Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why some Argentinians seem to want the Falkland Islands so much?

210 replies

Jane3212 · 24/09/2026 23:46

I really like Argentinian literature and would like to know more about the country- I don't know much at the moment.

However, I have read up on the Falklands War, especially after Milei's grandstanding and the World Cup, and I'm confused as to why there still seems to be a strong sense it was 'stolen' and 'needs to come back', and disregard for the wishes of the Islanders, among some Argentinians (I know many don't feel this way).
The war was terrible and Argentinian men were conscripted. But that was the fault of Galtieri. Argentinians suffered under the brutal junta: we had to defend the Islanders, or they would have suffered under it too. And aside from that, the Islanders don't want to be ruled by Argentina. Virtually no Argentinians live there, and it's not particularly large or rich in natural resources : why the obsession among some? It also seems odd to frame Argentina as a sole victim of colonisation by Britain when the modern country itself was founded upon colonising the indigenous peoples.

I was disgusted with Trump's behaviour : I'm sure he'd scoff at anyone saying that the US is an illegitimate settler state, but he appears to be leaning to Milei for his own ends.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Jane3212 · 24/09/2026 23:47

I know Argentina has been through hard times and still is in them, economically, but it would be much better to focus on their positive achievements and potential now, and not rehash territorial arguments. Spain still disputes Gibraltar, but they manage to have friendly links with it nevertheless. This kind of violent blackmail from Milei will just deepen divides.

OP posts:
RobinHumphries · 24/09/2026 23:48

They want the oil and gas deposits

TeenLifeMum · 24/09/2026 23:49

Geographically it is odd that it’s ours.

Jane3212 · 24/09/2026 23:50

RobinHumphries · 24/09/2026 23:48

They want the oil and gas deposits

Good point, I'd overlooked that.

But the invasion was of course in the 1980s, and there was a lot of public support. The dispute & emotion over it seems to date back further, too. The oil & gas was only found in 2010.

OP posts:
gillybombilly · 24/09/2026 23:51

As above, and gold exploration too.

Jane3212 · 24/09/2026 23:51

TeenLifeMum · 24/09/2026 23:49

Geographically it is odd that it’s ours.

Yes, but then geographically you could say it's odd Guadeloupe still belongs to France, or that so many white British descendants live in Oz. Yet that's how it's panned out. Most people living there are descendants of Brits and feel British.

OP posts:
dustabsorber · 24/09/2026 23:59

What if the Isle of Wight belonged to Brazil? How would we feel about that? I remember when the Falklands' crisis broke, I looked at a map of the UK, expecting to find the Falklands north of the Shetlands.

Parabendum · 25/09/2026 00:02

dustabsorber · 24/09/2026 23:59

What if the Isle of Wight belonged to Brazil? How would we feel about that? I remember when the Falklands' crisis broke, I looked at a map of the UK, expecting to find the Falklands north of the Shetlands.

Am I the only person who wouldn’t care if the Isle of Wight was owned by Brazil? Why should I care, assuming the people on the Isle of Wight wanted to remain Brazilian?

MyOtherProfile · 25/09/2026 00:07

Parabendum · 25/09/2026 00:02

Am I the only person who wouldn’t care if the Isle of Wight was owned by Brazil? Why should I care, assuming the people on the Isle of Wight wanted to remain Brazilian?

This.
Falkland Islanders overwhelmingly voted to be British.

dustabsorber · 25/09/2026 00:08

Parabendum · 25/09/2026 00:02

Am I the only person who wouldn’t care if the Isle of Wight was owned by Brazil? Why should I care, assuming the people on the Isle of Wight wanted to remain Brazilian?

You might be right. Imagine what Ryde carnival might be like.

PollyBell · 25/09/2026 00:11

Why does Britain want them so much?

DenizenOfAisleOfShame · 25/09/2026 00:43

I may be wrong, but I don’t believe the Falklands had inhabitants before Europeans got there. The first recorded visit was by a British ship. After that the French, Spanish and British set down tiny settlements over a few decades. They each may not have even known the others were there. After various withdrawals of all the countries the British asserted sovereignty in 1833.

