Trans men are women according to Gender Critical Movement

6' 2" is fairly tall for a man in the UK where the male average height is 5' 9".

It's extremely unusual for a natal female. Fewer than 1% of women are over 6'.

I don't think I would clock Jamie Raines. Partly because he is 6ft 2 so unusually tall for someone born female.

If he were 5ft 4 (average female height) then I probably would

You know Fripp, I read this thread back early this morning because I wanted to get my head around what had and hadn’t been said and done because something has felt disconnected and discordant. I think you are certainly onto something here.

I am sorry that I missed this Fimofriend. I cannot remember the specifics, but D.H was a regular poster here for quite a while under their own name in some form. They stopped posting on MN pretty soon after.

My name means enough4me of the lies that single sex spaces are magically not needed now some men say they want them to be unisex spaces.
If any posters here are in doubt:
no thanks to men in our spaces.
You want them in your spaces, loos, prisons, wards, sports then create third spaces and join them.
Although, how many men pretending to be women want to undress next to other men pretending to be women?

Did you miss this bit of that particular OP?

“FYI: I've name changed for this to avoid a pile-on.”

It was the very first sentence.

Good advice, Rufus. Though I doubt anyone is going fo start discussing what username is who. Because that is not the point and as you say, it is irrelevant.

The point is that the poster announced that they had name changed on the thread. It wasn’t rocket science. The poster was upfront that they name changed.

Please enlighten us as to who this person is

i really don’t think this is a good idea

i am crap with name changes, absolutely pants

That is interesting, thanks for raising the issue. Do name changes confuse you so you can only recognise patterns in posters who don’t change their usernames, and don’t see patterns in posters who change usernames?

Why do you regularly claim to know who people are and that they are hiding behind name changes? It's a claim you make quite often. These are all anonymous strangers on an online forum, how you can possibly claim to know who anyone is?

Please enlighten us as to who this person is.

I know. Cornflakes doesn't realise they are proving the point of women.

Or maybe they are a double agent?

Anyway, lets stop feeding Cornflakes.

The detraction from the point of the thread is deliberate.

Women, as a sex class do not include men, even ones who really think they are women.

There is no excuse for males to be in women's single sex spaces when they know that many women say no.

Males, (including transwomen) who engage in such behaviours are predators. They literally don't care about women's consent.

But it is such a good example of gaslighting from TRAs.

Honestly, you have some gall saying that Helleofabore is engaging in 'hidden bullying.

Anyone reading these posts can see who the aggressor is.

It is this simple basic logic that was responsible for the term transsexual being coined - so yes, an individual can change their biological sex and a post op transgender woman is therefore a biological woman.

So if I have to have my breasts removed and a hysterectomy, does that make me a man?

You CANNOT change your biological sex because your chromosomes are in every single cell of your being.

Cutting off your penis and having a new surgical fistula produced does not make you a woman, nor does having a large penis shaped organ sewn to your mound of Venus make you a man.

“yet the accused thinks nothing of posting a bullying hidden emoji.”

should be

yet the poster thinks nothing of posting a bullying hidden emoji.

They also never acknowledged how that thread appeared on another social media platform where posters are regularly bullied.

apologies.

They also never acknowledged how that thread appeared on another social media platform where posters on MN are regularly bullied.

this one you mean?

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/sitestuff/5261547-fwr

Where the poster, a known regular, despite the name change. posted a thread that mischaracterised other regular posters actions while never acknowledging their own negative generalisations in their posts and that they resort to personal attacks as they did on that thread.

Something they conveniently didn’t mention. The name change didn’t hide who the poster was.

They also never acknowledged how that thread appeared on another social media platform where posters are regularly bullied.

You assume incorrectly.

The reason you won't read the comments is because you prefer to bury your head in the sand - if you read the comments you'll be forced to realise many of them make sense.

They turned up asking for receipts. Naturally. They didn’t get any (shock).
Wash rinse repeat. And to some this is ‘shouting down’ and ‘mocking’.
No. You state something you at least try and back it up with something, anything. If you can’t you’re going to be called out.

You're not the only one who's noticed.

A few weeks ago someone posted in site stuff complaining about this behaviour on the FWR board, they all turned up there and shouted her down while mocking her between them.

It was quite incredible. The irony was shocking.

I think it might be a good idea for you to sit down and have a jolly good think about where on earth this nonsense came from.

This has come out of nowhere and has only been around for about 10 years. Those of us like me who are in their 60s never met a single person throughout our entire schooling, our neighborhoods, our clubs, our groups, our families, our college, our university, our workplaces who identified as being the opposite sex and then went around aggressively demanding that everyone bows down to their wishes, their pronouns, and all the rest of the nonsense that goes with it.

It is hard to follow isn’t it? There have been accusations that posters have bullied, yet the accused thinks nothing of posting a bullying hidden emoji. Accusations of mocking, yet the poster has accused posters of posting nonsensical comments and stupid questions.

All while declaring they cannot express an alternative opinion while posting accusations and what amounts to personal attacks while
posting thos alternative comments. It is a form of negative feedback farming, post an opinion, but include comments that dismiss, or diminish or derogate others so peoole respond and accusations of not accepting that alternative opinion are made.

And when the behaviour is pointed out, posters need to seek help and who cares anyway?

It is remarkable really. But it isn’t surprising from posters who dismiss women who state that they need single sex toilets. It does seem all too familiar.

and now with the exaggeration

Sorry which posts specifically do you mean ?
Can you elaborate .