Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

50 Book Challenge 2020 Part Seven

999 replies

southeastdweller · 23/07/2020 10:25

Welcome to the seventh thread of the 50 Book Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2020, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, it's not too late to join, and please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read.

The first thread of the year is here, the second one here, the third one here, the fourth one here, the fifth one here and the sixth one here.

What are you reading?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
MamaNewtNewt · 25/08/2020 08:10

Bit behind on my reviews:

  1. Look For Me by Lisa Gardner. The book centres around the search for a missing teenage girl after her family is killed, is she a victim or is she the perpetrator? By the numbers crime book with some meditations on what it means to be a family and forgiveness. There were some sensitive subjects explored but I felt it was too slight to elicit the emotional reaction that the author was aiming for, probably because of the very limited character development. (2/5)

  2. The Man Who Fell To Earth by Walter Tevis. A refugee from another planet comes to Earth disguised as a human with a plan to use his knowledge of advanced technology to rescue the rest of his race. It is never specified which planet he is from but it is strongly hinted to be Venus. The book got off to an intriguing start but as it progressed I found it less and less engaging. I think it just wasn’t science-fictiony enough for me, I wanted to know more about the alien technology and the impact on Earth, as well as more about the alien life form, planet and way of life. Instead what I got was a meditation on alcoholism. Also the section involving the U.S. government was VERY unrealistic, although perhaps just of its time. Not necessarily a bad book but not what I was looking for. (3/5)

  3. The Steam Pump Jump by Jodi Taylor. A Chronicles of St Mary’s book centred around the plan cooked up between Max and Markham to do a bit of matchmaking for Peterson. This book was from the point of view of Markham, who is one of my favourite characters, and is a funny, touching love story. (4/5)

  4. And Now for Something Completely Different by Jodi Taylor. Another short story that details the Mars landing, which unusually is a contemporary event for Max and crew – well kinda. Of COURSE they manage to get mixed up in this event, courtesy of another version of St Mary’s. I enjoyed this one but Max’s constant refusal to move when there is danger is really starting to get on my nerves, it’s one thing to have a death wish and another to be constantly putting others in danger. (4/5)

  5. Hope for the Best by Jodi Taylor. The most recent full length St Mary’s book sees Max moving in a new direction and joining the Time Police in a semi-undercover role to capture Ronan once and for all. The section on the time map and the side adventure into Tudor England was interesting. I loved the ending of this book with the fragile truce between the Time Police well and truly shattered and it is set up well for the next book. (4/5)

  6. When Did You Last See Your Father? By Jodi Taylor. A short story that deals with the reappearance of Max’s abusive father. St Mary’s comes together to deliver a comeuppance of sorts. Personally I think he got off lightly. (3/5)

  7. Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince by J.K. Rowling. Audio book listen which I really enjoyed. I found myself feeling pretty sorry for Malfoy which I don’t remember doing when I read the book. Define feeling of the end of an era as Harry, Ron and Hermione plan their hunt for the horcruxes. One criticism was the shoe-horning of the Half-Blood Prince reveal at the end of the story felt clumsily done. (4/5)

Currently reading Enigma by Robert Harris, a re-read from a few years ago and listening to Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows by J.K. Rowling.

Terpsichore · 25/08/2020 08:32

Have you seen the film of The Man Who Fell to Earth, Mama? Not that it'll answer any of your questions (the aliens appear to wear retro platform boots and live in a sort of wonky garden shed, which casts doubt on their technological superiority imho), but David Bowie plays the lead role and does plausibly look and sound as though he's just dropped from the sky into 70s America. It turns up on TV fairly often.

StitchesInTime · 25/08/2020 09:19

73. Malory Towers Upper Fourth by Enid Blyton

A re-read of a childhood favourite. This is the one where Gwendoline tries to fake a heart condition in an attempt to get out of doing her exams.

CoteDAzur · 25/08/2020 09:35

Mama - I also recently read and reviewed The Man Who Fell to Earth. I am a big hard-SF fan and like my fiction as mathematical and 'sciency' as possible, but thought that this book didn't suffer from lack of scientific detail - its focus was on the human condition, our strengths and shortcomings, our miserable tumble towards inevitable doom, and how we are unable and unwilling to see let alone stop it. The alien was just a plot device to see ourselves clearer in juxtaposition: He comes to Earth with superior knowledge, technology, and a mission. Over time, he slowly 'goes native' and starts making the same mistakes and disappears down the same psychological pitfalls as humans.

