Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s crazy that National Minimum wage is £27k

663 replies

Butterflyfluff · 09/10/2026 20:08

Yet it’s not really enough to live on 😢

My first job paid £7.5k per year and I thought I was loaded! And I’m not ancient.

Now 2 people on NMW earn over £50k between them yet it’s really not enough these days.

OP posts:
AnneShirleyBlythe · 10/10/2026 01:58

Friendlygingercat · 10/10/2026 01:38

So how is it that a pensioner is expected to live on so much less than someone of so called working age?

We are not all millionaires with big houses that have risen in value or scroungers on pension credit who never saved.. Many are stuck in the middle with very modest occupational pensions. Many now rent, have to heat their homes and buy food, pay extortionate council tax. Many pensioners have more or less the same expenses so why are we expected to manage on less?

I only know ‘average’ pensioners not any rich ones but they don’t have the expense of bringing up children & often have nearly as much income as families.

FourFruitSalads · 10/10/2026 02:06

Having read this thread I find it interesting that many on MN think that pensioners are living the life of Riley on just 50% of the minimum wage

And we all benefit from huge inheritances. When in reality only 20% of people in the uk inherit anything at all.

rainingsnoring · 10/10/2026 03:01

Butterflyfluff · 09/10/2026 20:53

I would genuinely love to know how this is possible - our council tax, utilities etc are north of £10k per year before anything else.

It isn't possible because it obviously isn't true.

The poster has either made it up entirely or has missed out other key details such as their large income from benefits, being heavily subsidised by family, being able to buy a home outright from an inheritance, etc. It simply isn't possible.

Yogafiend · 10/10/2026 03:11

Shakespeareandi · 10/10/2026 01:55

Ha, I thought I was doing pretty well on 34k. I'm in the civil service. No wonder my friends on city wages looked at me pitifully when they were helping me w some financial disclosure things. Sad, really.

That’s the problem with civil service. I myself worked in the civil service for a period (whilst my kids were smaller) but I took a pay cut. Good for people with kids as flexible working but not great with pay.

rainingsnoring · 10/10/2026 03:12

Friendlygingercat · 10/10/2026 01:38

So how is it that a pensioner is expected to live on so much less than someone of so called working age?

We are not all millionaires with big houses that have risen in value or scroungers on pension credit who never saved.. Many are stuck in the middle with very modest occupational pensions. Many now rent, have to heat their homes and buy food, pay extortionate council tax. Many pensioners have more or less the same expenses so why are we expected to manage on less?

Because pensioners have much, much lower expenses than younger people and the state pension was only ever expected to give the bare essentials.

The great majority own their home outright so have no mortgage.
They can live in smaller homes as most don't need to accommodate a family.
They have less people living at home so bills are generally reduced.
Their food bill will be far smaller than for the average family.
They don't have all the many expenses of raising a family.

Only a small percentage rent privately and some of these will receive housing benefit anyway.

Apart from this, pensioners have already lived through their working life and many have been in a position to save up for their retirement. As a generation, pensioners are far wealthier than all other generations nowadays.

battairzeedurgzome · 10/10/2026 03:52

Silverbirchleaf · 09/10/2026 20:59

Try being a pensioner. They have half that to live on.

It's hardly breaking news that the state pension alone will not finance a comfortable retirement.

Trappedinthecastofawhodunnit · 10/10/2026 04:26

intrepidpanda · 09/10/2026 20:39

He is a tradesman
He earns £12, 570

He’s either spinning you are yarn or he’s grossly and illegally underpaid

Trappedinthecastofawhodunnit · 10/10/2026 04:39

Friendlygingercat · 10/10/2026 01:38

So how is it that a pensioner is expected to live on so much less than someone of so called working age?

We are not all millionaires with big houses that have risen in value or scroungers on pension credit who never saved.. Many are stuck in the middle with very modest occupational pensions. Many now rent, have to heat their homes and buy food, pay extortionate council tax. Many pensioners have more or less the same expenses so why are we expected to manage on less?

