Please or to access all these features

30 days only

Friends betrayal

105 replies

andromeburns · 17/10/2026 17:19

Hi I need some advice. I recently found out I have a younger sister. Basically when i was 4/5 mum had an affair and had another child. She gave the baby up for adoption and her and dad stayed together. My parents both died in the last five years and the ‘baby’ has found me on social media after getting her adoption details. We are both in our fifties and have messaged and met up once. Shes great and we are getting to know each other. Because both my parents are dead and we don’t know who her dad is there’s not really any one we can talk to about this and get more information. I don’t know if my grandparents knew but they are all dead and my uncle didn’t know. I recently told my oldest friend and it turns out she knew and has known for over thirty years (her cousin was close friends with my mum) I feel really betrayed by my friend as had I have known early I could have asked my mum/ dad or her cousin about it but now there’s no one to ask. (Her cousin died 3 years ago)I’ve known my friend since we were children and we have been close our entire lives. Am I right to feel betrayed by her? I don’t know if I can forgive her.

OP posts:
HambleDoll · 17/10/2026 17:44

I wouldn’t ever speak to her again. I hope you and your sister become great friends.

Redflagsabounded · 17/10/2026 17:55

I think the opposite. If course you are questioning why she didn't tell you and are hurt about that. Have you asked her why in a non- confrontational way?

I can imagine she was torn in two by this. It's a secret she should never have been told when she was presumably quite young? It must have been a burden, surely.

She respected your parent's privacy, and kept her nose out if your family business. Telling you would have launched a rocket into your life. Or maybe now she regrets not telling you at some point?

She an old friend. Talk to her.

TheDr46 · 17/10/2026 18:05

The burden your friend must have felt, carrying this for all these years. She probably wanted to tell you but her hands were tied. You’ve got every right to feel upset and but I doubt very much this is a betrayal on the traditional sense. There would have been no good time for her to tell you this without some fall out. Friendship of over 30 years is worth holding on tight to.

WallaceinAnderland · 17/10/2026 18:07

It wasn't her secret to tell. She had no way of knowing if you would be devastated.

AudiobookListener · 17/10/2026 18:20

She kept your Mom's secret. As she should. It was never her place to tell you. And she may have felt she was protecting you from a lot of potential stress and upset. It may have been stressful for her keeping this secret. I'd not let it affect a good friendship.

Ipsevenenabibas · 17/10/2026 18:29

AudiobookListener · 17/10/2026 18:20

She kept your Mom's secret. As she should. It was never her place to tell you. And she may have felt she was protecting you from a lot of potential stress and upset. It may have been stressful for her keeping this secret. I'd not let it affect a good friendship.

This.
I also think she would be damned if she told you and clearly, damned if she didn't. What a horrible position she was in. She absolutely did the right thing.

Emilesgran · 17/10/2026 18:34

andromeburns · 17/10/2026 17:19

Hi I need some advice. I recently found out I have a younger sister. Basically when i was 4/5 mum had an affair and had another child. She gave the baby up for adoption and her and dad stayed together. My parents both died in the last five years and the ‘baby’ has found me on social media after getting her adoption details. We are both in our fifties and have messaged and met up once. Shes great and we are getting to know each other. Because both my parents are dead and we don’t know who her dad is there’s not really any one we can talk to about this and get more information. I don’t know if my grandparents knew but they are all dead and my uncle didn’t know. I recently told my oldest friend and it turns out she knew and has known for over thirty years (her cousin was close friends with my mum) I feel really betrayed by my friend as had I have known early I could have asked my mum/ dad or her cousin about it but now there’s no one to ask. (Her cousin died 3 years ago)I’ve known my friend since we were children and we have been close our entire lives. Am I right to feel betrayed by her? I don’t know if I can forgive her.

How could she know how you would react? And it wasn't her secret to tell you anyway - she was in an impossible position. What if you learning that before your mum died had seriously destabilised you - maybe even ruined your relationship with your mother? She would have been to blame for that and would have ruined your mum's life too.

susiedaisy1912 · 17/10/2026 18:37

She probably didn’t want to know the information but ended up knowing by association so she’s had to keep this secret around all these years. Give yourself time to think it over before you cut all ties with her.

andromeburns · 17/10/2026 18:38

Redflagsabounded · 17/10/2026 17:55

I think the opposite. If course you are questioning why she didn't tell you and are hurt about that. Have you asked her why in a non- confrontational way?

