Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think his disability does not explain limited parenting responsibility?

14 replies

justhereokay · 23/09/2026 20:01

We have a toddler together. Her dad has MS and gets significant fatigue/physical limitations. I genuinely don’t fault him for that and I’m not expecting him to do things he physically can’t do.

He sees DD twice a week at my house for around 4-6 hours. He’ll play with her/supervise her so I can relax or pop to the shops, usually for an hour or two. But I need to do most of the childcare. He will change nappies and supervise her eating lunch or dinner. On Fridays his mum has DD overnight and he visits his mum’s Friday for a couple hours, and Saturday for a few hours. And his mum takes charge of her care. But this will change soon to my home/no overnight with nan. That’s another story.

He lives alone but his house has never been set up for a baby/toddler and DD has only been there a handful of times. He doesn’t know things like her routine, nappy size or shoe size. He pays £160 a month, although if I’m struggling and ask for another £20 for something like soft play he’ll usually send it without an issue. He doesn’t work and receives maximum PIP and UC. Tbh child maintenance would set it at £7 a week as he doesn’t work.

I do have another child, not bio his, but has been in his life for 5 years and considers him his own.

Meanwhile I’m the default parent 24/7. I have another child, chronic health problems and ADHD. Im up pretty late recent weeks writing job applications (NHS.. if you know, you know) and at uni part time. Money is tight and I’m trying really hard to build a decent future for my kids. My entire life/home obviously revolves around them.

He has a lot more freedom. Can sleep/wake when he wants, goes on holidays and to festivals, dates, sees friends/goes to the pub etc. I’m NOT saying he shouldn’t do those things because he’s disabled or a dad.

There’s also probably some historical resentment on my side. He cheated on me which led to the break up just before pregnancy, and about 5 weeks postpartum, although we technically weren’t properly together, he was staying at mine, sharing my bed and we were essentially behaving like a couple. Then with 3 days’ notice he announced he was going on holiday and I found out it was with another woman.

A friend recently pointed out that although his MS obviously limits the physical childcare he can do, it doesn’t really explain why he doesn’t know basic things about DD or take more responsibility for the nonphysical side of parenting. I’d never really looked at it that way before.

I just don’t think he takes much authority (right word?) or initiative as a dad. He asks me permission to take her to visit his dad or visit places while at his mums (I said.. she’s your daughter too, you have PR ? Im not some gate keeping mother). Everything about her routine, needs, teething, what she wants, his mum asks me. Because he has no idea, and he doesn’t take much interest to understand.

But we are on good terms, obviously there’s some hard feelings on my side, due to history. But I haven’t let this show, I just want my daughter to have time with her dad.

Also to point out, he’s never copped out of contact with her, although he’s 9 times out of 10 an hour late. He does clearly love her, interacts and plays with her when he’s around her. She knows he’s daddy and she adores him too.

AIBU to feel like I’ve perhaps excused too much because of his disability, and that he could take more responsibility as her dad even if that doesn’t mean doing 50/50 physical childcare? Or am I letting old relationship resentment colour how I see this?

OP posts:
Anothercake · 23/09/2026 20:10

If you take the MS out of it, you're left with yet another shit dad. And that's what it comes down to.

seahorsessky · 23/09/2026 20:15

MS can massively affect how you feel, and your confidence with things, not just physically. Previously confident friends diagnosed are the same-asking things they would once have just done without thinking. Was he the same when you lived together, or only since you broke up.
For people lucky enough not to have MS, or to have a "milder" variant which enables you to do these things, please don't have a go as you've not idea how it can be.

Grumpyoldcat · 23/09/2026 20:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

stichguru · 23/09/2026 20:31

To be honest there absolutely can be a much more mental side to MS. Obviously, this might not be the case with your child's father, he might just be a lazy, rubbish, uncaring father. However I spent 2 years volunteering for the MS Society in the guests' shop in one of their respite centres, and there were definately some people who had mental affects quite early on. Not like full blown dementia or anything, but people who would come into the shop and struggle to chose things or who struggled to organise money etc. Sometimes they would be the advanced patients in wheelchairs with multiple medical issues, but sometimes they'd be independently mobile and have all their physical abilities in fairly good order.

It is perfectly possible that your child Dad's can play with her etc, but not remember her routine, her shoe size etc, or organise appointments or trips etc. His core memory of facts like he has a child, children like to play may still be fully in tact, but his organisational memory and ability, like I need to check her shoe size, and all the stuff that goes with taking her shoe shopping may have gone. That is quite possibly called MS attacking his brain.

