Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

50 Book Challenge 2020 Part Six

999 replies

southeastdweller · 19/06/2020 22:13

Welcome to the sixth thread of the 50 Book Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2020, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, it's not too late to join, and please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read.

The first thread of the year is here, the second one here, the third one here, the fourth one here and the fifth one here.

So, we're now almost half way through the year - how's the first half of the year gone for you, reading-wise?

OP posts:
mackerella · 17/07/2020 23:31

Sorry for the long radio silence – must do better. I was chuffed to see that Fortuna and Tanaqui have also read and enjoyed The Porpoise recently. It’s a slightly odd book, and not without its flaws, but it’s not quite like anything else I’ve read recently.

I have just made it to 50 books, thanks to some concerted audiobook-listening (I am currently spending a lot of time sewing masks and scrubs, so audiobooks help to relieve the tedium). So I’m no longer in the gang of 44, but hope we can all somehow mystically re-synchronise on the next thread. Number 50 was Slow Horses, which I enjoyed very much; number 51 is The Woman Who Went to Bed For a Year, which I am not, and which may yet become my second stinker of the year. We’ll see!

I'm just working on my backlog of 15 reviews... Blush

mackerella · 18/07/2020 00:33

Here goes - reviews part 1:

36. Noble Savages by Sarah Watling
I've been desperate to read this ever since I read this review of it last year. The four Olivier sisters - Margery, Daphne, Brynhild and Noel - grew up in a Fabian- and suffragette-supporting, Bohemian family, and had a fairly untamed Edwardian childhood and early adulthood, full of tree climbing, and wild horse-riding adventures in Jamaica while their father Sydney was the Governor there, and nude bathing with Rupert Brooke, and mixed-sex camping excursions where they tried to be self-sufficient for weeks on end. Noel went to the progressive co-educational Bedales school, where she learned exciting things like fencing and astronomy and got to hang out with members of the Hungarian nobility. Because of this background, they were educated more than most women of the time, and went on to lead interesting and varied lives in their own right – Bryn as a jewellery designer and later farmer, Daphne as a pioneering educationalist who founded the first Steiner school in the UK, and Noel as a respected paediatrician. Only Margery failed to fulfil her brilliant early potential, struggling throughout her life with severe mental illness, including several episodes of psychosis and erotomania for which she was institutionalised.

The four sisters moved in a fascinating milieu, surrounded throughout their childhood by socialist writers and economists, and then becoming part of the Neo-pagan group that coalesced around Rupert Brooke and other bright young things from Cambridge, and which included Lytton and James Strachey, John Maynard Keynes and the Stephens sisters. (Incidentally, many of them don’t come out of this particularly well: Virginia Woolf comes across as a complete bitch, and Rupert Brooke as a selfish shit). I could say so much more about this background, which I found fascinating, but I’ll spare you all! Sarah Watling covers it all in a lot of detail – some might think a little too much detail, although I personally enjoyed all the diversions about progressive schooling systems and suffragette politics and the training of women in medical schools – and it really helps to set these women and their lives in a wider context. The structure of the book is a bit fragmented: because Watling is trying to tell 4 stories in parallel, there’s a certain amount of weaving back and forth in the timeline, and also some large jumps where the historical record is a bit patchy at times. I had to concentrate hard to keep all the stories and characters and locations straight in my mind, but the journey was well worth the trouble.

37. Coffin, Scarcely Used by Colin Watson
Gently humorous but otherwise unremarkable post-war police mystery. I borrowed it through Prime Reading, and I think someone else has already reviewed it above. There was plenty of local colour in the setting, including a supposedly-scandalous solution to the mystery that was actually flagged up for the reader several chapters before the police unravelled it. I’m sounding a bit lukewarm about this because I read it several weeks ago and can’t remember much detail, but I enjoyed it at the time and will probably read others in the series.