Re US government - You need to remember that the book was written during Cold War. How US government handled the alien reads a lot like how Soviet defectors were processed, wringing them out for information in an off-hand manner, mistreating them, sometimes even uselessly, then discarding them.

It's not the best SF I've ever read, but I found its message and delivery interesting (and David Bowie was fantastic in the film).

BestIsWest · 25/08/2020 10:28

Rebecca - Daphne Du Maurier A re-read of one of my favourites. Such a good book, so many twists and turns, brilliantly drawn flawed characters, wonderful descriptive passages and most of all great tension. I’m always sorry to finish it.

PepeLePew · 25/08/2020 10:50

Oh I do love Rebecca. It may be time for a re-read.

67 Dancer from the Dance by Andrew Holleran
This is a beautiful gem of a novel that I came across by chance - it reminded me in setting and tone a little of The Great Gatsby but I much preferred this. It's about the 1970s gay scene in New York and Long Island. Anthony Malone is a beautiful lawyer from the Midwest who turns his back on his past to embrace his new life and Andrew Sutherland is a drag queen and socialite who is interested in pairing him up with a millionaire so they can live the life they want. There's dancing, drinking, sex and drug taking, narrated by a cast of characters who remain largely anonymous. I'm usually wary of books that have cult status but this was absorbing and sad, and reading it now with the knowledge that AIDS is lurking on the horizon - the book was written and published in 1978 - is particularly poignant.

68 Our Universe by Jo Dunkley

This is a short explainer in the vein of the "Very Short Introduction to" books and really does cover pretty much the story of the universe from the Big Bang to what the end may look like. It was a good mix of science and scientific history and I was particularly interested in how we know what we know about the universe. There was a lot in here that went slightly over my head but if I'd paid more attention I think I would have been fine with the science, which is well explained and carefully presented. It was an excellent primer for some star gazing last week in a field in Devon, where the stars were incredible, and I'd recommend it to all my fellow dark sky campers on this thread.

69 Slow Burn City by Rowan Moore
I had this on my wish list for ages and it came up at the library - it's an architectural history of London, with a strong social and political argument threaded through it and a clear vision for the future and how that needs to be delivered by government, the private sector and citizens. The detail about areas of London I know and love was absorbing, and Moore clearly loves the city and feels passionately about the need for it to be designed and built to work for everyone, not just the few.

70 Murderous Contagion by Mary Dobson
This is a series of short essays (I don't think it was intended as such but it's certainly how it reads) on different diseases - bacterial, viral, lifestyle and parasitic, and how humanity has dealt with them. The detail of each was interesting, as was her account of their emergence and (in some cases) how we've eradicated them, but I really missed any kind of unifying story of medical progress or any real detail on the biology of the diseases. Even a conclusion at the end would have really helped pull it all together - she didn't really get to what I think is essential in the story of human disease, which is how we have learned so much but still undermine our own best efforts both through the lifestyles we lead and the way we interact with nature.

71 Magda by Meike Ziervogel
I bought this to support a small publishing imprint that did a good job on social media of urging people to buy a book direct from them. I picked this - a novella about the wife of Goebbels - because it sounded interesting and a little bit different. While there were elements that were well done it felt a little overwritten and overly self-conscious to me, compared with (for example) Dancer from the Dance which just sang and felt effortless.

