Got a question about going dairy-free? Dietitian Kate Arthur answers your questions - £200 voucher to be won

(119 Posts)
LucyBMumsnet (MNHQ) Mon 11-Oct-21 09:58:49

Created for Alpro

Ever thought about going dairy-free but wondered how it might affect your health? Post your questions to registered dietitian Kate Arthur, and you could win a £200 shopping voucher.

- Everyone who shares a question on the thread below will be entered into a prize draw
- One lucky Mumsnet user will win a £200 voucher for a store of their choice (from a list)
- Kate will be back at the start of November to answer a selection of your questions

About Kate:
“Kate Arthur is a Registered Dietitian with 25 years experience. She is passionate about promoting easy to understand nutrition and dietary advice for adults and children. Having worked for a number of years as a Dietitian for Alpro she has helped to promote the importance of plant based eating for both health and the planet.”

Here’s what Alpro have to say:
“With an increasing number of people wanting to lead a more plant based lifestyle, Alpro is on hand to ensure that parents are equipped with the tools and information to be able to follow a nutritionally balanced, healthy diet. Alpro Soya Growing Up drink and the new Alpro Oat Growing Up drink are tasty alternatives to cows’ milk and are formulated to provide nutrients tailored to the needs of children aged 1 to 3 years.”

So whether you have a question about the health or eco benefits of adopting a dairy free diet, or the ways you can introduce dairy free alternatives into your family’s diet, post your question on this thread for Kate to answer.

Thanks and good luck,

OP’s posts: |
Bloatstoat Mon 11-Oct-21 10:40:09

If we don't have any allergies/intolerances as a family, can we mix and match? I'd like to reduce dairy, but also there are some things we really enjoy and would like to have sometimes, so would it be ok for my children (aged 2 and 6) to have oat and soya milk sometimes and sometimes dairy? Thanks smile

Beurre Mon 11-Oct-21 11:11:17

Can you recommend a test to check if people have intolerances to dairy? My sister has constant stomach pain and although she has IBS, I suspect she may also have a dairy intolerance.

LadyLothbrook Mon 11-Oct-21 11:16:59

Will there be any deficiencies or health issues if we choose to eliminate dairy from our children's diet altogether? Neither child has dairy intolerances.

lemonjam Mon 11-Oct-21 11:20:17

Is there a best plant milk for young children?
Does going dairy free change anything in regards to iron/iron absorption? (Am stubbornly anaemic!)

jellybeanpopper Mon 11-Oct-21 12:45:50

What are the benefits of going dairy free?

jellybeanpopper Mon 11-Oct-21 12:46:25

Is there an age under which you would not recommend going dairy free?


jellybeanpopper Mon 11-Oct-21 12:47:43

What are the differences between different dairy free milk in terms of the benefits they provide?

jellybeanpopper Mon 11-Oct-21 12:48:37

Rather than going dairy free would mixing between dairy and dairy free options be more advantageous?

adrianmolesmole Mon 11-Oct-21 12:50:15

As someone who's just turned 50 I've found my hair is thinning at the crown and my peri/PMT symptoms have worsened. How much can dairy be contributing to this? Can dairy increase DHT/oestrogen/testosterone etc levels in women thus contributing to hair loss?

MumDad1958 Mon 11-Oct-21 13:20:08

I would like to be dairy free to see if I have an Intolerance but I'm not sure. I was looking at using Oat drink as a milk substitute but I'm not sure about substitutes for other dairy products. I have ibs - had this for a number of years. I have been diagnosed with diverticulitis. I also have a gluten Intolerance. I would be so grateful for any advice. Thank you.

NellieEllie Mon 11-Oct-21 14:20:49

Calcium is obviously a vital mineral, especially for children.
Calcium carbonate is the calcium source added to many plant milks. I read different stuff about how it can be absorbed. Is this source OK, or is calcium phosphate/tri calcium phosphate - or any other source better?

