Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not buy her a tail, so she can be like her friend who ‘is a therian’

57 replies

Laura9899 · Yesterday 23:34

My ten year old has a friend who seems nice and has sane sensible normal parents and yet she wears a tail and tells my daughter she’s a therian. I’m not in any way happy with all the furry rubbish and this feels along the same lines. My daughter has now asked to be a cat for Halloween, then asked for a furry tail as part of her costume, and now I think it’s actually so she can join in with her friend. They are only ten so it’s likely just play but there’s no way I’m letting her go out in a tail 🙄.

OP posts:
NewDogOwner · Today 01:15

Show her the pictures of Pride in Brighton with all the men dressed up as pups along with people in other fetish gear.

OneoftheWeddingPeople · Today 01:04

Agree with you op it’s weird and slightly sinister. Would not be facilitating

deadbobaplace · Today 00:59

I don't see why you can't let her be what she wants for Halloween? Being a cat is pretty innocuous compared to some of the costumes out there.

PotentialPartTimer · Today 00:58

I regularly wore cat ears and occasionally cat nose paint as a baby goth/emo teen 20 years ago. Shame the world's gone mad since then. We hadn't even heard of furrys.

ThatCosy · Today 00:55

I remember playing being horses with friends as a kid. The tail was imaginary. I'd relax a bit unless there's a massive reason not to.

InfoSecInTheCity · Today 00:54

@OakleyAnnie ways to ‘plug them in’ to your rear end that don’t involve an elastic band or clip 😂

GFBurger · Today 00:54

maggisimpson · Today 00:27

It's a slippery slope though, they start off reading Warrior Cats and making masks and then they... I'm not sure actually what the end of the slope is supposed to be 🤔
Think maybe it's got mixed up in the Mumsnet trans panic.

Slippery slope towards a love of literature, enjoyment of the outdoors and an A* in GCSE Textiles… shocking.

I agree. They are 10. It’s just play. There is no sexuality or sex involved.

Yellowcakestand · Today 00:51

There's playing. This type of play would be a young age. Not 10.
Agree with do not start on this path, no matter how minor

A relative of mine went full blown furry. Fur suit. Foreign travel to conventions. Turned out mostly fetish and grossly weird and inappropriate behaviour. Id worry about grooming for kids and teens here.

OakleyAnnie · Today 00:46

GFBurger · Today 00:01

It’s just a fad and a minor trend. She may start reading warrior cats too at the same time.

My daughter went through this and she was also making some very beautiful cat masks.

I let her make the masks and wear the tail at home. I also took her and her friends to some secluded forest type areas where she wouldn’t be seen being a therian.

It was relatively ‘healthy’ in that’s it’s hard exercise to try walking like a cat! And the crafting was fun and she was reading a lot too.

However, I did ensure I was telling her that this is just play and that it can be fun to pretend to be a cat just as it’s fun to play with Barbies. But she isn’t a cat, as much as she isn’t a plastic doll.

I also worked on her self esteem, encouraged other activities she could see progress in and made her realise it wouldn’t be safe to wear tails or masks in public.

So make sure she knows it’s fun to explore through play but you draw the line at her safety.

It probably lasted about a year. I think it was a fun thing to play with a few of her friends. She kept it quiet from lots of her other friends.

She’s slightly embarrassed by it all and thrown all her stuff out now. So much work went into those cat masks!! Almost sad to see it go.

Also… some of those tails come with ‘additions’ that a 10yr old wont understand, so make sure you open the package first!! 😆

What additions? 🥹

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · Today 00:35

what's this about BUYING a tail? can't she just make one?

I really don't see the problem with someone dressing up as a cat for Halloween - I definitely did this, when I was younger than 10. I never actually thought I was a cat!

Making a tail is not a particularly hard, or expensive, project. Why not encourage her to do some crafting?

maggisimpson · Today 00:27

johnd2 · Yesterday 23:55

"seems nice" but "wears a tail" . Shock horror!
I feel like it's back to the middle ages with the witch trials or something. Either buy your daughter a tail or don't but I don't see the need for all the moral consternation?

It's a slippery slope though, they start off reading Warrior Cats and making masks and then they... I'm not sure actually what the end of the slope is supposed to be 🤔
Think maybe it's got mixed up in the Mumsnet trans panic.

XmasCrackPies · Today 00:25

My daughter was into this for a while. One of her friends had unrestricted access to tiktok and was watching all sorts of weird stuff.

I bought the tail and ears and let her wear them on the understanding that she knew it was just play and she wasn't actually a cat/fox/wolf spirit or whatever they believe. The Therian phase came to an abrupt end after some older kids clocked on to what they were doing and teased them.

