Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect people to respect a shy dog’s boundaries?

63 replies

TheLivelyCat · 14/09/2026 07:08

AIBU That people should listen to dog owners?

Yesterday I was out with my dog, lovely sunny afternoon, so we went on a long ish family walk 2.5h by the river. My dog was swimming, there were other dogs, cows in the feild at one point, quick outdoor cafe stop. basically dog heaven, mix of on lead and off lead,

Anyway on the way home 1h drive. I stopped at the pet store to get some ear cleaner, due to dog swimming in 2 different rivers this weekend. DH ran into the supermarket across the road and 1 took dog and children to the pet store, should gave been a 5 minute stop to get 1 thing.

My point is and this isn't the first time this has happened is my dog is friendly but shy. (Not recative, just slow to warm up) shes also a Labador who everyone assumes wants to say hi to everyone.
So when people ask to say hi to her I will say she might say hi but shes shy. Sometimes she will give someone a sniff or sometimes she will back away to increase her bubble.

Most people will respect her and read her cues and usually she will say hi within a minute or 2.
However some people seem to think they are the dog whisper and try to override me, saying she has to get used to people saying hi, and tell me how good they are with dogs.......

Yesterday's Example has annoyed me. Customer in pet shop ask to say hi. On her approach dog walked behind me. "I said she's shy and shes had a big walk and tired so she probably won't say hi". Anyway the Lady seemed to take it as a personal insult, and walked away only to come back 30s later and try again, looking sorry for my dog. My dog was fine, just didn't want a fuss off strangers, and was standing in the cue calmly as I payed.
Its not the first time that self proclaimed dog experts have done this to us.

We are slowly working on gaining her confidence, for example people she meets on walks she knows shes greets them friendly and lively, and she will now take a treat from the pet store staff ect.

OP posts:
Flamingojune · 14/09/2026 11:20

Gertlushthatis · 14/09/2026 10:51

As a dog owner, I'd say stop taking your dogs into shops, including the pet shop. Why not just get DH to nip in and wait in the car? Also get a yellow lead so people are aware.

I've never heard of yellow leads.

Cheese55 · 14/09/2026 11:21

TheLivelyCat · 14/09/2026 07:19

Yes she is a yellow lab. Not a bad bone in her body, but like you say reserved till she knows you.
People wouldn't do this to a shy child, so why a dog. Shes the equivalent to the shy child that hids behind there parents.

She's not a child.

Turnedtochaos · 14/09/2026 11:21

I set boundaries myself.

No sorry you can’t touch them because of whatever reason.

I have giants and it’s hard but if I didn’t I would have people touching them constantly!

BibityBah · 14/09/2026 11:23

Flamingojune · 14/09/2026 11:20

I've never heard of yellow leads.

They have the word 'anxious' printed on them repeatedly.

But I found people couldn't see that from farway with off lead dogs anyways.

And its not a universally known thing that a yellow lead = anxious dog.

Plus a lot of the types of people that allow off lead dogs to approach on lead dogs wouldn't care anyways or be able to read

OriginalSkang · 14/09/2026 11:28

Someone I know used to have an extremely grumpy jack Russell, and people would try to overrule her even when she told people not to approach him because he wasn't friendly! She didn't take him into the pet shop obv though

Not quite the same, but people used to do this with my terrified cat too - not believing that he was scared. I think a lot of people don't really understand cats though

TheLivelyCat · 14/09/2026 11:44

Melsy88 · 14/09/2026 11:09

Sorry, but this is a load of rubbish. If a dog is well behaved and minds its own business, you should be able to take it to a shop/cafe/pub without people approaching.

Yes. She is well behaved in public, she doesn't bother anyone, and if another dog barks at her she just looks and carries on walking, she actually loves other dogs and people she knows.
She just isn't a fan of random people thinking they have a right to stroke her.
She will sit fantastically at dog friendly pub/cafe you wouldn't know she was there. She happy to sit and people watch, offen with a waggy tail. Hoping we will drop food.

Its just when people think they have a right to pet her because she's there, I myself don't want random people coming to my table if im trying to have a meal ect, dose that mean I shouldn't be in public places too.

If she was reactive, barking, a risk to the public I wouldn't take her to those kinds of places, but after a long walk, hike ect sometimes we do stop off. will sit outside if possible and weather on our side. Shes done it from being young, We live in a very touristy place, and lots of walking opertunaties local to us.

OP posts:
OnlyFannys · 14/09/2026 11:49

We have 2 super friendly dogs and one nervous/shy dog so we got her a bright yellow harness with "nervous dog" written all over it and its really helped with boundaries and people seem to take it less personally now that she hides

Flamingojune · 14/09/2026 12:37

TheLivelyCat · 14/09/2026 11:44

Yes. She is well behaved in public, she doesn't bother anyone, and if another dog barks at her she just looks and carries on walking, she actually loves other dogs and people she knows.
She just isn't a fan of random people thinking they have a right to stroke her.
She will sit fantastically at dog friendly pub/cafe you wouldn't know she was there. She happy to sit and people watch, offen with a waggy tail. Hoping we will drop food.

Its just when people think they have a right to pet her because she's there, I myself don't want random people coming to my table if im trying to have a meal ect, dose that mean I shouldn't be in public places too.

If she was reactive, barking, a risk to the public I wouldn't take her to those kinds of places, but after a long walk, hike ect sometimes we do stop off. will sit outside if possible and weather on our side. Shes done it from being young, We live in a very touristy place, and lots of walking opertunaties local to us.

Comparing yourself having an undisturbed meal to a dog not wanting to be petted is a bit of a stretch

EmeraldShamrock000 · 14/09/2026 12:40

Just say she is not friendly. End of. Don’t make excuses. My dog is unpredictable. I warn people from a distance. Mind you I wouldn’t take her the pet shop either as there is always kids, dog lovers and other dogs.

CalmTheFuckDownMargaret · 14/09/2026 12:42

I had this. I then began telling people ‘don’t touch her - she’s being treated for ringworm.’ The approaching / touching stops immediately. A shout of ‘she’s got a bacterial infection - can you recall your dog?’ soon kicks crap owners into action.

Katiepants27 · 14/09/2026 12:50

You need to be a better advocate for your dog.
She is telling you she doesn't want interaction with strangers and you need to listen to her. Just say "no, but thanks for asking" when people ask to pet her.

If you carry on being vague, she may lose her trust in you and start advocating for herself (I.e. escalating to growling/snapping)

I have a dog who hates being intentionally touched by strangers. She is completely non reactive and can be walked through the heaviest of crowds because she trusts me 100% that I will advocate for her. If anyone asks to pet? "No, she's not friendly, but thank you for asking ".

omghereistrouble · 14/09/2026 13:54

if you just leave your dog in a car or at home it will be a miserable life for it.
to socialise it then you need to introduce it to places that you will be visiting often.
no reason why a dog cannot enjoy a pet shop without being grabbed.
if i see a dog i like which is all of them! i just smile and say to the owner what a lovely dog or name breed, if unsure i ask oh what a lovely dog what breed? the owners are friendly and then you can ask if you can touch but if the answer is no then i just smile and say hope you both have a nice walk/visit

SoVeryVeryBored · 14/09/2026 20:39

Cheese55 · 14/09/2026 11:21

She's not a child.

And what’s your point? Don’t impinge on the personal space of another creature.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread