Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

Random scenes in random books that stuck with you

77 replies

BlueRaincoat1 · 18/09/2022 19:25

So not necessarily classic scenes from classic books (although happy to hear of them too!) but are there random scenes that pop into your mind frequently from otherwise 'regular' books?

I read a fiction book about the siege of Stalingrad many years ago, and there's a scene where the mother sees an onion, and imagines being able to.cook.it for her sons, and imagines all the goodness going into him. One onion. It pops into my head fairly regularly.

Also a book which had a very fluffy/'chick lit' cover but was much better than the cover suggested (as is often the case...) about an artist who was no longer with her husband but painted a picture of him that perfectly captured the way he rotated his fo

OP posts:
Delabruche · 21/09/2022 13:08

Thanks. I couldnt get it to work but I worked it out. Very interesting!
www.theguardian.com/news/2020/oct/05/weatherwatch-1885-whitby-storm-inspired-grim-scene-in-dracula

Hyacinth2 · 21/09/2022 18:01

I remember in Burial Rites - I think she was lying in bed watching the dawn light and observing the veins in the sheep's bladder stretched across the window ( set in Iceland 1700s) Confused

ThickCutSteakChips · 21/09/2022 18:04

In the third Hunger Games book there is a scene where they are going through a booby trapped cave or something. One of the traps is a light so hot and bright that it just melts the person on the spot! It said that the person just melted like a candle. I just remember thinking it was such a horrible image for a kids book!

ilovesushi · 21/09/2022 18:18

@darisdet Yes, I'd forgotten that! I'll have to reread it now! I mostly felt that Gaskell was on Ruth's side and all that sacrificing her own life in tending smallpox patients at the end didn't seem to sit with the rest. Ruth seems to disappear as a person and become a saint like being. I seem to remember there was a lovely doctor at the end who was very taken with her and I think understanding of her past. I would have preferred a happy ending with him! Definitely going to reread!

didiimaginethis · 21/09/2022 18:59

BlueRaincoat1 · 18/09/2022 19:26

Argh pressed post...

...foot... it was just a really good page/scene in the context of the book and I really liked it. Wish I could remember the name of the book, I'd read it again!

Would love to hear others' 'random scenes'.

I think this book is Love is a Four Letter Word. She's an artist and painted her partner (who died) as a present for his family....they love the way she captures the way he used to swing his foot.

BlueRaincoat1 · 21/09/2022 20:37

Amazing! Thanks @didiimaginethis ! That's definitely it. Can't belive someone recognised the scene 😊

OP posts:
upinaballoon · 22/09/2022 22:05

di2004 · 19/09/2022 13:41

Ten Thousand Sorrows by Elizabeth Kim - as a very young child watching her mother being murdered by hiding inside a woven basket which her mother had put her there for safety. Her murder was an honour killing caused by the shame she brought on the family for having a child with an American GI and her being Korean.
I will never read a book like it again, so very sad. Losing the only person that loved her.

...and she was adopted to America? Oh, I read that, but I couldn't have told you the name of the book. Thank you for the reminder.

upinaballoon · 22/09/2022 22:33

There is a book called 'Bless This House' by Norah Lofts. It follows the house through from the time of Elizabeth I to the coronation year of Elizabeth II. It is a damp English day. The daughter of the house is walking along in her sensible clothes and shoes. The family is not wealthy and the house is not in a good state. She is offered a lift by an American. I think he is descended from someone who once lived there and went to the USA - something like that, and he has come over to England on holiday and to look for the area. He is rich. She had been to buy raw meat for the dog/s and when she gets into his car she hopes that the meat does not smell nasty and cause him to wonder where the smell's coming from.

DillonPanthersTexas · 22/09/2022 22:36

Most of 'The Road' by Cormac McCarthy

CalmConfident · 22/09/2022 23:08

A scene where a man is running through a remote wood in Scotland on a route he has done many times before, but this time a large ancient standing stone has appeared just off the path that was never there previously.