38. The Time Machine by H. G. Wells
Classic sci-fi from 1895, about an unnamed Time Traveller who creates a machine for taking him forward (and back) in time. This is recognisably of its age in many ways (the Time Traveller sits astride his time machine on a bicycle saddle, which must have seemed quite cutting-edge at the time Grin), but other aspects of it are gob-smacking. Not content with going a measly few thousand years into the future, the Time Traveller goes forward to the year 802,701, where he discovers that humans have not only evolved unrecognisably, but have also split into two distinct types of creature. Intriguingly, this is tied into a political (socialist) framework: changes in society, and in technological capabilities, have led the human race to progress/regress (depending on your point of view) to their unsatisfactory current state. There are a few anxious moments when it looks as if the Time Traveller will be unable to return to Victorian London – and a mind-blowing episode where he proceeds further into the future to witness the near-death of the galaxy – but he makes it back unscathed and is able to recount it all in this book. This was a thought-provoking and surprisingly modern read.

39. Look Who's Back by Timur Vermes
German satire that asks: what if Hitler woke up in Berlin in 2011? What kind of world would he find? How would he adapt to it? And what would he do next? (Become an alternative comedian who blurs the boundaries between satire and genuine fascism is the answer – the joke being that Hitler is in deadly earnest, even while all the gormless TV execs around him are praising his edgy, “ironic” rants and devotion to method acting.) This didn’t quite work for me: many bits were genuinely funny, but the satire was a bit laboured (Hitler’s misunderstandings about the modern world, which he sees filtered through his knowledge of Germany in 1945, palled after a while), and his rants were overblown and pompous (which was the point, of course). I was reading it in translation, so I’m sure some of the resonances were lost – but there was a clear distinction between Hitler’s old-fashioned, pedantic speech and the slangy speech of the TV producers. On the other hand, it was fascinating to see a German writer address his country’s past history head-on and with sharp-edged humour. There are very many outraged reviews on Goodreads (mostly by Americans, who seem to be a more earnest breed than Europeans), appalled that anybody would think Hitler a laughing matter (not sure Spike Milligan got that memo). It’s true that a satire can be so accurate that it is nearly indistinguishable from the real thing (remember the outrage over Chris Morris?). The difference is really only a matter of degree – of making the satire so over the top that it’s plainly ridiculous. You’d have to be a complete numpty to think that Timur Vermes is giving a genuine platform to fascist speech – and a complete snowflake to think that exposure to Hitler’s ideas, especially in the context of an obvious satire, could count as hate speech.

40. Where Do Comedians Go When They Die? by Milton Jones
Heartfelt and presumably autobiographical novel about a stand-up comedian. Ostensibly, there’s a plot (about being imprisoned during a gig in China for inadvertently insulting someone), but this is just a framing device that allows the protagonist Jerome to reflect on his rise to fame, from the poorly paid and abusive club circuit to his first TV appearance and beyond. Jerome himself is a self-absorbed and not entirely likeable character, and his friends and family are rather two-dimensional, being mostly there to form punchlines to gags. However, I found the descriptions of what it’s like to be a working comedian absolutely fascinating. Similarly, the descriptions of the other comedians and their acts, as well as the analysis of how jokes work, was where the book came alive – it’s clear that this is where Milton Jones’ heart is. Interestingly, I didn’t “hear” it in Jones’ (very distinctive) voice as I read it – there’s no sense of the cuddly, zany, wild-haired figure who’s always on Mock The Week.

41. Mount! by Jilly Cooper
A welcome return to Rutshire after some disappointing forays into the worlds of fine art, opera, schools and jump racing. Rupert and Taggie Campbell-Black are still going strong, although the former is now pushing 60 (which makes Taggie about my age, if I have the age difference correct Shock). All is not entirely well at Penscombe: Rupert’s father Eddie has dementia, a gorgeous live-in carer (who just happens to be a fabulously accomplished rider) threatens their marriage, and Taggie has a worrying medical scare. The shadow of Cooper’s own marriage (Leo Cooper had a humiliatingly public affair, and then developed Parkinson’s disease, so Jilly spent more than a decade as his carer). This book is a partial return to form (lots of horses and debauched parties, which is what Jilly does best), but some cringeworthy racial stereotypes about Chinese poachers and Zimbabwean black farmers make you realise that she’s now 83 years old. On the other hand, how many 83 year olds can come up with an epithet during a sex scene that literally leaves you open-mouthed with shock, fascinated disgust and then bubbling hilarity? (A very Jilly-ish mixture, that.)

