Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want half of the pension after divorce?

1000 replies

DivorcingDebbie25 · 20/09/2026 21:46

Trying to avoid drip feed. Am sixty. Married 40 years. Kids are 40/38. I’ve never really worked. Husband had corporate career. I have been waiting for him to retire for years but it’s become clear that will never happen. He is rarely at home, constantly doing adventure stuff or pursuing his hobby. I’ve given up waiting and I want a divorce. He’s not fought me on it and clearly we are just done. I’ve moved out into rented and he’s paying my rent and expenses- clearing credit card etc.

We are reasonably civil but he says asking for half is ridiculous. He says that the only real assets are his massive pension fund, my smaller one and our house which we will sell. I think he should give me half the value of the pension fund but he says that’s not possible. He says half the house and then we combine the value of the pensions and I get the equivalent of half the income from it. Surely I can just ask for the value and then do what I want with it? It feels very controlling.

I will of course get a lawyer but wanted to check if I’m being unreasonable in asking for my half? What about future income / inheritance etc? Once I’m divorced do I lose all claim on that even though I’ve supported him to earn this money and to see the return on investments that won’t come through for a few years?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
fuzziestkiwi · 21/09/2026 08:22

DivorcingDebbie25 · 20/09/2026 21:46

Trying to avoid drip feed. Am sixty. Married 40 years. Kids are 40/38. I’ve never really worked. Husband had corporate career. I have been waiting for him to retire for years but it’s become clear that will never happen. He is rarely at home, constantly doing adventure stuff or pursuing his hobby. I’ve given up waiting and I want a divorce. He’s not fought me on it and clearly we are just done. I’ve moved out into rented and he’s paying my rent and expenses- clearing credit card etc.

We are reasonably civil but he says asking for half is ridiculous. He says that the only real assets are his massive pension fund, my smaller one and our house which we will sell. I think he should give me half the value of the pension fund but he says that’s not possible. He says half the house and then we combine the value of the pensions and I get the equivalent of half the income from it. Surely I can just ask for the value and then do what I want with it? It feels very controlling.

I will of course get a lawyer but wanted to check if I’m being unreasonable in asking for my half? What about future income / inheritance etc? Once I’m divorced do I lose all claim on that even though I’ve supported him to earn this money and to see the return on investments that won’t come through for a few years?

Solicitor here. There is a LOT of misinformation on this thread. Also ignore those asking about your own contributions/work etc - I have acted for so many people around your age and they generally have similar lifestyle set ups.

You have provided very little info but based on my experience the likely outcome will be:

  • House sold and divided 50/50 unless either of you needs more - for example if you need a larger deposit as you have a smaller or no mortgage cap (if you cannot both rehouse mortgage free)
  • Equalise savings
  • Income clean break, potentially with you receiving a lump sum to capitalise your claims to spousal maintenance
  • Pension sharing order to equalise your income on retirement - not necessarily dividing 50/50 on capital but on income

Do see a solicitor as every case depends on its own specific facts and there is a lot of misinformation on MN.

StillgotmyiPod · 21/09/2026 08:23

It's not ridiculous or gold digging or parasitical for one partner in a marriage to stay at home if that's what has worked for the couple concerned. It's none of anyone else's business.

As OP is 60, the courts will take into account that there is limited time and chance for her to earn a significant amount of money.

I would say a 50-50 split of the house and a portion of the pension - perhaps not 50% but in the region of 25 - 40% given the high value of it - is probably the likeliest outcome.

Butchyrestingface · 21/09/2026 08:24

FairKoala · 21/09/2026 08:17

Why should she?

The meal ticket can be cashed in for a fair amount and she doesn’t have to wait to live her life.

I would say that he thinks he has been ever so smart. Everything of any value is in his name whilst the house (in both their names) which is usually the higher value item is quite modest in comparison

I can see that he thought he would write off £400k to her but keep the millions he has been hoarding in his pension.

I think he has been planning this divorce for years.

Because she may find the grass isn’t always greener and that she finds herself in significantly more impoverished circumstances, despite all the promises from Mumsnetters about what she will or won’t get.

But a lawyer is best placed to advise on her individual circumstances.

Passaggressfedup · 21/09/2026 08:24

You are entitled to half of his assets as you supported him so You are entitled to half of his assets as you supported him so he was able to earn the money through looking after the children and latterly the home
No! OP is entitled to half because that's what you sign up to when you marry.

MN meme 'was able to earn the money through looking after the children and latterly the home' is what women tell themselves to relieve the guilt. They know it's a lot of crap. MANY families have two parents working FT in high paid roles. Women stay at home because it's what they want and/or did not have what it takes to get a career themselves.