As a trail runner it gives me the chills just thinking about it as I can totally imagine this and the feeling that goes with it !

upinaballoon · 23/09/2022 13:06

upinaballoon · 22/09/2022 22:33

There is a book called 'Bless This House' by Norah Lofts. It follows the house through from the time of Elizabeth I to the coronation year of Elizabeth II. It is a damp English day. The daughter of the house is walking along in her sensible clothes and shoes. The family is not wealthy and the house is not in a good state. She is offered a lift by an American. I think he is descended from someone who once lived there and went to the USA - something like that, and he has come over to England on holiday and to look for the area. He is rich. She had been to buy raw meat for the dog/s and when she gets into his car she hopes that the meat does not smell nasty and cause him to wonder where the smell's coming from.

Well, I misremembered! He already owns the house, and it's January, but he does give her a lift and there is some smelly meat for the dogs (and obviously he's going to marry her and the old Elizabethan house is going to be lovely again.)

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 29/09/2022 11:59

The "My Friend...series of books by Scottish writerJ contains one anet Duncan My Friend Flora contains a scene I will never forget and wish I'd never read.

The series is about the life of Janet, a precociously bright child with bookish interests growing up in the Black Isle from around 1915. I got the books from our local village library. Superficially they all seem a charming picture of rural life in that period. They move on through Janet's live on to university, marriage and travel, but they are books for adults and I was too young by a long way for a scene in My Friend Flora.

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 29/09/2022 12:04

KohlaParasaurus · 19/09/2022 19:09

The bit in The White Hotel where the ski lift breaks and the ladies in their big skirts drift down to the ground slowly, "silently followed by a hail of skis".

The gratuitously unpleasant scene in Jude the Obscure.

Everyone remembers that Jude scene which of course mirrors the equally unpleasant scene with Hareton in Wuthering Heights

crazybunnyladyy · 29/09/2022 20:32

spoiler!

I'm a big fan of Karin Slaughter so mine would be in Beyond Reach, where Jeffrey Tolliver meets his sudden, shocking and untimely demise!

crazybunnyladyy · 29/09/2022 20:33

Or, if anyone has been brave/ stupid enough to read it... any scene from 120 Days of Sodom.
That book will haunt your dreams.

WallaceinAnderland · 29/09/2022 20:41

When Rosasharn tries to breastfeed the old man in Grapes of Wrath.

Vebrithien · 29/09/2022 21:00

In an old children's book about the history of England. It was bound in mustard coloured canvas, and had line drawings of a village throughout different periods in English history. A little bigger than A5 size, closer to square. It was old in the early 1990's.

There was a boy and his farmer father, who were taking food to the nearest town, to be sold.

I would love to re-find that book. I can see it in my mind's eye

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 29/09/2022 21:29

WallaceinAnderland · 29/09/2022 20:41

When Rosasharn tries to breastfeed the old man in Grapes of Wrath.

Much earlier in that book when the Okies stop at a diner to buy bread. Mae, the diner owner, is pretty much the last person to treat them with any decency or give them any dignity

He was about to drop the penny back into the pouch when his eye fell on the boys frozen before the candy counter. He moved slowly down to them. He pointed in the case at big long sticks of striped peppermint. "Is them penny candy, ma'am?"

Mae moved down and looked in. "Which ones?"

"There, them stripy ones."

The little boys raised their eyes to her face and they stopped breathing; their mouths were partly opened, their half-naked bodies were rigid.

"Oh them. Well, no them's two for a penny."

"Well, gimme two then, ma'am." He placed the copper cent carefully on the counter. The boys expelled their held breath softly. Mae held the big sticks out.

"Take 'em," said the man.

They reached timidly, each took a stick, and they held them down at their sides and did not look at them. But they looked at each other, and their mouth corners smiled rigidly with embarrassment.

"Thank you, ma'am." The man picked up the bread and went out the door, andhthe little boys marched stiffly behind him, the red-striped sticks held tightly against their legs. They leaped like chipmunks over the front seat and onto the top of the load, and they burrowed back out of sight like chipmunks.

The man got in and started his car, and with a roaring motor and a cloud of blue oily smoke the ancient Nash climbed up on the highway and went on its way to the west. From inside the restaurant the truck drivers and Mae and Al stared after them.

