Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you had your chance to start again, would you still have had kids?

417 replies

Chefpig · 15/09/2026 07:36

The reason I ask is I can't have children of my own. I'm early forties now so time is ticking along. I'm single, so I'd be looking at adoption as a single person.

As a single person with no ties, I enjoy lots of holidays, meals out and doing what I want, when I want, yet there's this yearning inside of me for a child. I'm not sure if I can go through life not experiencing being a parent, but is it all it's cracked up to be?

OP posts:
Milly16 · 15/09/2026 08:58

A lot depends on the child. I love both mine equally and hugely but one, while I think they're amazing, doesn't give much back (but has taken plenty), and one has given me more back in love and joy than they could ever take. So while I could never regret either of them the personality and needs of the child is a big factor in how rewarding parenting is. In your shoes I would not adopt. Fostering can make a huge difference in a child's life and isn't such a commitment or stress.

Anythingbuthelpful · 15/09/2026 08:56

I can't say that I would definitely choose not to have children, because I did only have one child (by choice) and I wouldn't be without him now, but certainly becoming a parent impacted me as a person much more than I ever thought it would, and I had spent my entire life believing motherhood was the reason I was on this earth - the only thing I'd be good at.

I can confidently say that I could live a content, full life without a child. But that's something I have the benefit of figuring out when I've already got one and can weigh up the pros & cons.

It took me a good 3 years to not hate being a parent and there were many times I'd wished I had not done it. If I didn't have a child now, I would absolutely be making the most of that freedom and I think I'd die a happy, old (hopefully) lady with lots of other important people I'd "gathered" along the way.

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 15/09/2026 08:56

Yes, absolutely. But it's different for everyone. And adoption is wonderful but it can also be incredibly hard.

I don't think you can really know how you will feel about being a parent until you actually become one. For some, it turns out to be the best thing they've ever done. Others deeply regret it. Others are somewhere in between. You can't know which camp you would fall into.

LivingForTheWinter · 15/09/2026 08:55

Chefpig · 15/09/2026 07:47

Oh gosh. Why not? I think your post just put me off having any!

Really? You surely must have known that you'd get some people saying that, a quick Google would have told you some people regret having children.

bobbybigbollocks · 15/09/2026 08:54

I did a straw poll of my friends a few years ago. The responses were
Yes
No
Fuck no
Only the first one and not the next two
Yes
Yes
No.

SomeOtherUser · 15/09/2026 08:53

I love my kids beyond words, but if I had to do it all over again and I knew I wouldn't get the same kids, I wouldn't. I can't enjoy life fully because I worry so much about my kids and the clusterfuck of a world they are going to be left with. I would be a much more relaxed person if I didn't have those anxieties hanging over me.

BG2015 · 15/09/2026 08:53

Now that my children are adults and both working and independent I would say yes.

If you had asked me 20 years ago when they were 6 and 3 and their dad left and I had to cope as a single parent I would say no. Those years were tough, constant fighting between them (2 boys) little money and working fulltime.

Now they are adults and great company. I did an amazing job.

TheRobotsAreComing · 15/09/2026 08:52

Yes and no!

I would go back and wait for a better man. One who's financially stable, has empathy, loved me unconditionally... the behaviour of the man I chose completely marred my motherhood experience.

Children are hard work and parenting is better with money (sad but true)

CliffPsych · 15/09/2026 08:52

I don’t know. I would have not regretted it for 22 years. But having a child develop a serious health condition at 22 has given me a level of worry that I never knew possible. Life can change suddenly and it has made me wonder if this worry was worth it.

Blackwidowsbite · 15/09/2026 08:52

If I could do it all again no I wouldn’t have had them with the father I had them with and I would have waited until I was in a decent career and had my shit together first. That’s the brutal truth in my circumstances. I would have enjoyed life before hand.

MNLurker1345 · 15/09/2026 08:51

Yes absolutely! I have one DD, she and her little family are central to my life along with DH.

