Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

1000 Splendid Suns

89 replies

trulymadlydeeply · 22/06/2008 21:37

Just finished this and it's on my mind as it was so brilliant.

Has anyone else read it and loved it like I did?

OP posts:
auntyspan · 22/06/2008 21:40

YES I finished reading it on Thursday and am still thinking about it.

I wish it had been 50 times longer - so many relationships that could have been explored more etc.

I found the ending a bit like a film script but sometimes I prefer those to the abrupt way some books finish.

HURRY UP AND WRITE ANOTHER!!

mollysawally · 22/06/2008 21:41

Read it last year.
Loved it.
Felt so sad she was executed.

dizzydixies · 22/06/2008 21:42

oohh noooo hides thread - tis my next read aarrgghhhhhhhh

artichokes · 22/06/2008 21:43

I loved it. Was totally absorbed by it and moved too.

However, there are some people on this board who really hate it and say you would only enjoy it if you were totally ignorant of Islamic culture. I don't really know what they mean, I am not totally ignorant of Islamic culture having lived in Turkey BUT western Turkey is not a very hardline Islamic culture... Sorry, I am rambling now!

Amphibimum · 22/06/2008 21:43

fantastic book. i miss having the characters in my life now ive finished it.

Amphibimum · 22/06/2008 21:47

really artichokes? oh. well i suppose i am pretty ignorant of islamic culture tbh.

mollysawally · 22/06/2008 21:48

Amp - I feel the same way when I finish a book I love, thats why I love reading. You just dont get the same feeling about films or TV.

Arti - I've just read 'maps for lost lovers' and that explolres muslim and islam in uk, that seemed to back up most things in '100 suns' so I don't think you are ignorant if you enjoyed it .. now I am rambling!

auntyspan · 22/06/2008 21:48

Me too I guess... although if it meant I didn't enjoy the book as much as I did then I glad I know nothing.... if you see what I mean....

mollysawally · 22/06/2008 21:49

rambling and commiting a thousand typo's!

CoteDAzur · 23/06/2008 15:09

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

trulymadlydeeply · 23/06/2008 16:24

I'm afraid I'm very ignorant, and after reading the book wanted to know more about Afghanistan's history, and Islamic culture.

Where to even begin, is the question ...

OP posts:
AbbeyA · 23/06/2008 16:34

I loved it although there were times that I could hardly bear to read it and was relieved when it moved forward a few years.

MaryAnnSingleton · 23/06/2008 16:38

it was ok..not bowled over by it though...over-hyped imo.

mollysawally · 23/06/2008 19:33

I did think half of a yellow sun was better.

herbietea · 23/06/2008 19:38

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

CoteDAzur · 23/06/2008 19:47

The author has left Afghanistan with his family as a child. He has lived in Paris, and then in California, where he lives to this day.

He wasn't in Afghanistan when the Taliban came. He wasn't there when Taliban fought Soviets. He wasn't there when Soviets withdrew. He heard about all this from TV and newspapers, just like the rest of us.

That he doesn't know much about Afghanistan is is obvious when you read the book. 95% of the story is indoors and main characters talk to a handful of people, probably so that the author can avoid having to talk about Afghan people, their interactions, and especially their cities, landmarks, customs, etc.

The only Afghan monument discussed in the whole book are the two Buddha statues blown up by the Taliban that everyone else in the world knows about. The books/authors it references are Western Classics like Pinocchio, Old Man and the Sea, etc.

It's a book written in English, by a guy who is Afghan only by heritage, and for the Western audience.

artichokes · 23/06/2008 20:46

But Cote, does the fact that the author did not directly experience the events he recalls necessarily mean it is not a great read? I don't think so. Many great books are written about placed and events that the authors could only imagine.

Also the book is about personal relationships. The author was not trying to write a book that gave the reader a tour of Afghanistan and its monuments, he was trying to explore the effects of war, isolation and prejudice on two women in a society where they are disenfranchised. He has managed to write it in such a way that the majority of readers and absorbed and very moved.

In my opinion he is a very good story teller.

Love2bake · 23/06/2008 20:50

Loved it - not as much as the Kite Runner though.

Miyazaki · 23/06/2008 20:55

I didn't like it. had to read it for book club.

Think he is V overrated. imvho.

suedonim · 23/06/2008 20:57

Thanks, Cote. Am C&P-ing (aka plagiarism) your post for my book group tomorrow.

CoteDAzur · 23/06/2008 21:27

Sure, there are some brilliant books written by people who have never lived where the story takes place. This is just not one of them.

The story takes place during some great upheavals - invasions, civil war, resistance, regime change. Normally, these would be woven into the story line. Not in this book. Here, they are told by third parties, once in a while.

Just for comparison, our book club is now reading Kate Mosse's "Labyrinth". Although set in the Middle Ages, so obviously not a time/culture the author is familiar with, I feel like Mosse knows more about and shares more detail with medieval Carcassone than Hosseini knows/tells about Afghanistan.

MaryAnnSingleton · 23/06/2008 22:34

hooray Miyazaki !

singersgirl · 23/06/2008 22:39

Was it just me who found it rather dull and not particularly well written? I found it so manipulative, though not quite as bad as "The Kite Runner', which really irritated me.

I don't know about the Islamic/Afghani angle of it, but just didn't rate it.

MaryAnnSingleton · 23/06/2008 22:44

no singersgirl, me too.

singersgirl · 23/06/2008 22:49

Oh, good. I always feel as if I might have missed something if other people rave about a book I'm lukewarm towards.

Swipe left for the next trending thread