You get housing benefit, winter fuel allowance, you don’t pay National Insurance any more, prescription fees, eye tests, dental. You get cheap transport, discounted entry in to loads of places. You are more likely to have built up enough stuff to furnish a household. You can go on holiday in low season. It’s not the high life but there are more benefits than for a single person with no kids trying to build a life.

rainingsnoring · 10/10/2026 05:00

Trappedinthecastofawhodunnit · 10/10/2026 04:39

You get housing benefit, winter fuel allowance, you don’t pay National Insurance any more, prescription fees, eye tests, dental. You get cheap transport, discounted entry in to loads of places. You are more likely to have built up enough stuff to furnish a household. You can go on holiday in low season. It’s not the high life but there are more benefits than for a single person with no kids trying to build a life.

Exactly. This in addition to all the things I said above.
It's dishonest to pretend that the average pensioners has the same outgoings as the average family with children or the average younger, working adult.
It's even worse than the poster on the first page pretending that she has a household income of 20k with children and lives a very comfortable life.

Some pensioners are poor for various reasons but they are, overall, much better off than the generations that followed them and certainly have much lower outgoings.

dancehysterical22 · 10/10/2026 05:06

PaulBaker · 09/10/2026 20:19

My first wage as a teacher was £25k a year (11 years ago) and I thought I was loaded. As in cocktails in The Savoy loaded. 🤑 😭

Same 😂

IzzyGone · 10/10/2026 05:31

What’s crazy to me is in 1980 a factory wage unskilled for shift was £12,000

and now 46 years later people accept the media’s label of cost of living crisis, rather than suppressed salary structure

£24,438 for a 37hrs week

its suppressed wages and people accept being ripped of by large companies making millions of £ worth profit.

fumingrightnow1 · 10/10/2026 05:35

Fidgety31 · 09/10/2026 20:18

I think - I work full time demanding non stop mentally exhausting nhs job for not much more than minimum wage.
probably get more of if I didn’t bother and claimed benefits instead tbh .

You wouldn't benefits isn't anywhere near minimum wage unless you have very high housing costs and multiple disabled children which isn't something anyone would wish for

IzzyGone · 10/10/2026 05:45

FourFruitSalads · 10/10/2026 01:53

Plenty of well off people inherit a lot, often close to retirement age

Around 20% of people get an inheritance. That leave an awful lot of pensioners who don't.

Average age at inheritance is 47 peak is 55-65
average amount unt is £65k
tjats over the last 10 years and is at 22% of the population

in the next 20 years that will change to 55% of the population will receive an inheritance and £5.5 trillion will be inherited in the next 30 years

If the
£5.5 trillion in projected inherited wealth were divided equally across the entire UK population, it would amount to approximately £79,000 per person

£3.84 is from property

IzzyGone · 10/10/2026 06:12

Taking the £12,000 of an unskilled factory worker on shifts further, In 1980, strong trade union agreements routinely secured premium night rates of time-and-a-third (+33.3%) or time-and-a-half (+50%). In today's market, standard night shift allowances have compressed significantly, frequently hovering closer to +15% to +25%.

If an unskilled factory worker's salary of
£12,000 in 1980 had strictly kept up with inflation over the last 46 years, that wage would be £66,794.40

Comparison to Modern Night Shift Workers:
An unskilled factory worker working night shifts today typically earns a base rate near the UK National Minimum Wage plus a modest shift allowance. This brings average modern night-shift earnings to roughly £28,000 to £34,000 per year—meaning a worker today performing the exact same role has roughly half the purchasing power of that 1980 position.

in comparison unions have become weak with low membership but in teaching that trend hasn’t occured.

In 1980, the average salary for a school teacher in the UK was £7,350. If teacher wages had strictly kept pace with inflation over the last 46 years, that average wage would be £40,911.57 today.

However, unlike factory wages, modern teachers have actually beaten inflation. The average school teacher salary in the UK has risen to over £52,800

To add further context to the teachers salaries versus the unskilled factory worker with night shift

In 1980, entering the teaching profession was relatively low-paid in real terms (the equivalent of less than £20,000 today). Massive structural adjustments to the [DfE Teacher Pay Scales] have raised the modern minimum starting salary to £34,068 (and up to £41,728 in Inner London) to attract new graduates.

While a night-shift factory has seen de-unionisation, teachers have held on to their union which has helped them stay at a better pace with inflation.