72 The Universe Speaks in Numbers by Graham Farmelo
I read this to try to have a better conversation with my brother who is a physicist and very exercised by the link between maths and physics and how and whether maths underpins the physical laws that govern the universe. Farmelo makes a very good case for the fact that it does, although this is more a history of the dialogue between mathematicians and physicists and how they have worked together (or not) to inform what we know about the universe than it is a scientific book. It does the science very well, I think, with very little knowledge assumed on the part of the reader but it is still a lot to take in

73 Clothes and Other Things That Matter by Alexandra Shulman
I picked this up in the Kindle Daily Deal. I'm going to defend it in the face of Remus's criticism, though what she says is valid - Shulman is self absorbed and despite her protestations that she subverted people's expectations of a Vogue editor by not being a clothes horse that clearly isn't true. She gets given a lot of very expensive clothes by designers and there are lots of anecdotes along the lines of "I dashed into Balenciaga to avoid the rain during Paris Fashion Week and couldn't help but buy a £400 pair of trainers". But if you put that to one side, which I found easy enough to do, there are some interesting stories about the genesis of different items of clothing and some engaging reflection on the role that clothes play in our lives and our identities. It certainly made me feel differently about some items of clothing I own, and think about the way they have shaped my experiences and memories. Particularly poignant as I have just consigned to the rag bag a much loved and much worn hoodie that finally fell apart after many many years of being worn by camp fires on holidays. As a quick and diverting read I think this was ok. And to whoever asked, no socks but she does have a chapter on tights.

BestIsWest · 25/08/2020 12:32

After finishing Rebecca I feel a bit like my Dad did after he read Middlemarch - he thought it was so good that he didn’t read fiction for years after thinking nothing could live up to it.

I think I’m going to revisit more du Maurier.

Boiledeggandtoast · 25/08/2020 13:57

The Constant Nymph by Margaret Kennedy The story of the Sanger children, brought up in chaos in the Swiss Alps and transferred to a more "respectable" upbringing in England on the death of their Bohemian composer father. The Constant Nymph refers to 14 year-old-Teresa, in love with a family friend who also loves her but marries her more conservative cousin (who brings the children back to England). This was something of a curate's egg. At times the writing was wonderful and there were some very amusing characterisations, at others I found the story too contrived and really quite tiresome. It was written back in 1924 and although probably a reflection of attitudes at that time, there is some dreadful anti-Semitism as well as the relationship between the adult Lewis Dodd and the 14-year-old Teresa which is more disturbing to the modern viewpoint (well me anyway, perhaps not to the much younger reader?).

The Dancing Bear by Frances Faviell The follow-up memoir from the marvellous Frances Faviell, this time based in Berlin between 1946-49. This was a terrific and fascinating read about conditions in Berlin after the war, both personal and political. I was sorry to see that she only wrote two memoirs as I have loved both of them. Have any of you Furrowed Middlebrowers read her novels and are they as good?

ChessieFL · 25/08/2020 14:48
  1. 52 Times Britain Was A Bellend: The History You Didn’t Get Taught At School by James Felton

Quick easy read detailing 52 historical events where Britain did not emerge as the good guy! Some of these I was aware of (slavery, medieval torture methods), others I wasn’t (taking over a Mauritian island and forcing out the 1800 people who lived there). The title gives you a clue about the way this is written - there’s a reasonable amount of swearing. Not bad for 99p (it’s in the monthly deal).

Piggywaspushed · 25/08/2020 17:59

So, I have just read Girl, Woman, Other and I am sure I am behind the thread on this one!

It wasn't at all what I expected. I was previously put off because synopses and reviews made me think I wouldn't enjoy it. It was far more entertaining and lighter than I expected and Evaristo's full stopless style didn't faze me at all. I am in awe of all the voices she creates. I had to Wiki her at one point to check if she had been a teacher because it was so authentic (I am slightly worried I am Mrs King!) . The intertwining of all the lives is really cleverly done.

I did feel it faded towards the end, and I didn't like the beginning as much as the middle. I sort of frog marched myself through the After Party bit.

Liked it; didn't love it.

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 25/08/2020 19:48

Pepe - glad you got more out of it than I did.

MamaNewtNewt · 25/08/2020 20:18

@Terpsichore no not seen the film but I LOVE David Bowie so might have to give it a watch.

@CoteDAzur you definitely got WAY more out of this book than me. Maybe because I went in expecting one thing and found it was something else meant I missed the true meaning. That or my brain has gone to mush during lockdown Smile

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 25/08/2020 23:24
  1. Quartet In Autumn by Barbara Pym

Edwin, Norman, Letty and Marcia work together in an office and are approaching retirement and old age, with all four sharing loneliness in common and being unwilling to acknowledge it.