42. Love, Nina by Nina Stibbe
I’m sure this has been read by almost everyone! The first half, in which Nina is a (pretty useless) live-in nanny to Mary Kay Wilmers’ children, and hobnobs with all sorts of North London literati, is charming and entertaining. I was particularly tickled by the vision of Alan Bennett earnestly advising his neighbours about bicycle repairs, and also by the saga of Jonathan Miller’s axe. The second half, in which Nina starts University, goes rather off the boil – and the sharp observations about her fellow students feel a bit more like punching down than when she’s writing about older, more famous people. I have bought a couple of her novels, though, as I found this a very easy and engaging read, and I’m hoping for more of the same.

mackerella · 18/07/2020 00:51

Three more and then I'm going to bed!

43. The Hoarder by Jess Kidd
Wow, I nearly didn't read this because I was put off by the blurb and the cover (harking back to the conversation earlier on this thread). I am so glad that I did - Jess Kidd is an amazing writer. Maud Drennan is an Irish carer to Cathal Flood, an ancient and irascible Irish artist who lives in a grand but decaying house in London. The house is stuffed full of creepy and bizarre curios, and there is some mystery about what has happened to Cathal’s wife and daughter. There are elements that should have put me off: Maud is followed around by a band of saints, who pop up at moments of emotional stress and comment on her activities, and whom only she can see. Maud also lives with Renata, the ageing but glamorous transsexual widow of a stage magician. In other hands, these elements could have been eye-rollingly kooky, but the novel is saved by its air of darkness and real menace. I was reminded of Beyond Black, where the veil between life and death is similarly thin, and where the dead are also just as unpleasant and ignoble as the living. In best Nancy Drew fashion, Maud decides to investigate the mystery of Cathal’s past, which results in a slightly silly chase across the country in search of a nun who can Reveal All. However, there is a lot of enjoyably dark humour and tart dialogue to keep things fresh, and some patches of stunning writing that mean I’ll definitely seek out more of Kidd’s work.

44. One More Croissant for the Road by Felicity Cloake
The Guardian's "Perfect" food writer cycles round France on a pilgrimage in search of the perfect croissant (and also seeking out the many regional specialities that France can offer). This was exactly the kind of good-humoured, relatable, mildly escapist content that I was looking for to distract me from lockdown work and home schooling woes. And it delivered in spades: lots of descriptions of obscure regional specialities, visits to tiny and eccentric museums, punishing climbs up mountains, dodgy campsites and breathtaking landscape. I gobbled it all up as greedily as Felicity ate her croissants, and am working my way through the regional recipes that have been thoughtfully placed at the end of each chapter.

45. The Golden Age of Murder by Martin Edwards
Martin Edwards is the current President of the Detection Club, and has written a history of its members during the Golden Age (basically between the world wars). I was already aware of the DC (and have read many of their jointly-written publications), but it was fascinating to read the history behind its founding, and to discover that some of their literary ventures were intended primarily as a promotional stunt (thanks to that astute publicist Dorothy L Sayers) or, even more prosaically, to raise funds to buy premises. Edwards is really good at sketching the different characters and the inevitable personality clashes that occurred (particularly between DLS and Anthony Berkeley). I am a total Golden Age nerd, with a very large collection of books from the period (my supply of original green Penguins from the bookstall in Cambridge market seems to have dried up, so if you know of an alternative supply please bung it in my direction!). So this was right up my street, with lots and lots (some might say too much) detail about the workings of the DC, and about once-famous and now obscure authors. There's a lot to offer the Golden Age nerd, but it's also interesting and accessible to more general readers.