Thecows · 10/10/2026 06:19

Poor @intrepidpandabet you wish you hadn't bothered now 😟

iamnotalemon · 10/10/2026 06:50

The problem is the housing costs. If they were reasonable, this salary would be manageable. (Though I do still think that people have a funny idea of what essentials are and need ‘x,y,z’).

iamnotalemon · 10/10/2026 06:52

CatamaranViper · 09/10/2026 20:50

And yet we have a gross income of £80k and struggle to make ends meet.
We're stuck in a debt spiral and have been for years. Can't get out. Every time one of us earns a tiny bit more, everything else becomes more expensive and we still can't pay off the debts we have.

@CatamaranViperThe debt is the issue here, not the salary. No judgement as I’ve been in debt myself and know how hard it is. Head to moneysavingexpert and see if his website can help you - it did me.

IzzyGone · 10/10/2026 06:53

iamnotalemon · 10/10/2026 06:52

@CatamaranViperThe debt is the issue here, not the salary. No judgement as I’ve been in debt myself and know how hard it is. Head to moneysavingexpert and see if his website can help you - it did me.

If your spending power keeps decreasing, of course debt will become an issue

Smokeywater · 10/10/2026 07:01

In the year ending December 2025, 813,000 people immigrated to the UK. This figure represents a decrease of 20% from the previous year.

I feel I live in a parallel universe as everyone is cheering as the number of immigrants has gone down but 813,000 people to be housed and cared for is nuts imv. I don't see house prices coming down ever if this continues. In fact they must surely go higher.
Then there's the high energy prices to pay for green energy - again this won't stop until we are covered in enough wind farms to power our homes - that's not coming down either.

Itsnotallaboutyoulikeyouthink · 10/10/2026 07:11

My student loan in 2000 was about £3-3.5k. It paid my rent, food and everything else for the year.

BabyCat2020z · 10/10/2026 07:16

Minimum wage is crazy as a lot of companies haven't caught up, so you have people on jobs they could walk into aan pick up in 2 minutes on a similar wage as jobs that need a degree and take 6-12 months to master. Property/ rent prices also bonkers, massive disparity between those renting a room in a house for £800 a month and those who live in a 4 bed house with low or fully paid mortgage as they got on property ladder 25 years ago. It's a broken system.

Sartre · 10/10/2026 07:18

MyFairLady27 · 09/10/2026 20:19

Well we get by nicely with kids,pets, new cars, holidays,no credit owed to anyone or anything. And get around £20k a year between us as I'm part time atm dh full..Takes good balancing and communication and we do fine and dandy

This is giving Yorkshiremen sketch. Unless you have no rent/mortgage, barely eat and don’t use electricity - how on earth does a family survive anywhere on 20k??

We earn 120k between us and things can be tight. We don’t get any handouts so everything we need is paid from our pockets. It’s hard not to feel bitter when we see SIL’s DC getting FSM, free breakfast clubs (hasn’t been rolled out at our school), free dentistry and so forth. We get nada.

iamnotalemon · 10/10/2026 07:18

IzzyGone · 10/10/2026 06:53

If your spending power keeps decreasing, of course debt will become an issue

@IzzyGone depends on what the debt has gone on. If it’s essentials, food, petrol, I understand.

Summerhillsquare · 10/10/2026 07:21

IzzyGone · 10/10/2026 05:31

What’s crazy to me is in 1980 a factory wage unskilled for shift was £12,000

and now 46 years later people accept the media’s label of cost of living crisis, rather than suppressed salary structure

£24,438 for a 37hrs week

its suppressed wages and people accept being ripped of by large companies making millions of £ worth profit.

Very much this. Wages have been surprised in order to turn millionaires into billionaires.

ChocolatesAndRainbows · 10/10/2026 07:23

HardFuckingBird · 09/10/2026 20:15

DH and I live off around £50k gross between us and we have a very comfortable lifestyle (we have two children in primary school). It's a perfectly reasonable household income in inexpensive areas (I realise it wouldn't go far in London or much of the south). In my area the problem is lifestyle creep. People's expectations are crazy compared to when we were children. When I was at school most families didn't have one foreign holiday a year, but now a lot of the families I know expect to be able to go away 3-4 times a year. Families often shared one old car - now most people I know have a luxury car per adult, often on PCP. Meals out used to be a rare treat - whereas now a lot of my colleagues feel entitled to coffees, lunches, takeaways and meals out every week.

This exactly,