24 The Secret History by Donna Tartt
I can see why this has been dubbed a ‘Modern Classic’, I’m sure most people have read it but for some reason it passed me by, so sincere thanks to @noodlezoodle for bringing this along to the 50 Bookers meet up and book swap.
Written in 1992 and set in the early to mid 1980’s when Tartt herself would have been a student at Bennington College, Vermont (Although I don’t think this is explicit in the text, Bunny in particular is written like a Gatsby throwback, but there are cultural references to Jane Fonda’s workout videos, the movie Bachelor Party and other clues which were fun to spot.)
The novel is narrated by Richard Papen, something of an outsider, he transfers from college in his home town of Plano, California to the prestigious Hampden college in Vermont. Here he attempts to hide his humble origins and fit in with the rich kids - when asked where his family get their money he claims it’s ’Oil’, when the truth is his abusive father runs a petrol filling station - so some truth there I suppose …
After some dogged perseverance on Richard’s part he is accepted by the enigmatic Classics Professor Julian Morrow onto his exclusive ancient Greek course, where Richard joins five other students, all of who are beautiful, glittering and wealthy - Henry, Francis, twins Charles and Camilla and the doomed Edmond ‘Bunny’ Corcoran.
The novel is split into a prologue, two ‘Books’ and an epilogue. The iconic opening line of the prologue tells us:
‘The snow in the mountains was melting and Bunny had been dead for several weeks before we came to understand the gravity of our situation.’
So we know from the outset that Bunny is dead and also that the other five members of the Classics programme have murdered him, what we don’t know is why.
The lead up to the murder is dealt with in Book 1, whilst the immediate aftermath, long term impact and fall out from the crime is covered in Book 2.
This was a beautifully written book it had echoes of other great novels, notably The Talented Mr Ripley, Brideshead Revisited and as mentioned The Great Gatsby (Particularly in the casual cruelty and perceived superiority of the life wrecking rich set.)
The characters were well drawn, with the exception of Camilla who remained somewhat sketchy and nebulous, perhaps deliberately so, as she becomes the obsession of several of the male protagonists and perhaps is portrayed as all things to all men with her most prized quality being her beauty.
Book 1 was superior to Book 2 imo with a narrative drive and page turning quality which was less apparent in Book 2 but taken overall it’s a novel that will stay with me and is undoubtedly the boldest, bold I’ve read so far this year.