Boiledeggandtoast · 18/07/2020 07:12

Many thanks Harlan. I'm in South East London and although I follow Fintan O'Toole on Twitter, I haven't explored the Irish Times beyond following the occasional link. I love the idea of an archive of short stories.

ShakeItOff2000 · 18/07/2020 08:28

Catching up on the thread. That’s such a shame about the weekend Guardian.

Museum and Pepe, I DNF’d The New Silk Roads on audiobook last month (on BorrowBox rather than using a precious Audible credit) . Male- and West-centric selective account, I preferred your much more accurate title. Irritating narrator too.

My latest read:

36. The Life Project by Helen Pearson.

Fascinating account of the British Birth Cohorts Studies and the dedicated people who campaign for funding and run them. Started in 1946, and repeated in 1958, 1970 and 1991, these are world-admired population studies following a large group of British people at various intervals in their lives from baby to adult producing the informative data helping to form social, public health and government policies. These cohort studies helped lead the way for randomised controlled trials, the bedrock for today’s evidence based medicine. Well written and engaging, a great read.

This is a book I wouldn’t have read without this thread/forum, having picked it up as a recommendation a couple of years ago.

Terpsichore · 18/07/2020 08:58

Great reviews, Mackerella. I like the sound of Noble Savages, and I've got that Martin Edwards book (+ lots of green Penguins) as DH is a Golden Age devotee too, so I must get round to that.

Btw, for any Olive Kitteredge fans, Elizabeth Strout's follow-up, Olive, Again, is a 99p special today.

bibliomania · 18/07/2020 09:19

Shake, thag might have been me. Glad it wasn't a dud!

Good reviews, Mack. I've downloaded the croissants book.

And some more reviews from me:

73. Magpie Lane, by Lucy Atkins
99p thriller. A nanny is being interviewed by the police. We eavesdrop on this while she tells the reader the whole backstory. The Big Reveal isn't all that surprising (read similar in the last year) but where this scores is there compelling portrait of academic Oxford - not just the snobs at the top table, but the lonely and displaced visiting academics and those hanging around the fringes. A decent read.

74. David Copperfield, by Charles Dickens
This has kept me company since January, and I have a lovely warm feeling about the characters, especially the wonderful Aunt Betsey Trotwood. I don't normally do slow steady reads, and doing this read in installments for the readalong brought an unexpected new dimension. It wasn't exactly a journey in real time, but it felt closer to it. Looking forward to following it by the new book by A N Wilson about Dickens.

75. Haunts of the Black Masseur, by Charles Swanson
A bit of an oddity. Bought this after reading about it in the author's obituary. It's about the joy of swimming. Expected something like Waterlog, but it's not about the author himself, but rather about writers and others who loved it. It does get repetitive as soon by one they exult in the waves. A few men seem to be more interested in the naked young boys splashing therein, which makes for a slightly uncomfortably read. Some enjoyable snapshots (in the course of two sentences, an Egyptian diver is on the Olympic podium in the 1920s, about to accept the medal when a recount determines he didn't win after all, and is then decapitated by headhunters when his plane crash-lands in WWII. A life less ordinary indeed, although not perhaps enviably so.

Sadik · 18/07/2020 11:39

Also just added Noble Savages and One More Croissant to my wishlist :)

Having had a string of DNFs, I've happily had two excellent books both of which I think will be highlights at the end of the year.

  1. Mindf#ck by Christopher Wylie
    This is the story of how the author - then in his early 20s, and, as he describes himself, a queer Canadian computer / fashion geek who spent his teens campaigning for the Liberal party - ended up a key player in Cambridge Analytica using data for propaganda & manipulation purposes across the world. He describes the background and activities of the company, and then how he realised he needed to get out, eventually became a whistleblower, and the process of working with journalists to get the story out there.

