Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you love your partner more than you love your parents?

115 replies

Selenaso · 15/02/2024 05:19

Or is it just a different kind of love? (Assuming you have loving relationships with both your partner and your parents, which I recognise that not everybody does). I’m single, and my parents still very much feel like my emotional centre. Obviously I’m sure when you get into a serious relationship that shifts, but I’m curious whether you feel like your partner replaces your parents as the emotional centre/sense of home, or it’s more like you gain multiple centres?

YABU - I love my partner more than I love my parents, he (or she) is my emotional centre now

YANBU - it’s a different kind of love, not greater or less, they are both emotional centres for me

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
bradpittsbathwater · 01/11/2025 15:41

Why bother thinking about it/comparing? Seems weird

PigletIsWorried · 01/11/2025 14:57

It's complicated. I don't think it's necessarily easy to quantify love in terms of more or less. It is a different kind of love.

I love my parents in a way which feels biological or mandated. It's not an uncomplicated relationship, I have a lot of trauma from a childhood which was emotionally abusive (notwithstanding that I believe my parents loved / love me), but loving them feels like some kind of imperative.

My husband is my home, safety, comfort, security. He's the person I rely on and turn to for advice, support and comfort. I trust him a thousand times more than I trust my parents, I would choose his well-being over theirs in some horrific hypothetical where a choice had to be made.

Patatatamata · 01/11/2025 14:52

I'll reopen this old thread: when your parents are unrepentant are white ethnochristofascists supremacists and you didn't even realize it until you were in your twenties because of the control and the isolation and the lying and the emotional and physical abuse (he flung my 110-pound, 14y/o body at walls and furniture—the house had a broken couch for years because he threw me at it so hard I hit the back and it flipped backward over me, and this was one week after he grabbed me by the neck, choked me, and threw me by the neck at the kitchen table) and normalization of violence in the "home" and the disgusting grooming for an adulthood of passing on that disgusting stuff, there's really no reason to love them, because loving that rotting carcass of a situation will only make you sicker. My daughter is 20, has no desire to communicate with them (she is half Mexican and queer—the antithesis to my worthless birthright) and she has actual, real, substantive values.

PoliteTurtle · 17/02/2024 20:51

ALittleFreakedOutby · 17/02/2024 18:52

I love how other people have the same opinion but I’m immature bc I said my age

LOL. It's because you have a fixed idea and cannot conceive that your personality and you will change as you age and with experience. That is what is immature; your blinkered ridgity and accusing @Immemorialelms of being patronising just for pointing out to you that you are probably wrong. Saying at the age of 26 that you would never date again if your DH left you or died is completely different from saying that aged 70 as a widow or a divorcee.

And while we are about it, starting a thread at 1am fishing for other people's views to support your irrational position just because strangers on the internet have pointed out to you that you are likely to be wrong is obviously the height of maturity!

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/amibeingunreasonable/5009006-would-you-date-again-if-you-were-suddenly-single

Edited

Is this whole site not others asking for other peoples views?
Oh yes apologies I was up in the wee hours, is that immature too?

I never said my personality won’t change? I simply don’t believe I would want to date again in the event my partner wasn’t there..? What is this 😂

Edit: also, it can’t be too irrational if so many people agree?…🤭

YukoandHiro · 17/02/2024 20:50

Every relationship is different. Do I love my best friend more than my husband? Do I love my child more than my husband? One child more than another?
You can't answer these questions because each relationship between two individuals is unique. The love i share with each of them is powerful.
I guess what makes children exceptional is that you expect (biologically) to outlive you, so if you lose a child the grief is markedly different to any other relationship.

HeadNorth · 17/02/2024 20:49

I love my parents but my DH is my safe space and home in the way they weren’t - they were pretty flaky when I was growing up. Ironically, it is from my DH that I feel the unconditional love you are meant to get from your parents.

DillDanding · 17/02/2024 20:47

If I had to rank them, yes, I love my husband far more.

Ulysees · 17/02/2024 20:46

@HideTheCroissants at least you're honest. Can't relate and my dcs are adults. I love my dc unconditionally. Nothing they could do would change that. Whereas if dh fucked up I'd get rid.
Dcs are fantastic so not much chance of them doing anything terrible.

HideTheCroissants · 17/02/2024 18:58

I love my husband more than anyone else on the planet. Yes - even more than our children. I realise that in MN world that makes me a monster but there you go. He loves me more than he loves the children too. BUT I assure you we do love our children very much - just not more than each other. 🤷‍♀️

ALittleFreakedOutby · 17/02/2024 18:52

I love how other people have the same opinion but I’m immature bc I said my age

LOL. It's because you have a fixed idea and cannot conceive that your personality and you will change as you age and with experience. That is what is immature; your blinkered ridgity and accusing @Immemorialelms of being patronising just for pointing out to you that you are probably wrong. Saying at the age of 26 that you would never date again if your DH left you or died is completely different from saying that aged 70 as a widow or a divorcee.

And while we are about it, starting a thread at 1am fishing for other people's views to support your irrational position just because strangers on the internet have pointed out to you that you are likely to be wrong is obviously the height of maturity!

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/amibeingunreasonable/5009006-would-you-date-again-if-you-were-suddenly-single

Would you date again if you were suddenly single? | Mumsnet

Sorry, I realise this could be abit of an insensitive question so I’ve tried to phrase it correctly… Say for example you just found yourself as you ar...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5009006-would-you-date-again-if-you-were-suddenly-single

mrskimsneakattack · 17/02/2024 15:07

No DCs here, I love DH and the dog way way more than anyone else. My dad died when I was young, I get on fine with DB but we are not particularly close, and I've always had a bit of a tricky relationship with my mother.

