I think a handsome Mr Bennet is perfectly plausible - Mrs B is very clear about what Jane should look for in a man (looks, charming manners, money & social cachet) so it makes sense that Mrs B had the same priorities. If Mr B was lacking in any of this, she probably would have complained about it.
@RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie- completely agree with both the age of Mrs B & the poor casting. My estimate is that she must be between 40-45 & she also needs to be pretty (to make sense of why Mr B married her). Mr Collins also needs to be good looking to.
I do enjoy the Andrew Davies adaptation as it’s a lot of fun, but most if not all of the casting is wrong for the book & I feel it completely lacks the depth of the book. The fuss about that adaptation (“Look, we’re daring because we’ve put Darcy in a wet shirt”) is probably why I just don’t have the headspace for the new Wuthering Heights film.
Back to book reviews (as I could speculate endlessly re P&P):
22 . Circle of Friends by Maeve Binchy - this chronicles 2 friends from a small Irish town, who go to university in Dublin during the late 50s & find friendship, love and infatuation. Thank you to everyone who recommended Maeve Binchy as I really enjoyed this (definitely a bold). It’s a long novel and I think this suits her talents better than the short story format. The central characters aren’t quite as vivid as in Light a Penny Candle, but I found the plot was much better. It had a shorter timeframe, which worked better for me, and - although bad things happened - the ending was much more optimistic for the main characters. The author’s trademark vile men were there - but these were balanced by also having some decent men on the main characters’ side. Finally, just like in Light a Penny Candle, I do like that characters face the natural consequences of their behaviour - if they behave stupidly &/ selfishly they suffer.
Just going back to previous discussions, I could have read Circle of Friends as a teen, but I didn’t as I was put off Maeve Binchy by the covers looking a bit too middle-aged. I was wondering if anyone else enjoyed it at that age as given the subject matter (university, friendship & first love / infatuation) it would seem a good choice for an adult novel that you could put in a teenage library / bookshop section?