    I didn't buy this when I first came across it, largely because I figured I'd read all about Cambridge Analytica in the papers, & it would just be more of the same. In fact, it's absolutely fascinating & incredibly thought provoking. It's my first audible book for ages where I've been looking for jobs to do so I could listen more. As well as being a good book, the narration was excellent (& bonus points to the American reader for pronouncing the place name Llanfihangel y Creuddyn correctly - it really irritates me when English narrators CBA to find out how to pronounce the simplest Welsh words).

  2. The Man Who Went Into The West by Byron Rogers
    Biography of the poet RS Thomas. This is currently on monthly deal & I'd thoroughly recommend it. Byron Rogers does a really good job of humanising and exploring all sides of the man, and making sense of how the poetry fits within his life. RS was a 'born-again' Welshman who was brought up in Holyhead speaking English, learnt Welsh as an adult, & became a crusader for the language & culture - but never spoke it with his son, & sent him aged 8 to an English boarding school. An eccentric, famously reclusive & silent figure who had an active social life with writers & other notable people - and was also warmly remembered by many of his parishioners.

    The book also spends a lot of time on RS's wife, the artist Elsi Eldridge who I'd never heard of, but was also a fascinating character. Apart from all of this, it's very, very funny - I kept highlighting bits to read out to DP & DD - especially if you come from or have ever lived in mid/west Wales. (Byron Rogers has also written an equally good biography of JL Carr - he evidently specialises in eccentric and deeply individual writers.)

MuseumOfHam · 18/07/2020 12:04

Thanks Sadik, just put the JL Carr biography on my wishlist.

I reviewed The Life Project glowingly on here a couple of years ago, but have a feeling I originally heard of it from a previous review also on here (where else?).

I am beginning to feel that my review of The Silk Road has performed a small but important public service. If only I could be rewarded by being given the time back that I spent reading it.

Undeterred from reading long non-fiction books by male academics with a ridiculously over ambitious scope, I am now on Sapiens (about 5 years after everyone else). It's going better so far.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 18/07/2020 12:56

Another one for Noble Savages on the Wish List, thanks mackerella

mackerella · 18/07/2020 13:27

...and I've just put The Life Project and the JL Carr biog on my wish list! I was also tempted by the Christopher Wylie book but would prefer to have it as an audiobook, I think (especially following Sadik's review). Unfortunately, neither of my local library's audiobook apps has it, so I may have to rethink that.

There have been some great books reviewed over the last few days - thanks all! (But also, CURSES for making me lengthen my TBR list even more.)

Piggywaspushed · 18/07/2020 14:57

Just read The Mystery of Charles Dickens in which AN Wilson explores the carapace (a word he uses a lot!) and the 'divided self' that is Dickens. it is all rather Freudian.

He says at one point
But would the real Charles Dickens please stand up? We are trying to make him do so in this book , but something tells me, reader , that you are going to be disappointed and that, by the end, we shall be looking around and shall find that he has made his escape

To be honest, it has never much bothered me 'who' Dickens was quite to the same extent as ,say, Hardy. An interesting read and some excellent analyses nonetheless. And I am very grateful that at one point eh explains one of the childhood stories Scrooge refers to (and in fact uses this as a metaphor throughout).

teaandcustardcreamsx · 18/07/2020 18:58
  1. Dracula by Bram Stoker
Written in the form of diary entries and newspaper clipping, tells the story of the famous Count Dracula. First time reading this and I was rather impressed. Definitely one of my favourite ones now. I had watched the 2013 version where there was some strange subplot about Lucy Westenra being a lesbian and in love with mina Hmm so that was rather confusing. After reading the book I’ve been able to fully understand it, and I love it. Looking forward to seeing the many adaptations on Netflix in the next few days! Smile
Palegreenstars · 18/07/2020 19:24

@teaandcustardcreamsx the 2020 bbc one is truly terrifying. I loved the novel.

teaandcustardcreamsx · 18/07/2020 19:53

@palegreenstars I’ve been told that it’s also the best adaptation. Looking forward to watching it Smile

RubySlippers77 · 18/07/2020 21:17

The BBC Dracula adaptation was fab Grin

@bibliomania I was looking at Magpie Lane for 99p, might give it a go; our library is still shut with no opening date in sight and their ebook system is good but not that comprehensive...

