Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Have there been any studies about elderly trans people with dementia?

56 replies

GreatFox · 17/01/2026 18:19

I am currently dealing with dementia in my personal life.

So many people with dementia revert back to childhood emotionally and withing their own version of reality. We are told the best thing to do is go along with this as correcting them can be upsetting (ie telling them their mums have passed away 30 years ago)

I was wondering if its known if Trans people go back to thinking they are their biological sex if they have dementia? As they most probably would have lived their childhoods as thei biosex.

And if they become confused/distressed if they have had gender reassignment surgery?

OP posts:
inkymoose · 20/01/2026 13:47

ThatZanyFatball · 19/01/2026 14:32

Receptor doesn't have to be human it can be anything with the capacity to hear. If there is no "one" (including any and all living creatures) in the forest there is nothing to receive the sound waves created by the tree falling. A tree falling makes sound waves, ears and brain synapses (human or otherwise) turn sound waves into sounds.

Isn't that more or less what I said? The chances of there being no living creatures in a forest is pretty much zero.
I suppose this particular quote or philosophical question or whatever it is winds me up because one of my strange relatives once sent me some kind of religious brainwashing type video, where the young man who was trying to do the brainwashing (at great length) stated categorically that there would be no sound if there was no one there to hear it. A stupid diagram of a tree falling down again and again with no sound was employed to hammer home their point. Surely the whole point of asking the question about a tree falling in the forest is to engender philosophical thoughts and discussions, not to find a concrete answer, because there isn't one.

I guess this is something I need to let go of ... meanwhile the question about elderly trans people wondering what the hell has happened to them remains. I think it's simplistic to say that people are born one thing and remain that thing forever. People change throughout their lives. It's a trueism though that people who are old revert to a second childhood. But I do not think that a human being or any other mammal can change sex. That's not a philosophical question, it is fact.

pontefractals · 21/01/2026 12:23

eatfigs · 17/01/2026 20:42

Not sure if there are comprehensive studies on this phenomenon but there is anecdotal evidence, e.g.

That poor woman. Imagine putting up with everything she'd put up with, thinking she was doing the right thing and being a dutiful, loving wife, and then having their life together end like that.

OpheliaWitchoftheWoods · 21/01/2026 12:55

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

ManManManManMan · 21/01/2026 16:34

My uncle got dementia in his early sixties due to alcoholism. The last photo I ever saw of him was him dressed fully as a woman and he died a couple of years later. Not sure what that means!

lcakethereforeIam · 21/01/2026 16:57

Wouldn't it also work the other way round then. If gender identity is innate and immutable as tras would have it, would we not see people who've suppressed their inner-true-opposite-sex-self (probably because of us mean terfs) suddenly transitioning if Alzheimer's took away their inhibitions. Aside from the pp's uncle, has this ever happened?

JellySaurus · 21/01/2026 19:10

It is common for men to become sexually disinhibited with dementia. We certainly hear about this a lot. Less common, I think, in women. If transgenderism was innate, but had been stifled, wouldn’t it be expressed as part of male sexual disinhibition? Or would the transgenderists say that the lack of expression proves that men who identify as women would not become as disinhibited as other men, because they would be behaving as a woman, therefore not displaying sexual disinhibition?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page