Being a parent and now DGP enhances my life.

Iocanepowder · 15/09/2026 08:50

No.

I love my kids but the impact it’s had on my freedom, mental and physical health and my enjoyment of life has not been worth it tbh.

The extreme lack of sleep has meant I spent quitr a long time spending each day wishing I was dead so I could get some rest.

Right now i have 1 in school and 1 in nursery, I work 80% over 5 days and it’s relentless. Always something to do or worry about. Life is often now about surviving the day instead of enjoying it.

Boxfulloftoys · 15/09/2026 08:50

No

MiceSpiders · 15/09/2026 08:50

Chefpig · 15/09/2026 07:36

The reason I ask is I can't have children of my own. I'm early forties now so time is ticking along. I'm single, so I'd be looking at adoption as a single person.

As a single person with no ties, I enjoy lots of holidays, meals out and doing what I want, when I want, yet there's this yearning inside of me for a child. I'm not sure if I can go through life not experiencing being a parent, but is it all it's cracked up to be?

It's really hard because I love my son more than anything, but he's neurodivergent and life is a daily challenge. I feel tired to my bones in a way I never did before I had children, but equally I can't imagine a world he doesn't exist in.

MyAgileUser · 15/09/2026 08:48

No.
and if I did, I wish someone would shake me and say DO NOT STOP WORKING.

DearlyDiego · 15/09/2026 08:48

Chefpig · 15/09/2026 07:47

Oh gosh. Why not? I think your post just put me off having any!

If a faceless comment from an anonymous, online forum would put you off having children, then you should probably just not have kids.

I'd still have children, but I'd have chosen their father more meticulously. Without him, I wouldn't have made the fabulous people I have today but my life would have been incalculably easier without him. Perhaps the kids and myself would have been happier. We'll never know.

But yes, I wanted children. I would still want children. But I'd want to have them in an easier life.

EndorsingPRActice · 15/09/2026 08:48

Yes, I love them and they have given me so much, they are young 20s now so I've experienced all their childhoods. They are definitely worth all the care and attention I've given them, and probably a great deal more. I had them in my late 30s and was getting bored of living life mainly for me. Would do it all over again very happily.

elaineyadayada · 15/09/2026 08:47

I think this is such a great post ! I had my kids later in life and very close together. I had a footloose life prior, great slightly glamorous job and it took my quite some time (!) to get used to the change as I was a SAHM.

I would really concur with the previous post. The cost of raising kids really has sky rocketed. We have felt it hugely as a family even in the last five years. Our two are nearly at the end of secondary.

These are the things I would really consider if adopting:
Kids can really reflect back your own failings/ complexities and internal complications and the way you relate to your self and others and not necessarily in a good way - sometimes like one of those freakish circus mirrors! The likelihood that any family stuff (from your own family) than is unresolved and relationships difficulties may come up, is very high and can have the most profound impact on your parenting / and the child for good or ill. I think this is what (can) make it so hard at times. I say this as someone who had an inkling of this and did some therapy prior to try and become more aware of my own background (which included maternal loss). It helped but was still really challenging.

Add to this the complexity and demands of a child you won’t know the true needs of if adopted. You can’t really know how it will impact them - until it all is revealed over time. We know so much about the perils of incomplete or troubled attachment.

I was surprised at just how physical a parent is - when they are little you’re always carrying them, loads of bags, lifting buggies, lack of sleep etc. When you’re ill and the GP says “You need to rest” you will make a hollow laugh. There is no rest - if your child needs you, you are the bottom of the pile.