I haven't posted for a while as I was too engrossed in the Alex Rider books, despite being a lot older than the target audience Blush - my updated list is:

  1. Anthony Horowitz - Scorpia
  2. Anthony Horowitz - Ark Angel
  3. Anthony Horowitz - Snakehead
  4. Anthony Horowitz - Crocodile Tears
  5. Anthony Horowitz - Scorpia Rising
  6. Anthony Horowitz - Never Say Die
  7. Anthony Horowitz - Nightshade

Adventures of teenage spy Alex Rider. Will he save the world and live to fight another day?! Well, the fact that there are lots of books in the series will give you a clue, but still, very entertaining.

  1. Edward Marston - Railway to the Grave
  2. Edward Marston - The Stationmaster's Farewell
  3. Edward Marston - Peril on the Royal Train

Further instalments in the Victorian Railway Detective series. A bit longwinded but entertaining enough.

  1. Rachel Abbott - The Murder Game

99p Kindle deal, which I was really looking forward to. Instead it was just a bit confusing and not very well thought out IMO... perhaps I just couldn't relate enough to the incredibly upper middle class people in it or indeed, care much about their fate.

  1. MRC Kasasian - The Ghost Tree

The third in the Betty Church series, a follow up to the Mangle Street Murders series. I love these books (MSM more, but BC are catching up) - cleverly written, beautifully thought out, very evocative of their period and above all humorous. Great books for re-reading too as there's always something I've missed/ would enjoy again.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 18/07/2020 23:01
  1. Once Upon A River by Diane Setterfield

A four year old girl is pulled from a river, but is she Alice Armstrong, Amelia Vaughn or Ann White?

Difficult. I had a lot of goodwill towards it, but there really is too much whimsy and twee in the end.

It's a shame because I really liked Bellman And Black and The Thirteenth Tale both.

I just think maybe there is a surfeit of these "magical fable in the real world" books in the literary market currently and I have had my fill of it.

So...

I have hit 100 (mini wave and celebration to me) I went for this thread in the hope I might hit 50 this year and really did not expect to hit 100 a total that takes me 12 months on a good year.

I do think I have overly kept an eye to my numbers though, and thus chosen books no longer in most cases than 500 pages.

Now that I have hit my own goal, and more than exceeded it really, my posting rate will probably slow down as I turn my attention to "classics" and "longer books" potentially starting with :

TTOD ShockGrin

mackerella · 19/07/2020 00:37

Congratulations, Eine! That's a fantastic achievement. Look forward to hearing your review of TTOD - I'm almost tempted to buy it on spec, solely on the back of the reviews on here Grin

Incidentally, after the last discussion of it, I looked up Harry Thompson. I hadn't realised he'd been instrumental in producing so many comedy programmes that I've loved. But I was Shock to read that his marriage had broken down after an affair with Victoria Coren Sad

mackerella · 19/07/2020 00:42

Still catching up with old reviews - only 4 more to go!

46. Celestial Bodies by Jokha Alharthi
I read this because it won last year’s International Booker Prize and I'm trying to read more literature in translation, or by authors who aren't from anglophone countries at least. It’s a multi-generational family saga set in Oman, a country I wasn’t that familiar with (although I have a lot of relatives in a different Middle Eastern country, where my father is from). Nothing very much happens: Abdallah, a middle-aged businessman, is on a plane journey to Europe, drifting in and out of sleep and reminiscing about his boyhood, his marriage and children, and his later life. Chapters narrated by him alternate with an omniscient third-person narrator giving us the perspectives of other characters. The narrative jumps around over three generations (about 50 years, I think) and tells the story of two families connected by the marriage of Abdallah and Mayya.