PoliteTurtle · 17/02/2024 15:02

ALittleFreakedOutby · 16/02/2024 23:49

Oh, I found that comment really patronising 🤨 I hate this notion that I don’t know what I’m talking about because I’m in my 20’s? I definitely do know… I’ve been through enough to know what I want and why…. but thank you anyhow

@Immemorialelms was exactly right @PoliteTurtle and your initital position and your further responses, particularly your insistance that you are right and that there is no other option betrays your immaturity.

In fact, that you truly believe with such utter confidence in your twenties that if your partner died that you 'would never date again', underlines that immaturity. It's a sign of maturity to appreciate that your personality changes sometimes in quite fundamental ways as you age and experience life. Grief particularly changes people especially loss of a life partner at a young age.

It's very sad that you can't actually open your mind to the idea that you are most likely wrong in your certainty but at the very least admit that it is a possiblity that you are wrong.

Okay strangers from the interweb, I’m immature 😂
Is my life story on file or something?.. no I didn’t think so…
I love how other people have the same opinion but I’m immature bc I said my age 🤭 Sure thing…

BigFatLiar · 17/02/2024 09:16

It's just different. Same with children.

I remember years ago there was a survey about families of who the children loved and poor old dad came below the family dog.

Shiningout · 17/02/2024 09:01

I hate all this 'who do you love more' crap. It's very possible to love multiple people in your life without having to put them in an order, it's a strange way of thinking to me.

Hoplolly · 17/02/2024 08:59

Way more. I'd do anything for my DH. My parents whilst not bad parents, were not great parents. I have no idea why they ever had children, they had such a lack of interest in me growing up. I don't feel that close to them, most like extended family.

mrlistersgelfbride · 17/02/2024 08:57

It sounds awful but the love for either of them is nothing compared to how I feel about DD. I love her the most, more than anyone.

I would say actually I love my brother 2nd most. We are very close.
Then it's my mum.

My dad and partner are further down the list. I have a difficult relationship with dad, always have. He's very short tempered and intolerant. It's hard to be around him.
And me and partner are mostly together for DD, unfortunately.

scaredofff · 17/02/2024 04:38

My mum has recently been diagnosed with cancer and the fear of possibly losing her has made me realise how much I love her and you only get one. Once she's gone that's it. Awful

Yanbu - I love them both very very differently and couldn't be without either for different reasons. They both (and ds/dgp) are pieces of a jigsaw that make up my heart

NoBinturongsHereMate · 17/02/2024 01:16

Wednesdaysotherchild · 16/02/2024 17:25

Neither of them are my emotional centre! I am my own emotional centre. Thanks to therapy.

DP is autistic so can’t, parents both immature & self-centred.

I'm glad someone else said this. I was beginning to think I was odd. My emotional centre/sense of home lies within.

As for whether I love parents or partner more - well, it's a bit like asking whether apricots are better than bicycles. Totally different things, with different purposes; too different to compare.

Being born into a linguistinc environment that has umpteen words for types of precipitation but only 1 for love makes it difficult to discuss the distinctions of storge, philia and eros - but they are not interchangeable just because we lack individual words.

WearyAuldWumman · 17/02/2024 00:15

I don't know how to answer this but...It hurt when I lost each of my parents. When my husband died, it felt as though my life had come to an end.

herewegoagainy · 17/02/2024 00:13

When you are in a long happy marriage, the love does get deeper. It is different to being married for a shorter length of time.

KThnxBye · 17/02/2024 00:13

I’ve known my partner longer than I’ve known my parents. I’ve lived with my partner for longer than I ever lived with my parents.

yes, I absolutely love him more than anyone else except my children.

bozzabollix · 17/02/2024 00:10

It’s a weird question to think about, I’ve been with my husband for longer than I was ever with my parents. I remember having a really bad stomach once which hurt, and you know that feeling you get when you’re hurt as a child and you just want your mum? I had that but it was for my husband. Funny really because we’re not lovey dovey and I wasn’t guaranteed huge levels of sympathy! But I did feel better with a hug. It was then I knew everything had shifted.

herewegoagainy · 17/02/2024 00:07

My mother loved me unconditionally. She did not know me as an adult like my husband knows me. He knows me inside out as we have lived together for decades.

Lennon80 · 17/02/2024 00:04

ALittleFreakedOutby · 15/02/2024 23:34

It will depend on your parents surely. The love will be different because its a different kind but the love for your parents will be unlikely to be trumped by your partner if you had good parents.

If you had great parents, no one will love you like your parents because it's that unconditional love thing particularly for women - no man will love you like your father if you had a great father.

A partner is someone who has randomly chosen you and you randomly chose - they could have chosen many other women, are likely to have loved at least some other women, and no matter how devoted you think they are to you, history shows they can leave at any time for a younger model/your best friend/the postman. The same is true for you - a random choice based on luck, who you happened to meet, how you felt at the time, wehther you were in a space for a relationship and so on.

Your mother and father will always be your mother and father and again repeating if you had good, kind, stable, loving parents, that is the kind of love that you cannot get anywhere else. Equally the love you have for those kind of parents runs very deep and is very profound.

No matter how much you think you love your partner, the reality is if he died tomorrow and you are young enough, you would meet someone else different and love again. You can't get new parents in the same way.

It's a joyful thing to come from a loving happy parentage and anyone who has that is very blessed.

Agree 100%

MrsSkylerWhite · 17/02/2024 00:00

Yes, absolutely.