I mean, I think as 'Novels Containing Astute Observations Of The British' go, this is a prime example. It reminded me a lot of Mrs Palfrey At The Claremont

I just don't really think that observational books about ageing and loneliness were not much happens as well done as they are; are "my bag" as a reader really.

I do also have Excellent Women to be read though

SlightlyJaded · 26/08/2020 01:12

47. American Dirt - Jeanine Cummins

Reviewed fairly extensively on here so I'll be brief with my plot summary. Middle Class Mexican woman becomes the target of a dangerous cartel who massacre her entire family, leaving her and her 8 year old son with no choice but to leave Acapulco for the relative safety of the USA. The majority of the story follows their perilous journey as 'migrants' trying to illegally cross the border.

Like others, I am aware of the controversy and backlash and can't quite decide whether I feel that a white woman writing from the point of view of a hispanic woman is appropriation or simply fiction - women writing as men/children/other nationalities is just part and parcel of writing fiction surely? BUT i do concede that there were cliches and stereotypes and I can understand why some people found the whole thing a bit hard to swallow. The occasional use of a few token Spanish words slightly jarred with me as well ...

Having said that, as a work of fiction, it was gripping and offered me - a white women living in a leafy suburb of London - an insight into the plight of the journey across the Mexican border, and a better understanding of the reasons people take such risks. It worked well on a the level of a 'good story' and it was a book I was keen to get back to.
But it was flawed: most of the characters were very loosely drawn, or felt created to 'tick a box' and Luca, in particular, was far too perfect to be true for me. Even the main protagonist didn't really share any thoughts that deviated much from the literal and I never felt like I got to really know her. For me, it lacked heart.

Having said all that, I whizzed through it and was absolutely rooting for them to succeed in their quest and it has prompted me to read more, true life accounts, of attempts to make a similar journey, so it certainly struck a chord.

ChessieFL · 26/08/2020 06:38
  1. How To Disappear by Gillian McAllister

A crime/thriller book that’s a bit different - this is based around a mother and daughter having to go into witness protection after the daughter is the only witness to the murder of a homeless man and the trial falls apart. I thought this was good as I enjoyed reading about the witness protection aspect, although as with all these types of books the characters make some really stupid decisions which means they’re not as safe as they should be.

Terpsichore · 26/08/2020 09:05

Eine, as a Barbara Pym devotee I'd say that Quartet in Autumn is very much an outlier in her fiction - it had been 15 years since she'd had anything published and she'd felt this time in the wilderness very deeply. After all, a long and successful writing career had been destroyed by her publisher's verdict that her style of fiction had become dated (it's clear from her diaries that she was devastated by being dropped, as she saw it).

She did carry on writing but Quartet was also rejected until Philip Larkin and Lord David Cecil both named her as 'most underrated writer' in a TLS article and surprise, surprise, it was suddenly deemed publishable and was even shortlisted for the Booker Prize (but didn't win). So she enjoyed a late renaissance but very sadly she'd had cancer in the interim and on its return she died a couple of years later.

Excellent Women is a much earlier book - her second novel, from 1952 - and while the two books clearly spring from the same imagination, it's totally different in spirit and outlook. It was the first Pym I read and I was totally captivated. FWIW I was pretty spooked out by Quartet, though I admit it has its moments of bleak humour.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 26/08/2020 11:18

@Terpsichore

I will definitely give her another chance due to your passionate defence! It was my first Pym

Quartet and Ew are both in the 1,001 books to read before you die book of books.

