My OH and I cannot agree on a name at all. We like many of the same ones, but we each have one or two we really love, and the other just likes but doesn't love.
So either we go with a name that I love and OH just likes a lot, or OH loves and I just like a lot. I'm guessing this can't be that uncommon, can it? Is there anybody who settled for a name they really like, but don't LOVE? How is it? Do you grow to love it over time?