Abdallah’s father, “the Merchant Sulayman” was a slave-trader (slavery wasn’t abolished in Oman until 1970), and one of the most prominent figures in the book is Zarifa, his slave-turned-concubine. Zarifa was a powerful influence on Abdallah throughout his childhood – many of his memories are about being enfolded in her ample bosom and about the protection that she, as the dominant household servant, was able to give him from his abusive father. She is a vividly drawing character, scolding all and sundry, forever quoting rhyming proverbs, and lamenting the deficiencies of her estranged husband and her daughter-in-law.

As he enters adulthood, Abdallah visits another family in their village of al-Awafi and falls instantly in love with the middle daughter, Mayya. Mayya is quiet and seemingly compliant, spending most of her time at her sewing machine. But after her marriage, she turns away from her husband to devote herself to her children (especially her autistic son Muhammad), becoming embittered and sometimes shrewish. The novel also tells the story of Mayya’s sisters Khawla (who is vain and shallow, but refuses good marriage prospects because she has been promised to her cousin since she was a child) and Asma (who is bookish and ends up marrying an idealistic painter in the hope of finding her long lost “other half”). All three girls face disappointment in their marriages and family lives, although it is clear that their prospects are much better than those of their mothers (the discussions of the older women of the village about their marriages, childbirth experiences and compelled sex lives are sad in the extreme). The older women are all defined by their relationships with men, being called things like “Muezzin’s Wife”, “Judge Yusuf’s Widow” and “Umm-Nasir” (the mother of Nasir)! Another strand still tells the story of Azzan, Mayya’s father, who embarks on a passionate affair with a marginalised Bedouin woman, fuelled partly by his love of Classical Arabic poetry.

I found the context of the book fascinating, especially the contrast between old and new ways of living. This is a world in which a young, relatively emancipated woman (Abdallah and Mayya’s daughter London is a doctor) can have a grandfather who was a slave-trader, and in which children can die from a treatable fever only a few miles from a modern hospital because the Sheikh will not allow the parents to use his car (the only one in the village). It is a world in which the older people make offerings to the djinns with sincere belief, and where brides come with dowries and must wear heavy, useless, constraining jewellery on their wedding days. It is also a cosmopolitan world, with links to many other countries (some of them unhappily through the slave-trade). Zarifa’s grandfather was kidnapped from East Africa by pirates and sold into slavery in Oman, and her husband is from Baluchistan (which Wikipedia tells me is the region between Pakistan, Iran and Afghanistan). Some of the characters travel to Egypt or Canada or the UK to study and work, and Abdallah is on his way to Frankfurt as the novel begins. This clash of old and new, of tradition and innovation, adds depth and richness to the novel, as does the inclusion of so many different voices. It’s not the easiest of novels to get a grip on (although the family tree at the start helps!) but it’s worth a go if you want to explore a completely different world (both geographically and temporally).

CoteDAzur · 19/07/2020 07:03

Eine - Well done!

TTOD is such an incredible book. I envy you, taking this journey for the first time.

CoteDAzur · 19/07/2020 07:22

Thanks for the recommendation to watch Dark. I'll check it out Smile

Boiledeggandtoast · 19/07/2020 07:45

Mackerella I love your review of Celestial Bodies. Another one for my wishlist.

PepeLePew · 19/07/2020 08:03

mackerella, that’s a great review of Celestial Bodies. I read it last year after visiting Oman and it was one of my fiction highlights. And Oman is just the most beautiful and fascinating country. I would love to go back.

SatsukiKusakabe · 19/07/2020 08:25

Congratulations eine and I hope you’ll enjoy TTOD.

Lots of good reviews mackerella.

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 19/07/2020 08:51

Eine - really looking forward to your review of TTOD and hoping we won't need to prepare your marching orders. 😁