SatsukiKusakabe · 26/08/2020 11:25

Emma Jane Austen, Audible narration by Juliet Stevenson

This was a comfort listen to aid my terrible insomnia, in preparation for a comfort reread. Emma usually comes a solid 3rd in my list of favourite Austen, behind the 3 Ps, however I am feeling more fond of it than I used to, partly because I’m convinced that actually Mr. Knightley is the kindest and has the most consistently straightforward integrity of all the romantic interests and is therefore the most likeable for me. Juliet Stevenson has a nice soothing voice as most are no doubt aware; she is a ubiquitous voice-over artist. However, whilst she has great voices for many of the different characters, she doesn’t quite nail Emma herself for me. She is very difficult to get right - as proven by the many not-quite-there adaptations (Romola Garai is my favourite of the bunch) - and I don’t think this version succeeds either in capturing her tone. Some of the inflections on the sentences are not always accurate either. Also whilst the broad humour is served very well, in particular in the portraits of Miss Bates and Mrs Elton, I find that some of the more subtle jokes are missed, or, worse, delivered in earnest. The most glaring of which to me is Knightley’s wry declaration of “being in love with you since you were thirteen, at least” which is quite obviously a joke because he thought she was a spoiled brat which he now has to gloss over after finding himself falling for her once she is an adult, with the second intention of acknowledging any awkwardness over their past relationship as “brother and sister”. It is still very funny and an enjoyable listen, but I’m quite desirous to go back to the original and hear it right in my head.

bibliomania · 26/08/2020 12:26

Totally agree that late Pym is bleaker than her earlier work. I love Excellent Women but my personal favorite is Some Tame Gazelle (with a soft spot for Crampton Hodnet).

Terpsichore · 26/08/2020 12:43

Sorry Eine, I probably got a lot bit carried away Grin Lists can be good fun but sometimes when they don't explain things the context is lost if you just happen to read two books in a certain order, and why wouldn't you if there's no indication that you shouldn't?

Tbh I shied away from Pym for years because I thought they were dull Christian novels in deadly earnest. I didn't realise how funny and subversive they are.

ChessieFL · 26/08/2020 16:08

I am very excited because I am in Hay on Wye for two days! I have only been here a couple of hours so far, have been in 3 bookshops and have bought 7 books already! This could be an expensive break....

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 26/08/2020 16:43

The envy is real @ChessieFL EnvyGrin

Indigosalt · 26/08/2020 16:44

I'm very jealous Chessie - enjoy! I think you have been very restrained re your book purchases so far Smile

43. Segu – Maryse Conde

I found this ambitious tale set in the African Kingdom of Segu in 1797 to be a really satisfying read.

The book focuses on the impact of world events on the ill-fated, multi-generational Traore family during a time of significant upheaval. They experience the consequences of the rapid growth of Islam and the decline of their traditonal religions and the cruelty of the global slave trade; both will have devastating results.

This is a gripping story, well told and set during a fascinating period in history. Although I am sure there are others, this was the first work of fiction I have come across which considers these events from a completely black perspective. It is epic and sprawling and has a huge cast of characters. The world of Segu was vividly and convincingly re-created in all its brutal and bloody glory. In short, a great holiday read.

At times I did struggle a little to keep up with the (many!) different protagonists and there were a number of convenient plot twists which stretched credulity a couple of times. The helpful family tree at the back of the book also couldn’t be relied upon as it sadly contained spoilers. Despite these minor shortcomings, I liked this book very much and thought it was a great escapist read.

BestIsWest · 26/08/2020 17:23

Lucky Chessie. We are planning a day trip there in the next week.

So many lovely shops (and cafes and pubs).

mackerella · 26/08/2020 17:26

Wow, just catching up after falling off the thread for the last week or so.

Belated congratulations to @teaandcustardcreamsx!

Thanks for a lovely review of the Rameau book, Cote. I'm currently listening to the video of Les Boréades that you linked to at the end of your review - it's absolutely gorgeous. As a fellow French Baroque nut, this is definitely going on my (ever-lengthening) TBR list.

It was my review of Apricots on the Nile upthread, Terpsichore - I would love to see your reviews of the other books, if you do find them. I have just bought a second-hand copy of Matthew Fort's Eating Up Italy - I think memoirs or travelogues with recipes definitely hit my sweet spot.

I'm going to have to read that Clothes books and see what I think as my view of clothes in general is that they are things that stop me being either sacked, arrested or considered to be an unfit parent -

Glad you rated the Difficult Women book, Permanent - I love Helen Lewis. And lol at you speed-reading to get the upper hand in a Twitter spat (which I hope you did).

Thanks for some really interesting reviews, Pepe!

I've finished Ali Smith's Winter since I last posted, but have otherwise really gone off the boil reading-wise recently. I keep starting things and then losing enthusiasm Blush. Maybe I'll get my mojo back when the children finally go back to school the week after next?