I can imagine she was torn in two by this. It's a secret she should never have been told when she was presumably quite young? It must have been a burden, surely.

She respected your parent's privacy, and kept her nose out if your family business. Telling you would have launched a rocket into your life. Or maybe now she regrets not telling you at some point?

She an old friend. Talk to her.

I feel like she should have told me since my parents are gone. But yes she was in her teens when she was told.

OP posts:
spanishcheese · 17/10/2026 18:38

If I was your friend I would have never admitted knowing this. She presumably has no information to share. It's simply the knowledge of knowing - which is pointless and unhelpful. She chose not to tell you earlier so that you could follow up with your parents or wider family while they were still alive, so letting you know that she knew all along is a huge betrayal.

Emilesgran · 17/10/2026 18:41

andromeburns · 17/10/2026 18:38

I feel like she should have told me since my parents are gone. But yes she was in her teens when she was told.

But once your parents were gone, what would have been the point? Your OP was about the fact that it's too late now to find out who your half sister's father was - so the only way for your friend to have changed that would have been to tell you before your mum died.

Once she was gone, it wasn't clear that there was any point, or any hurry, in telling you then. And I don't expect anyone had "released" her from her promise to keep quiet at that point anyway.

I can understand why you're shocked, but I don't think it's fair to blame your friend - there was no "right" thing for her to do, other than continue to leave things as your mother had wanted them to be.

Emilesgran · 17/10/2026 18:46

spanishcheese · 17/10/2026 18:38

If I was your friend I would have never admitted knowing this. She presumably has no information to share. It's simply the knowledge of knowing - which is pointless and unhelpful. She chose not to tell you earlier so that you could follow up with your parents or wider family while they were still alive, so letting you know that she knew all along is a huge betrayal.

She very likely just didn't know how to lie about it when told about it. That would be me - I just can't lie very well (this is not a humble brag, it's really not a good thing socially to be such a terrible actor - people always know by my face what I'm thinking and it's a terrible disadvantage sometimes!)

So if someone tells me something I already know but am not supposed to, it's very hard for me to react convincingly. I've learned this from experience.

emuloc · 17/10/2026 18:47

It was not down to her to disclose something like that. In fact she should just have denied any knowledge whatsoever, because you are now placing unfair anger on her.

IronEverything · 17/10/2026 18:56

I doubt this is something she has gone through her life thinking about regularly. It was some information she was given as a teenager and most likely told never to repeat. She kept that promise.

Is understandable that you are upset and angry but you are taking it out on the wrong person.

andromeburns · 17/10/2026 18:57

spanishcheese · 17/10/2026 18:38

If I was your friend I would have never admitted knowing this. She presumably has no information to share. It's simply the knowledge of knowing - which is pointless and unhelpful. She chose not to tell you earlier so that you could follow up with your parents or wider family while they were still alive, so letting you know that she knew all along is a huge betrayal.

That’s exactly how I feel. I get why she couldn’t tell me and potentially blow up my family. But now I feel additional hurt that she’s known all along and no told me and there’s no benefit to me knowing now it’s just elevated her conscience

OP posts:
andromeburns · 17/10/2026 19:06

Emilesgran · 17/10/2026 18:41

But once your parents were gone, what would have been the point? Your OP was about the fact that it's too late now to find out who your half sister's father was - so the only way for your friend to have changed that would have been to tell you before your mum died.

Once she was gone, it wasn't clear that there was any point, or any hurry, in telling you then. And I don't expect anyone had "released" her from her promise to keep quiet at that point anyway.

I can understand why you're shocked, but I don't think it's fair to blame your friend - there was no "right" thing for her to do, other than continue to leave things as your mother had wanted them to be.

Edited

Her cousin might have known more as mums friend

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 17/10/2026 19:08

WallaceinAnderland · 17/10/2026 18:07

It wasn't her secret to tell. She had no way of knowing if you would be devastated.