I think the above are the reasons why it’s so demanding and can be extremely exhausting. The previous poster is quite right - external resources would be one of my first thoughts both in terms of human support and financial. Having a financial cushion is a massive massive help. The black cab when it’s pouring with rain and your child has a fever, emergency food shopping delivery when you’ve forgotten you have no food, money for activities to get out of the house, a cleaner because in the early years and if you’re working there are not enough hours in the day, money for a babysitter because if you don’t see your friends you will go mad (!), money for tutoring because they are struggling etc etc. They will drain your bank account! And of course back up emotionally so it’s not just you and them in your circle. Friends can be great but often it is family who will help. If they can and are able or willing to.

Having said all that - being a parent is a wonderful, wonderful thing and I echo a previous poster who said it was the privilege of her life. Nothing I’ve done comes close to the happiness and deep satisfaction and joy but it is a leap of faith and lots (and lots!) of self denial and hard work. I was not particularly maternal and did imagine having a good life without kids but I’m enormously happy that I ended up having them. They are funny, surprising, annoying, demanding, kind thoughtful and sweet. They are - as an older mum - still as late teenagers quite exhausting! I would take a really honest look at myself : do I have good support ? Am I fairly emotional together? What if having an adopted child means it’s unlikely I will have time to date for the next 5 years? Are there schools near me? What will I do if I have to take time off work (and there is lots of this). Etc etc.

PartyHard · 15/09/2026 08:47

Yes. And I say that as someone who has struggled badly at times with the grind of parenting, and as a parent of a disabled child - it’s been extremely hardgoing at times.

My children have completely changed me, and only for the better. I’m stronger, more compassionate and a better human being because of them. And as young adults now, they bring so much joy and energy and fun into my life.

However, I had them at 27 and 30. If I were single and in my early 40s, I would not choose to embark on parenthood, no. Parenting is a long, hard road and I wouldn’t choose to enter it alone and be spending my 50s and 60s consumed with the needs of others (especially an adopted child, with all the needs and issues that may come with that).

I say that as a perimenopausal 50 year old. The quite sudden onset of ‘no fucks left to give’ that has descended on me at this stage of life just doesn’t seem compatible with the unbounding physical and emotional energy, patience and selflessness required to parent children!

Chilly80 · 15/09/2026 08:46

Would i do it as a single mother? Hell no.

Sunsara · 15/09/2026 08:45

Someone else said it here. I love my children so much, there’s nothing like it. But it brings a whole new level of anxiety and worry. Are they happy? What will their life be like? Jobs are so incredibly hard to get for teenagers. My 18 year old is having a gap year and struggling to get anything. He’s applied for 100’s of jobs. Makes me worry for him. And that’s the bit of parenting that’s challenging for me. My heart and head being well depends on them being in a good place. I have a great life, great husband. Love spending time with my kids, always did when young and now as older teens. Would I do it again knowing the anxiety. Yes.

AngelinaFibres · 15/09/2026 08:44

I'm 61. It would be interesting to do my life again without children and without my first husband. A child free life with my second husband ( he has no biological children and we didn't succeed in having a child together) would have been very different and very luxurious. However, having children means you also possibly get the chance to be a granny ( I have 2 grandsons aged 2 and 4) and that is the most utterly and absolutely brilliant thing that has ever happened to me. I wouldn't change being a granny and living 10 minutes away from them for all the money/ travel/ freedom in all the world.

Dweetfidilove · 15/09/2026 08:43

My daughter is an amazing young woman, and yes, I'd have her all over again.

LiterallyGlowing · 15/09/2026 08:41

Don't do it OP. I wish I had the energy to explain all the reasons why. It will ruin your life in ways you can't even imagine. Especially considering your current lifestyle, your age, and the child you will be bringing up. I'm sorry. How about fostering?

momager22 · 15/09/2026 08:41

I’m child free op and I’ve never experienced that ‘yearning’ to have a child that you’ve described so maybe you do want to be a parent.
However I’m in a good relationship and we enjoy a relatively nice lifestyle so I don’t feel like I’m ’missing out’ on anything in life if that makes sense. Perhaps that’s the single side of you wanting a family unit rather than the child free side of you, if that makes sense ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread