My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

MNHQ have commented on this thread

Films

Any film adaptations that are better than the books?

118 replies

Walkthroughthefire · 11/01/2016 16:26

I know it's a very rare case but have you ever thought a film as better than the book it was based on. Controversial, I know.

I've always thought Breakfast at Tiffany's was better and more recently, the Hunger Games.

I feel like I had another but I'm drawing a blank just now.

OP posts:
Report
TheHiphopopotamus · 11/01/2016 17:14

I thought the film Stardust was better than the book. It's not very often that happens, but it helps if I see the film first and then read the book, rather than the other way round otherwise it never lives up to expectations.

Report
NatashaBolkonskaya · 11/01/2016 17:25

Thirty five years ago, I thought the film of The French Lieutenant's Woman was better than the novel.
I'm not sure if I would still think so - I haven't watched the film for a long time.

Report
DizzyDancer · 11/01/2016 17:27

How I live now

The book is almost very childish and doesn't portray much seriousness

The film does

Report
bigbadbarry · 11/01/2016 17:27

I agree it is rare. I love the Lord of the rings films and found the books a slog. The only other one I can think of is the English patient.

Report
rookiemere · 11/01/2016 17:30

I wouldn't say it was better, but I thought that the film of Still Alice did at least match the book due to Julianne Moore's amazing performance.

Report
LorelaiVictoriaGilmore · 11/01/2016 17:33

Bedknobs and Broomsticks which was still is one of my favourite films when I was little.

Report
ComeLuckyApril · 11/01/2016 17:38

Logan's Run (awful book!)
Mary Poppins (the books are so, so odd!)

Report
FedUpWithBriiiiiick · 11/01/2016 17:39

Agree with Breakfast at Tiffany's, OP. The novella was crapola.

Report
Quogwinkle · 11/01/2016 17:42

Oh yes, Bedknobs and Broomsticks is brilliant. Watched it with DS twice over Christmas on Netflix.

The Railway Children - just wonderful. Still makes me teary at the end.

Report
ShowOfHands · 11/01/2016 17:43

Most Nicholas Sparks.

I think Brokeback Mountain matches the novella for beauty too.

Report
iklboo · 11/01/2016 17:43

Bladerunner is SO much better than Do Androids Dream Of Electric Sheep.

Report
iklboo · 11/01/2016 17:43

Agree Mary Poppins. She's a right nasty piece in the books.

Report
AristotlesTrousers · 11/01/2016 17:44

Dr Zhivago.

Report
bigbadbarry · 11/01/2016 17:45

I loved the Mary Poppins books as a child, comelucky. Agree they are odd and the film is quite different.

Report
FeliciaJollygoodfellow · 11/01/2016 17:46

Cloud Atlas. The book was so tedious but I loved the film.

Report
fruityb · 11/01/2016 17:46

Shawshank Redemption. The book ends with Red hoping he can get there, as he says in the film. But it's the scene where he walks towards him in the film that I adore which is missing from the book. It's otherwise a good adaptation save for the identity he sets up for himself and such.

Report
TripTrapTripTrapOverTheBridge · 11/01/2016 17:47

We Need to Talk About Kevin.

Love the film but the book was just annoying

Report
AgentCooper · 11/01/2016 17:47

The Godfather - it misses out all the mad stuff in the book about the huge vagina.

Report
Fractiousfractions · 11/01/2016 17:48

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

museumum · 11/01/2016 17:48

Anything written by Philip K Dick makes a better film. His writing is just awful.

Report
DontCallMeBaby · 11/01/2016 17:48

Coraline - scarier than the book. It's not a bad book, and I love Neil Gaiman, but it doesn't paint the pictures the film does.

Report
Walkthroughthefire · 11/01/2016 17:51

Ooh yes, bladerunner
I might even say Peter Pan too!

OP posts:
Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

IfItsGoodEnough4ShirleyBassey · 11/01/2016 17:54

The novel of the Godfather is pulpy tosh, and the sex, as pp said is deeply Hmm

Report
YouBastardSockBalls · 11/01/2016 17:55

LOTR as they cut out a lot of the boring stuff.

And The Shawshank Redemption as the story it's based on is quite short.

Report
vestandknickers · 11/01/2016 17:55

I think the film version of The Horse Whisperer had a better ending than the book.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.