Yep. This,

Jibbee · 17/10/2026 19:10

She was trying to protect you at the time, as time went on it would have been harder to tell you, don’t throw away your friendship.

GardenCovent · 17/10/2026 19:10

If I was your friend I would never have told you.
This was a family matter, she was privy to information that she probably didn’t want to be and as such did not tittle tattle this.
I think I would actually respect my friend more for knowing she kept your family secret

Ipsevenenabibas · 17/10/2026 19:12

GardenCovent · 17/10/2026 19:10

If I was your friend I would never have told you.
This was a family matter, she was privy to information that she probably didn’t want to be and as such did not tittle tattle this.
I think I would actually respect my friend more for knowing she kept your family secret

Agree. It would make me respect her more too. I think the OP's anger is greatly misplaced.

Awkwardisfunny · 17/10/2026 19:26

andromeburns · 17/10/2026 17:19

Hi I need some advice. I recently found out I have a younger sister. Basically when i was 4/5 mum had an affair and had another child. She gave the baby up for adoption and her and dad stayed together. My parents both died in the last five years and the ‘baby’ has found me on social media after getting her adoption details. We are both in our fifties and have messaged and met up once. Shes great and we are getting to know each other. Because both my parents are dead and we don’t know who her dad is there’s not really any one we can talk to about this and get more information. I don’t know if my grandparents knew but they are all dead and my uncle didn’t know. I recently told my oldest friend and it turns out she knew and has known for over thirty years (her cousin was close friends with my mum) I feel really betrayed by my friend as had I have known early I could have asked my mum/ dad or her cousin about it but now there’s no one to ask. (Her cousin died 3 years ago)I’ve known my friend since we were children and we have been close our entire lives. Am I right to feel betrayed by her? I don’t know if I can forgive her.

I agree with others. She had no way of knowing if telling you would be the end of the friendship and it wasn't her secret to share. It isn't fair to blame her for keeping someone else's secret - it actually speaks volumes to her character.

I would have to wonder if she ever spoke to your parents to ask them to talk to you but.. even that could have rocked the boat.

I don't think it's worth losing a valued friendship over, if there are no other concerns.

Freshrain · 17/10/2026 21:13

No, you are not right to feel betrayed by her.

She was burdened with a secret she couldn't tell you. That was not her fault. She couldn't have told you and completely blown up your parents' lives.

After they were gone, what would be the point ? Even if she thought about it at all. More than likely she had filed it away in her memory and didn't think about it at all.

I get this has completely knocked you sideways. I understand the feelings of wondering what it might have been like knowing you had a half sister some years ago. This is bound to make you question so much in your life and leave you feeling a whole mixture of emotions, but you would be a fool to take it out on a friend of such long standing, even more so when it wasn't her doing.

EBearhug · 17/10/2026 21:24

In my 20s, I found out I had a half-sister. It turned out quite a few people must have known - grandparents, aunts, uncles. Cousins on one side assumed I had been told a limited story, but not the whole truth - I had had no idea at all, so it was all a huge shock, and I was left not knowing who I could trust. If such a major thing had been hidden from me, what else hadn't I been told?

But also, when woukd have been the right time to tell? Needed to be old enough to understand, but you don't want to tell someone something potentially confusing and upsetting when they're dealing with starting or changing school or doing exams, etc, and a lot of the time, people probably just weren't thinking about it at all. There never woukd be a right time, and then it's such a habit not to talk about it, it's easier to carry on... And because no one talked about it, no one knew what my full sister and I did or didn't know already - when my half sister told me, she said she might have approached it differently if she had realised we had never been told anything, not even a made up story with half a truth.

Try not to take it out on your friend - she was put it in a very difficult position, and this sort of thing coming out can really turn your understanding of the world and your relationships on its head. You need friends and support. Good luck with working things out.

Needacalminginfluence · 18/10/2026 03:52

I hate secrets and I think they always cause hurt or upset or trouble when they are revealed.
But I do think that your friend keeping this from you was motivated by what she thought was the best thing to do. It wasn't done in any way with the intention of hurting you.
I can totally understand how difficult this revelation must be for you but I think it would be sad to lose your friendship over it.

PollyBell · 18/10/2026 04:04

You mum did thia not your friend

Swipe left for the next trending thread