Big Bill wheeled back. "Them wasn't two-for-a-cent candy," he said.

"What's that to you?" Mae said fiercely.

"Them was nickel apiece candy," said Bill.

User287264 · 29/09/2022 22:00

I read a fiction book about the siege of Stalingrad many years ago, and there's a scene where the mother sees an onion, and imagines being able to.cook.it for her sons, and imagines all the goodness going into him. One onion. It pops into my head fairly regularly

Was that the same book I've forgotten the name of but can picture the cover of, and they have an older woman staying with them and just when they think there is no hope the older woman pulls out a jar of jam she's had hidden in her shoe the whole time? And the writer describes how they taste the jam and how amazing that she saves it for all that time. That comes to my mind fairly often

littleegghead · 29/09/2022 22:08

Someone else has already mentioned it but The Road. In particular, the part where they find the pile of people being held to be eaten. Horrifying.

RedAmber · 29/09/2022 22:35

I can't remember the book, but it was in the future and humans were just cattle - existing to be eaten. One fell in a river and everyone just watched while they drowned.

Reminds me of nowadays where people would probably just get their phones out and film rather than try and save them. :(

BlueRaincoat1 · 29/09/2022 22:51

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 29/09/2022 21:29

Much earlier in that book when the Okies stop at a diner to buy bread. Mae, the diner owner, is pretty much the last person to treat them with any decency or give them any dignity

He was about to drop the penny back into the pouch when his eye fell on the boys frozen before the candy counter. He moved slowly down to them. He pointed in the case at big long sticks of striped peppermint. "Is them penny candy, ma'am?"

Mae moved down and looked in. "Which ones?"

"There, them stripy ones."

The little boys raised their eyes to her face and they stopped breathing; their mouths were partly opened, their half-naked bodies were rigid.

"Oh them. Well, no them's two for a penny."

"Well, gimme two then, ma'am." He placed the copper cent carefully on the counter. The boys expelled their held breath softly. Mae held the big sticks out.

"Take 'em," said the man.

They reached timidly, each took a stick, and they held them down at their sides and did not look at them. But they looked at each other, and their mouth corners smiled rigidly with embarrassment.

"Thank you, ma'am." The man picked up the bread and went out the door, andhthe little boys marched stiffly behind him, the red-striped sticks held tightly against their legs. They leaped like chipmunks over the front seat and onto the top of the load, and they burrowed back out of sight like chipmunks.

The man got in and started his car, and with a roaring motor and a cloud of blue oily smoke the ancient Nash climbed up on the highway and went on its way to the west. From inside the restaurant the truck drivers and Mae and Al stared after them.

Big Bill wheeled back. "Them wasn't two-for-a-cent candy," he said.

"What's that to you?" Mae said fiercely.

"Them was nickel apiece candy," said Bill.

Oh god I love that book. Its been so long since I've read it. That scene you've quoted is incredible.

The one that comes to my mind (and I might be misremembering) is the women watching the men as the crops fail and the farms are repossessed and watching to see if it breaks them. The way it is written is so powerful.

OP posts:
OnTheBrinkOfChange · 29/09/2022 23:01

WallaceinAnderland · 29/09/2022 20:41

When Rosasharn tries to breastfeed the old man in Grapes of Wrath.

That book had such an impact on me and the ending was so powerful. I read that perhaps 40 years ago and I can still remember it so well.

CatNamedEaster · 29/09/2022 23:19

The scene in the hospital in The Outsiders. I read it first when I was a teenager and it made me properly sob.

We Need To Talk About Kevin. When she opens the box that he gives her and sees what's inside. I felt such a range of emotions imagining what she would have felt.

A book that I can't remember much detail of but it was about an elderly woman looking back on her life. One scene talks about her having four children because when she had the first she couldn't bear the idea of them dying so had another just in case. But then realised she still couldn't bear the potential loss so goes on to have another two.
In another scene she thinks about how lonely it us to be old as you never get touched anymore. It was put much more beautifully than that but at the time I had a toddler who touched me for 12 hours a day so it really resonated with me that at some point I will crave human touch.