-
Lost Girls by Robert Kolker
This book is the source material for the recent Netflix film of the same name starring Gabriel Byrne and Amy Ryan.
It tells the story of five victims of the Long Island Serial Killer who is still unidentified.
All the girls were sex workers, which meant as each disappeared, police showed next to no interest in their cases, until their bodies were found.
I also read Hidden Valley Road by Robert Kolker about a month ago, which was brilliant and absorbing. I have to say, had I read Lost Girls first I might not have done. It is not nearly as well written.
The film focuses mainly on Shannan Gilbert, so I was able to follow her sections better.
The problem is sadly, I felt that accidentally or unintentionally as Kolker writes about each girl, perhaps in the style he chooses, they literally become indistinguishable from each other:
Very sadly, the girls had A LOT in common from poverty to neglect to abuse to absent parents, drugs and unwanted pregnancy. Alongside these unifying similarities Kolker includes so many names of friends and family members, as well as working aliases and pimps, you become a bit bogged down in wait? WHICH girl is this one again? Which I feel does all of them a disservice.
I feel he could have done more to illustrate that these were five individuals all undone by a predator.
Their unifying factors do end up with this sense of shrugging inevitability, girls like those, with mothers like those, what more could anyone expect?
That the police might not use it to not bother doing their jobs would be a fine start.
Not well written, the film was very good though.