Coffeeandallthebooks · 23/09/2026 20:53

It is possible he simply can't remember these things. DH was a child carer for his mum with MS, and when he was 14 she called the police when he came home from school because there was a strange man in the house. She did it again a few months later.

I really sympathise with you having to deal with everything on your own, but many dads are like this without being ill, and there doesn't seem to be any way of making them take responsibility.
I'd hope if your ex is present when he's with dd, he will do more with her when she's older (and easier, hah) and you might get more time to yourself. But I really am sorry for you, it sounds like you're stuck with all the hard work.

AnnesPuffedSleeves · 23/09/2026 20:55

You posted about this just a few days ago, didn’t you? You wanted to limit his mum hosting overnight stays?

justhereokay · 23/09/2026 23:27

seahorsessky · 23/09/2026 20:15

MS can massively affect how you feel, and your confidence with things, not just physically. Previously confident friends diagnosed are the same-asking things they would once have just done without thinking. Was he the same when you lived together, or only since you broke up.
For people lucky enough not to have MS, or to have a "milder" variant which enables you to do these things, please don't have a go as you've not idea how it can be.

He had MS prior to us meeting. So I am familiar with how it can affect him. There’s been no change.

OP posts:
justhereokay · 23/09/2026 23:28

AnnesPuffedSleeves · 23/09/2026 20:55

You posted about this just a few days ago, didn’t you? You wanted to limit his mum hosting overnight stays?

Yes. Which they both agreed to with zero pushback which was unexpected

OP posts:
Thundertoast · 24/09/2026 00:05

I really, really appreciate that disabilities are complex and you can be well one day and not another, and some things take more energy than others, I do get all that. But... he can arrange and manage festivals and nights out and holidays and dating but he cant keep on top of what his own daughter needs? He cant show interest or ask you about her routine and then take notes? But he can show interest in new partners while dating and make arrangements with them? Sorry, its pointing to shit dad for me, but i am open to being educated by someone who knows more about MS. It doesnt feel like he is trying and struggling because of his disability, it reads like he isnt trying? Again, very receptive to someone being able to explain this behaviour.

Mrspatmoresapprentice · 24/09/2026 00:14

He can arrange and manage his own social life, and has the wherewithal and ability to have an affair, but can’t keep track of his daughter’s basic requirements and needs?

Getalittle · 24/09/2026 00:17

Hmm, I think he could do more. Maybe he will be better when she’s older. I’m chronically ill, had to pick up my child from school today, make her dinner, do all the usual and I could barely walk in a straight line as my balance issues are so bad and I have intense physical pain. But I don’t have a choice. He has the choice to opt out so he does. His loss.

Limiting overnight stays away seems to be shooting yourself in the foot though. It’s good for him and for her to get used to staying over and it gives you a break. Only reason I can think for not doing it would be if there were any risks to your child.

PPAPPINE · 24/09/2026 00:24

justhereokay · 23/09/2026 23:27

He had MS prior to us meeting. So I am familiar with how it can affect him. There’s been no change.

Taking this into account and the fact that he goes to festivals and holidays, he’s just a shit dad. Like diabolically shit.
I highly doubt mothers with the same illness and the same level of physical and mental impairment would behave the same way.

Everyone, including his mother has enabled and normalised it as well. It sounds like he’d be no different without MS.

Theresawaytobehonestandkind · 24/09/2026 00:26

Was the baby planned and wanted by him? Were you officially together when you conceived?

Lammpa · 24/09/2026 14:30

Mrspatmoresapprentice · 24/09/2026 00:14

He can arrange and manage his own social life, and has the wherewithal and ability to have an affair, but can’t keep track of his daughter’s basic requirements and needs?

But isn’t the opposite argument used about disability benefits? If someone says they can’t work due to a disability (whether a mental health issue or physical issue) but are married and have 5 children and take holidays with them etc everyone says that it’s totally possible to be able to care for 5 children and have a good social life with no problems but equally be unable to work. So why is the opposite not true? Why could it not be possible for a person with a medical issue (whether male or female) to be able to have a decent social life and go on holiday but be unable to care for a child well?

Would you say a person on disability benefits for say a mental health issue who does not work but is married, having an affair, goes on holiday twice a year and has 3 children should definitely be able to work?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page