Ultimately, a man who is a high earner should have the intelligence to know what a divorce would mean to what he thinks is his assets. If he was not prepared to accept that he would have to share half his pension in the instance of a divorce, he shouldn't have gone with OP being a sahm for all their married life.

Constantrunner · 21/09/2026 08:25

MN has real contempt for housewives.
Yes you are entitled to half of everything and you can get half the pension assets, rather than the pension income. There are different ways a pension can be split in divorce and pension companies are used to this.

ThisUmberSwan · 21/09/2026 08:25

bigboykitty · 21/09/2026 07:26

Have you never heard of marriage before? That is the legal contract they have in place between them.

Morally wrong either way contract or not. My partner works more than I do because we have children but in the event of if we got married which neither are interested and then split in 40 years I would leave that man’s hard earned pension alone.

NovaF · 21/09/2026 08:26

So to clarify

Your house is worth circa £800k and you will get half

Your husband wants to combine pensions, including his that is worth several million (lets say £3m).

you truly don’t believe you can buy a one bed over 60s property in London with a deposit of £300k and an income of millions from the pension? Why must you buy a property now instead of after the divorce? We bought a house in London with a much smaller deposit and do not have incomes of millions. Let me guess those properties you have been eyeing up have a nice postcode. So you can buy somewhere but they are just not in areas you want to live in. So entitled.

your husband paid into a private pension for you and currently pays your rent and yet you want more more more. You say he wanted the status of housewife and kids in private school but they left decades ago, and you had decades while he was off working more and more to work yourself. Don’t blame that on him, you didn’t work because you didn’t want to, your comment about ‘surely no one expects me to work in my sixties’, well yes normal people do.

foursquares · 21/09/2026 08:27

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 20/09/2026 21:55

I think he should give me half the value of the pension fund but he says that’s not possible. He says half the house and then we combine the value of the pensions and I get the equivalent of half the income from it.

Is.there financial illiteracy at play....

ie. Its a £1m pension and you want £500k cash? because if thats what you want its unreasonable. And the fact you never worked shows...
... he cant just give you 500k cash from a pension fund if he doesnt have 500k liquid assets.... which you'd also be entitled to half of anyway.so actually he'd need £1m in cash to buy you out of the £1m pension....

would you be happy If half the pension was transferred to a pension fund in your name ...?
if that happened you would get half the income so im not clear about what the issue is?

Edited

If he has access to his pension, and it's a DC pension, couldn't he just cash 50% in, buts she'd obviously pay 40% tax on it?

cattussuperior · 21/09/2026 08:27

Yes, I agree with @OutOfTheOtherSide, this thread is obviously a fishing trip…. But if nothing else, it’s made me very glad I have a career (as well as raising children, looking after the house, garden etc!)

UnemployedNotRetired · 21/09/2026 08:28

fuzziestkiwi · 21/09/2026 08:22

Solicitor here. There is a LOT of misinformation on this thread. Also ignore those asking about your own contributions/work etc - I have acted for so many people around your age and they generally have similar lifestyle set ups.

You have provided very little info but based on my experience the likely outcome will be:

  • House sold and divided 50/50 unless either of you needs more - for example if you need a larger deposit as you have a smaller or no mortgage cap (if you cannot both rehouse mortgage free)
  • Equalise savings
  • Income clean break, potentially with you receiving a lump sum to capitalise your claims to spousal maintenance
  • Pension sharing order to equalise your income on retirement - not necessarily dividing 50/50 on capital but on income

Do see a solicitor as every case depends on its own specific facts and there is a lot of misinformation on MN.

Accurate. Also be aware of rules about state pensions and pension credit. I assume you won't be entitled to a state retirement pension? You need to check that. Indeed that may mean you need a somewhat higher share to have some kind of equalisation of income in older age.

Goodgriefisthatrue · 21/09/2026 08:28

Yes you combine everything (your pension too) and split it 50/50 - thats how it works. Plenty of people work in their 60’s I am not sure why he should carry on paying for you.

FannybygaslightinGovan · 21/09/2026 08:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

foursquares · 21/09/2026 08:30

DivorcingDebbie25 · 20/09/2026 22:02

Yes I am a bit clueless. I don’t know how literally the ‘half’ is taken. So I understand I am entitled to half the marital assets but that would be the income from the pension not the actual cash equivalent then? I will need more cash than half the house to buy something of my own so was wondering if I could release it or have a claim on his future income somehow

You may be able to just cash in 50% of combined pensions, so say it's £1m, you get £500k, pay 40% tax, and end up with £300 (approx)

Somethinggg · 21/09/2026 08:31

Passaggressfedup · 21/09/2026 08:24

You are entitled to half of his assets as you supported him so You are entitled to half of his assets as you supported him so he was able to earn the money through looking after the children and latterly the home
No! OP is entitled to half because that's what you sign up to when you marry.

