it might be relevant. But quickly the talk turned to mandates and discriminating against the unvaxxed and I decided on principle that they could fuck off. I think it's absolutely right that if they had calmly discussed the pros and cons, I would have taken it, even with some trepidation. I find it amazing that people have put such trust in big pharma.

I don't think it's true that doctors and nurses would have refused to give the jabs though. Most people do what they're told. The doctors and nurses who spoke against it have been utterly monstered, and it looks like any information that calls the global narrative into question, even in a minor way, is being viciously stamped out.

I guess the next step is to connect vaccine status to your bank account. Then they can make sure we're all "healthy" - or else.

beastlyslumber · 23/09/2022 07:02

I think it might be a bit late for that. So many shops now don't take cash payments anymore.

Aishah231 · 23/09/2022 06:45

This is another reason why we must all resist any more towards a cashless society.

musicalfrog · 22/09/2022 23:07

Thanks I'll do that.

2Rebecca · 22/09/2022 23:06

I would contact them. I had stopped all my regular Paypal payments a few months earlier as I decided it was easier to have them all in 1 place but if changing a payment method the payer should inform the service provider so you don't lose any of the service

musicalfrog · 22/09/2022 22:55

Sorry to interrupt. Operational question: will Netflix contact me or do I have to contact them about a change of payment method?

2Rebecca · 22/09/2022 22:03

I'm a GP and I find the treatment of the Covid vaccine odd.
All vaccines have side effects, all vaccines kill a small number of people usually by anaphylaxis. The Covid vaccines may cause myocarditis.
Most vaccines including Covid are more beneficial to the population than not vaccinating. If they weren't governments would spend the money on something else and doctors and nurses would refuse to give them.
I think that all governments behaved very weirdly in not discussing the pros and cons of Covid vaccination with the public like adults but pretending it was a miracle vaccine with 100% efficacy and no side effects.
I had all my vaccines but can understand why some young fit people particularly those who'd had Covid chose not to bother.
This is different to nutters who think Bill Gates for some reason spent a fortune microchipping the vaccines but Toby Young is not a conspiracy nut.
Many people in to homeopathy refuse all vaccines. That's their choice, I think they are wrong and homeopathy is pseudoscience but they should not be refused financial services because of their beliefs which are not against the law
Lots of people believe weird things hence the large ( but shrinking) number of religions.
Paypal are very very wrong here.

Redshoeblueshoe · 22/09/2022 19:28

Matt Letissier has also deleted his paypal account.

AlisonDonut · 22/09/2022 19:04

DysonSpheres · 22/09/2022 18:37

Shock

I knew it would be grim, but bloody hell! WTActualF!

When I see people who have this board hidden I do wonder at what point this will hit them and they work out what it is we have been banging on about for the last 6 years.

And then they will say that nobody told them it was this bad.

It's this bad. It has been for a fair old while.

DysonSpheres · 22/09/2022 18:37

OldCrone · 22/09/2022 18:01

I'm afraid to ask what 'tucking underwear' is, I suspect the answer will be grim.

I assume it's something like this:

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4536459-genital-flattening-underwear-for-four-year-old-boys

Shock

I knew it would be grim, but bloody hell! WTActualF!

Needmoresleep · 22/09/2022 18:02

That article says he has his accounts closed due to COVID free anti vaccine speech. He himself says he has no idea why. So how do the Times know why?

My assumption is that, goaded by US based trans-activists, PayPal made an error. Rather than apologise and correct that error and risk unleashing the Kraken, they have engaged an expensive PR firm to brief the Times. Despite what the Times says it is perfectly OK to question the Government's vaccine strategy. As we know every single expert seemed to have a different view, and if Toby's view is towards the nutty end, so be it. Indeed I seem to remember recently Kate Bingham, the first vaccine procurement head, questioning the current strategy and its reliance on mRNA vaccines.

OldCrone · 22/09/2022 18:01

I'm afraid to ask what 'tucking underwear' is, I suspect the answer will be grim.

I assume it's something like this:

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4536459-genital-flattening-underwear-for-four-year-old-boys

ResisterRex · 22/09/2022 17:43

Jack Dee is cancelling his PayPal(!)

twitter.com/therealjackdee/status/1572945552169631744?s=46&t=NiCfdk0_6YHfUBKeBkudGQ

"I’m in the process of cancelling my PayPal account. Big Tech companies that feel they can bully people for questioning mainstream groupthink don’t deserve anyone’s business."

And there's a comment piece on the case from Toby Young in the Telegraph:

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/09/22/corporations-allowed-decide-opinions-permissible-free-speech/

"I’m at a loss as to what the Daily Sceptic has ever published that could possibly fall into those categories, but I know from defending feminists at the FSU that ‘hate’ is often used to mean ‘a point of view I disagree with’.
For instance, last year we went in to bat for the women’s rights activist Kellie-Jay Keenn_ after she had a petition removed from Change.org. Her petition, which had several thousand signatures, asked the Oxford English Dictionary not to change the definition of woman from ‘adult human female’ to something else. Change.org removed it on the grounds that defining a woman that way was ‘hate speech’.
The view that sex, like gender, is a social construct and therefore not binary and immutable, is one of five sacred nostrums that you’re no longer allowed to challenge on most mainstream forums, particularly those owned by tech companies in Silicon Valley.
The others are: the lockdown policy and associated Covid restrictions were a prudent response to the pandemic; the mRNA vaccines are safe and efficacious; we’re in the midst of a ‘climate emergency’ and the only solution is to achieve ‘net zero’ by 2050 (preferably earlier); and the West should continue to supply arms and aid to Ukraine.
If you express scepticism about any of these holy precepts, you can expect to find yourself in trouble"

OP posts:
DysonSpheres · 22/09/2022 15:57

I'm afraid to ask what 'tucking underwear' is, I suspect the answer will be grim.

Penny Mordaunt deflected the question really well.

ScreamingMeMe · 22/09/2022 15:14

In this video, it is explained that Patreon, Shoppify and Etsy have banned Conservative and GC people, but are allowing the sale of CSA material, child "sex dolls" and "tucking" underwear for toddlers.

InTheCanteen · 22/09/2022 14:30

Danny Kruger MP brought up this case in the House of Commons this morning:

ResisterRex · 22/09/2022 13:15

The FSU, or questioning vaccine efficacy, is not proscribed. We do have proscribed groups and the FSU isn't one of them. Questioning vaccine efficacy isn't against the law either.

OP posts:
DysonSpheres · 22/09/2022 12:36

He shouldn't have had his account closed down for anti-vaccine speech.

There are many people who are covid vaccine skeptical and I watched in dismay as the narrative turned anyone who didn't jump onboard with it into the enemy. 'antivaxxer' 'covidiots' pretty disgusting. People lapped it up though.

'Disinformation' is whatever the hell big tech platforms and their affiliated big corporations/investors/poltical think tank/backers say and decide it is. That is the huge obvious downside of the so-called Internet 'Safety' Bill. Whose safety will it be protecting?

It's going to get worse. Everyone is ok when the target seems unpalatable.

But they'll come for the apparently sensible next.

AlisonDonut · 22/09/2022 11:43

That article says he has his accounts closed due to COVID free anti vaccine speech. He himself says he has no idea why. So how do the Times know why?