Argentina’s claim to the islands is the weakest one possible. It’s nonsense really, just a distraction for their politicians.

Jane3212 · 25/09/2026 00:49

dustabsorber · 24/09/2026 23:59

What if the Isle of Wight belonged to Brazil? How would we feel about that? I remember when the Falklands' crisis broke, I looked at a map of the UK, expecting to find the Falklands north of the Shetlands.

By that logic, Guernsey and Jersey are nearer France than Britain, maybe France should have them back?

OP posts:
Jane3212 · 25/09/2026 00:50

PollyBell · 25/09/2026 00:11

Why does Britain want them so much?

Do you know the context? They overwhelmingly want to remain British, and we want to support them in that. If they didn't, I'm sure there'd be no issue. But they do.

OP posts:
ChestnutSquash · 25/09/2026 00:51

As pp said, they are sitting on a massive oil and gas supply. Huge.

OP posts:
Jane3212 · 25/09/2026 00:52

ChestnutSquash · 25/09/2026 00:51

As pp said, they are sitting on a massive oil and gas supply. Huge.

The dispute & emotion over it seems to date back further, too. The oil & gas was only found in 2010, the war was popular in 1982 and before that the dispute existed.

OP posts:
SemperIdem · 25/09/2026 00:54

Argentina want the Falklands because it is resource rich.

Argentina didn’t exist at the point the Falklands became a British territory. Nobody lived there at all. The British people who live there wish to remain so.

Argentina trying to grandstand now, after already losing a war over this, is tedious.

ChestnutSquash · 25/09/2026 00:54

Jane3212 · 25/09/2026 00:52

The dispute & emotion over it seems to date back further, too. The oil & gas was only found in 2010, the war was popular in 1982 and before that the dispute existed.

Yes, but the recent resurgence of the dispute is all about the oil, intensified by the current situation in the middle east.

lljkk · 25/09/2026 02:04

DenizenOfAisleOfShame · 25/09/2026 00:43

I may be wrong, but I don’t believe the Falklands had inhabitants before Europeans got there. The first recorded visit was by a British ship. After that the French, Spanish and British set down tiny settlements over a few decades. They each may not have even known the others were there. After various withdrawals of all the countries the British asserted sovereignty in 1833.

Argentina’s claim to the islands is the weakest one possible. It’s nonsense really, just a distraction for their politicians.

That... Las Malvinas haven't been Argentinian for almost 200 years.

The Falklands have had British settlers as their only residents for almost 200 years.
Who want to stay British.

The islands are VERY FAR from Argentina, too. They are very far from everywhere.

It's a very weird obsession and distraction from real political issues, I reckon.

montysmaw · 25/09/2026 02:05

Why does Britain want them so much?

WearyAuldWumman · 25/09/2026 02:33

montysmaw · 25/09/2026 02:05

Why does Britain want them so much?

It's the islanders who want to remain British.

montysmaw · 25/09/2026 02:42

WearyAuldWumman · 25/09/2026 02:33

It's the islanders who want to remain British.

They should perhaps live in Britain then.

PaperPanama · 25/09/2026 04:41

The Falkland islands were unoccupied before the Europeans started fighting over them. You could say that the French have greater claim than the Argentinians, because the British and the French occupied the islands at the same time, but the British threw the French out.

The Falklands are some 300 miles away from Argentina. That’s like the distance between Scotland and Norway, 1-2h flight.

Alaska is closer to Canada and to Russia than it is to the rest of the USA. What if they wanted Alaska? If Alaskans want to remain American, should they move to America because another country is closer?

To answer the OP: willy-wanging. Until oil was discovered. Then the desire for oil just wanged the willy more wildly.

HelmholtzWatson · 25/09/2026 05:19

montysmaw · 25/09/2026 02:42

They should perhaps live in Britain then.

"Go back to where you came from"

How progressive.