SnowyMouse Mon 11-Oct-21 15:03:15

Are there any good dairy free ready meals around, my mum is dairy free but can't cook for herself any more.

itsonlysubterfuge Mon 11-Oct-21 16:00:33

I switched to Oat milk and plant based butters to reduce saturated fats in our diet, but the trade off was an increase in sugar, is it really better?

Jensonfromtheblock Mon 11-Oct-21 16:07:48

I struggle with lactose so am dairy free except for real butter, which doesn’t seem to be an issue. I generally drink lactose free milk instead of dairy free. My main struggle with plant alternatives is the ingredients. Added sugar, salt or random sounding chemicals. Can you advise on if these are actually a healthy alternative?

lisaandalan Mon 11-Oct-21 17:10:20

Hi I have ibs, going to be tested for crohn's
When I eat dairy I get a bad stomach and I get a lot of phlegm.
Is there dairy free products that taste really nice, I have yet to find a good cheese.
Where can I get tested
For intolerance's please, my doctors won't do it they say they haven't got the Budget.
Thank you.

NerrSnerr Mon 11-Oct-21 17:14:23

I have recently been diagnosed with asthma and have been trying to find triggers. When I'm having a relapse I find that diary makes it worse but the research I have done is inconclusive as to whether dairy actually does exacerbate asthma or whether it would actually be down to an undetected allergy?

Chalatte Mon 11-Oct-21 17:46:22

The science is out there already: dairy milk is associated with calcium malabsorption, poorer bone density, has a massive carbon footprint, and is poorly tolerated/digested by nearly all of the world's population.

My younger children who are in nursery are not offered vegan milk alternatives while other children are given dairy milk. When will there be vegan milk alternatives in school? And when do you see these alternatives not "alternative" ; rather, the "norm"?

Joysutty Mon 11-Oct-21 17:52:37

A lot of children + adults also have allergies to cows milk, as a friend 8 years ago now told us of her allergy and that she only buys soya or almond milk, so my husband started with these on his cereals and his cholesteral levels came down so that was an interesting fact to find out, but I myself am not a fan prefering semi-skimmed milk. There are lots of different ones out now, Alpro, and some supermarkets are doing their own brand ones. Cashew milk is more new to the market but I did read somewhere the other week that too much Coconut can upset your stomach as there is Coconut milk out now also - so that is my question - is this true as coconut does have good benefits to your skin/hair but wondered why it would then upset your stomach/bodily system ? Or are they talking of lots and lots that you would have to consume for it to have this or any drastic effect.

PeacefulDreams Mon 11-Oct-21 18:01:56

Is it healthy to change to a dairy free diet during pregnancy or is it best to wait till post pregnancy?

BristolMum96 Mon 11-Oct-21 18:53:06

Why is the growing up drink not suitable as a main milk drink for under 3s?

Swifey40 Mon 11-Oct-21 19:47:00

Would going dairy free help my terrible migraines please? I am 43 and they are gradually getting worse, and are now so bad that I cannot work.

ButterMyMuffin Mon 11-Oct-21 19:56:48

Would going dairy free or significantly reducing dairy be suitable for kids aged 1-8? Would you reccomend taking vitamin supplements or making other changes to diet?

vincettenoir Mon 11-Oct-21 20:00:22

I’m anaemia and I don’t eat dairy. Can you give me some tips for increasing iron in my diet?

fishnships Mon 11-Oct-21 20:51:57

I have in the past had IBS but finding that I have a gluten intolerance has made masses of difference, and cutting out dairy (because it is harder to digest lactose as we get older - generally) has helped a lot too. I am using plant based milks but they come in cartons that have plastic openers and can't be recycled. I am concious that many years of getting milk delivered in reusable plastic bottles was a better environmental option - it seems a backward step! Do you know of a more eco-friendly way of obtaining plant milk - other than making it?

Join the discussion

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

Join Mumsnet

Already have a Mumsnet account? Log in