Just be careful if she has access to YouTube or tiktok. I went on a bit of a deepdive into it and some of the content can be disturbing.

maggisimpson · Today 00:24

I know loads of young 'therians' and it's just creative play 😂
They make masks and wear tails and gallop around the park on all 4s.

The moral panic over this is so strange. No, schools are not having to install litter trays because children are identifying as cats...

Papster · Today 00:20

Tell her you’re allergic to cats and she’s going to have to be rehomed or put down

Laura9899 · Today 00:18

It’s weird af.
the friend doesn’t have YouTube access or phone access I don’t think so I can’t understand how she is exposed to it.

OP posts:
Antisocial81 · Today 00:15

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · Yesterday 23:56

A lot of that sounds like just being a kid tbh

I’m not saying the Mum should validate or indulge all this being an animals stuff but the likelihood is she’ll grow out of it.

Really? I don’t recall any children being like this when I was a child, or my own children or their friends doing this. I think it’s nice to let children play make believe and be dreamers, but this is something else (driven by chat forums etc on the internet). It’s not pretending to be something (well it is); in their heads they ARE those things. It’s fucked up, not just part of a normal childhood.

HollyhocksandPeons · Today 00:05

Embarrass the shite out of her! Say 'what a wonderful idea! I shall join in', buy yourself a tail too and take her to school, wearing a tail, that is you wearing a tail. All the way to school and especially by school gates proceed to meow and if you care flexible and can bend, arch your back every now and then, if full view of other parents. That will quickly cure her of her idiocy.

Edited to add: Explain to her that if you are a cat and she is a cat, then daddy is also a cat and enlist his help with cat-like behaviour. And put a tray in the house and make her use it.

Laura9899 · Today 00:04

dustabsorber · Today 00:03

I am planning to reincarnate as a cat.

Yes, what a lifestyle 😆

OP posts:
Laura9899 · Today 00:04

There will be no package. I’m absolutely not letting her slide down this slippery slope.

OP posts:
dustabsorber · Today 00:03

I am planning to reincarnate as a cat.

GFBurger · Today 00:01

It’s just a fad and a minor trend. She may start reading warrior cats too at the same time.

My daughter went through this and she was also making some very beautiful cat masks.

I let her make the masks and wear the tail at home. I also took her and her friends to some secluded forest type areas where she wouldn’t be seen being a therian.

It was relatively ‘healthy’ in that’s it’s hard exercise to try walking like a cat! And the crafting was fun and she was reading a lot too.

However, I did ensure I was telling her that this is just play and that it can be fun to pretend to be a cat just as it’s fun to play with Barbies. But she isn’t a cat, as much as she isn’t a plastic doll.

I also worked on her self esteem, encouraged other activities she could see progress in and made her realise it wouldn’t be safe to wear tails or masks in public.

So make sure she knows it’s fun to explore through play but you draw the line at her safety.

It probably lasted about a year. I think it was a fun thing to play with a few of her friends. She kept it quiet from lots of her other friends.

She’s slightly embarrassed by it all and thrown all her stuff out now. So much work went into those cat masks!! Almost sad to see it go.

Also… some of those tails come with ‘additions’ that a 10yr old wont understand, so make sure you open the package first!! 😆

Besidemyselfwithworry · Yesterday 23:58

I mean I just wouldn’t tolerate this nonsense, end of

BibbityBoppityTwo · Yesterday 23:56

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · Yesterday 23:43

Its a fad. As long as she isnt insisting on using a litter tray just let her get on with it.

Agree. My daughter was into this around the same age. It’s just a fad that she’ll move on from. My daughter and all her friends were the same, we just let her have fun with it as make believe play and at some point they just lost interest and have heard nothing of it for years.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · Yesterday 23:56

Antisocial81 · Yesterday 23:50

It’s the thin end of the wedge. I know a girl who identifies as a boy (mostly, although sometimes she’s a girl and sometimes non binary). Also identifies as a range of different animals and wears tails and masks. And is gay (except when she’s not). Multiple changes of name too. And her mum just goes along with it all, and expects others to indulge her too. It’s mind boggling. I’d nip it in the bud now and bring her back to the real world.

A lot of that sounds like just being a kid tbh

I’m not saying the Mum should validate or indulge all this being an animals stuff but the likelihood is she’ll grow out of it.

johnd2 · Yesterday 23:55

"seems nice" but "wears a tail" . Shock horror!
I feel like it's back to the middle ages with the witch trials or something. Either buy your daughter a tail or don't but I don't see the need for all the moral consternation?

Swipe left for the next trending thread