MN meme 'was able to earn the money through looking after the children and latterly the home' is what women tell themselves to relieve the guilt. They know it's a lot of crap. MANY families have two parents working FT in high paid roles. Women stay at home because it's what they want and/or did not have what it takes to get a career themselves.

Ultimately, a man who is a high earner should have the intelligence to know what a divorce would mean to what he thinks is his assets. If he was not prepared to accept that he would have to share half his pension in the instance of a divorce, he shouldn't have gone with OP being a sahm for all their married life.

This is true. And even assuming he had strong feelings about someone else being there all the time for the kids, it's been decades since that needed to be taken into consideration. OPs DHs revealed preference has been to stay married and not require that his wife works.

Pipsquiggle · 21/09/2026 08:31

Of course you should go after all that you are entitled to. I am glad you are going to see a solicitor.

It really frustrates me that some people on this thread are not being supportive. OP gave up her earning potential so that her DH could exploit his. This was a joint decision. He would not have achieved as much in his career as he did without a supportive wife who did all the heavy lifting with childcare and life admin.

Yes it may seem she's had a charmed life but she's had to put up with a very selfish man who does not appreciate his wife

dreamingofgoodhair · 21/09/2026 08:32

fuschiaproudparrot · 21/09/2026 02:39

What's she going to do for the next 20 years ? The world could be her oyster . She could remarry . She could travel extensively with her % of that pension. Why not ?

She’s already said she’s not interested in travel.

JustAboutHangingInThere · 21/09/2026 08:32

Your life and the choices you both made has worked for you up until now. You are entitled to half the marital assests. You are not a parasite, greedy or grabby. Ignore those comments.
Add everything up and divide by 2. He may choose to give you the cash equivalent value of his pension from his share of the house. Depends on the figures and his needs I suppose. You need robust legal advice. Good luck OP.

luckylavender · 21/09/2026 08:32

Poor bloke

Thinkofnewthings · 21/09/2026 08:34

Minasama · 20/09/2026 22:10

It was much more common for women in their late 50s and 60s to stop working to look after the children & run the house than it is now. I don’t think the law necessarily looks at what might be “fair”, it looks after women who are in this situation after fulfilling the expectations of society 30 years ago.

It really wasn’t. I’m 60 and worked throughout, part time when my DC were small, but I returned to full time later. I don’t know a single woman my age or a few years older who gave up work completely and for ever, even if the husband earned well.

OutOfTheOtherSide · 21/09/2026 08:35

cattussuperior · 21/09/2026 08:27

Yes, I agree with @OutOfTheOtherSide, this thread is obviously a fishing trip…. But if nothing else, it’s made me very glad I have a career (as well as raising children, looking after the house, garden etc!)

Totally agree! I also have a career, children, independence and, possibly most importantly, self respect.

Smokeywater · 21/09/2026 08:35

I am not sure why he should carry on paying for you.

Well, possibly because she can't get a job - someone who has never worked won't walk into a job easily at 60, come to that someone who has worked won't walk into a job easily at 60.
Such a trite remark.
I doubt she said when they married - right I'm going to do nothing and you've to support me forever - it would be assumed by both of them that she would stay home to provide a support for him and bring up his children.
It sounds as though he has earned enough for her to continue in a comfortable life why should he sail away in comfort but she shouldnt?

FannybygaslightinGovan · 21/09/2026 08:35

luckylavender · 21/09/2026 08:32

Poor bloke

Poor bloke fuck all. He knew what he was getting into when he got married and he's not exactly been a prince of a man throughout his marriage.

angelos02 · 21/09/2026 08:35

luckylavender · 21/09/2026 08:32

Poor bloke

This. He grafted for decades while you did nothing and now you want half of it?! You should get none of his money. You're young enough to get a job so best crack on.

FriNightBlues · 21/09/2026 08:35

So you’ve never had a job? Never lived independently, never fended for yourself? Never answered to an employer? Have you paid bills? Budgeted?

What on earth have you been doing since your kids left home?

Smokeywater · 21/09/2026 08:37

How do you know he grafted - I know very rich landlords of many properties who spend their time in their villa in majorca

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread