Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

50 Book Challenge 2020 Part Three

999 replies

southeastdweller · 21/02/2020 17:14

Welcome to the third thread of the 50 Book Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2020, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, and please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read.

The first thread of the year is here and the second one here.

What are you reading?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Blackcountryexile · 05/03/2020 10:31

16 The Gustav Sonata Rose Tremain .Follows a boy growing up in post war Switzerland . The reader is told the backstory about his difficult relationship with his mother and his contrasting relationship with a friend he meets at nursery and his relationship with that very different family. I'm finding this difficult to review because although I recognise the quality of the writing I just didn't warm to the story at all. I found it very downbeat although the ending is positive.

Terpsichore · 05/03/2020 11:12

24: Me - Elton John

Borrowed from the library as a bit of light relief between two heavyweight slabs of Mantel, but in fact the capricious spirit of Henry VIII seems to hover over proceedings as the former Reg Dwight of Pinner unexpectedly finds himself crowned as a rock star, possessed of unbelievable fame and fortune, and proceeds to behave like an absolute monarch (with added industrial amounts of coke, which even he, Henry, didn’t manage to discover. Probably just as well, or there’d have been far more than 6 wives).
Me is very wittily written by ghost-writer Alexis Petridis and is frequently hilarious, and Reg/Elton comes across as basically a likeable human being, albeit with a fearsomely volcanic temper, but the latter sections pall a bit as inevitably all his ‘very dear friends’ stop being ordinary joes and become the likes of Gianni Versace (who tries to flog him a tablecloth handmade by nuns that costs a million dollars - Elton declines on the admirably practical grounds that the first drop of gravy will ruin it), Princess Diana and Lady Gaga. But at least he stays close to most of his family back from the old days and seems very happy to laugh at himself. Quite a hoot in places.

mackerella · 05/03/2020 11:42

Do it, Taswama! (She says with all the zeal of the newly converted...)

Interesting review, Satusuki. I don't know how much you know about Jordan Peterson, but he is a darling of the right because of his war on political correctness, and a bete noire of the left (who keep trying to cancel him). So I'm not surprised by the ideological stuff at the end of the book (which is a shame, because it sounds as if the first half was genuinely useful and insightful). If you want an antidote to An Antidote to Chaos, I recommend Robert Webb's book How Not to be a Boy, which I've just finished reading but haven't reviewed yet. I found it both thoughtful and touching and have really warmed to him as a result.

SatsukiKusakabe · 05/03/2020 12:54

mackerella The name was familiar to me but I didn’t follow it up until after as wanted to come to it myself if you see what I mean. I have since looked him up and I think he actually does try hard to remain true to certain principles which I admire and to some extent maybe he gets misrepresented on both sides, as is easily done these days to anyone who speaks publicly with any degree of nuance or complexity, but I do think he has definitely has blind spots (or perhaps hobby horses) of his own and these threatened to overwhelm the book. For example he would throw in an unsubstantiated opinion that women who believe in sex equality are more likely to treat their own sons as perfect princes who can do no wrong and over-mother them. Now I could throw in my anecdotal opinion that it is the women most steeped in traditional gender roles that are most likely to mollycoddle sons and that feminists are more likely to want to raise capable sons who won’t expect a woman to pick up after them, but that would be overgeneralising too and diminishing to women in its own way so I wouldn’t stick it in a book where I had the chance to flesh out something more worthwhile. It was an interesting read though, like sharpening your brain on whetstone (if that’s not too weird an image) as it’s good to find some things with which you agree followed by some you don’t from the same source - good intellectual exercise, so he is not cancelled. I read the Robert Webb last year and enjoyed it very much and agree with your sentiments totally.

mackerella · 05/03/2020 14:25

(Sorry for the multiple reviews - I'll try to keep them short):

23. England's Finest by Christopher Fowler
Bit wary of recommending this too enthusiastically in case anyone else hates it! I am a big fan of the Bryant and May series, so I really enjoyed this. The stories are as diverse as ever, taking in identity fraud, vampires, 18th century myths, the Bermuda Triangle, neurolinguistic programming and the BT tower. In the best tradition of golden age detective fiction, they're not really "realistic" - you're just supposed to go along with it all, admire the author's ingenuity at thinking up yet another devilishly clever murder device, and enjoy all the detail about London's history that gets thrown in along the way.

24. How Not To Be A Boy by Robert Webb
I really loved this, and thrust it straight into DH's hands as soon as I'd finished! Because I hadn't read the blurb properly, I didn't realise that it would be more memoir than polemic - but this proved a very effective way to structure the book, because Webb was able to show how his whole life, from early years to marriage, had been affected by the patriarchy - what his daughter calls "the trick that makes men sad and women get rubbish jobs". He doesn't spare himself or the people round him from criticism, but the book is also genuinely funny and touching. I especially warmed to him because he's only 4 years older than me and comes from a less-than-gilded background (the son of divorced working class parents in Lincolnshire), so a lot of his earlier life really resonated with me. I finished it feeling heartened by the way he'd managed to recover from some tragic and messy events, and also by his call to free both boys and girls from "the incoming tide of gender bullshit that [both boys and girls] will spend their lives wading through."

25. The Quest for the Golden Hare by Bamber Gascoigne
As a child, I was obsessed by Masquerade, the book of paintings by Kit Williams that told the story of how Jack Hare lost a precious jewel, and that contained clues to a real-life treasure hunt in which the prize was a real, golden hare. It seems I wasn't alone: Masquerade was published in 1979 and sold a million copies over the next 2 years. Hundreds of thousands of "Masqueraders" pored over the paintings, looking for clues to the hare's location and racing around the UK to dig up likely-looking spots. The National Trust made Kit Williams pay for a special sign at Haresfield Beacon, stating that the hare was not to be found there, because so many treasure-hunters came and dug up the ground. One man reported driving 45,000 miles around the UK in search of the hare. The whole country seemed to fall prey to lagomania - until the treasure was discovered in some very dubious circumstances. Even then, some Masqueraders were so drawn by the thrill of the hunt, that they refused to believe the news and carried on searching, convinced of the rightness of their own theories.

This very entertaining book tells the story of how Masquerade came to be, how Kit Williams devised his clues, and how the code was finally cracked. He also has a lengthy section in the middle about some of the "wrong" solutions, and the stories behind the Masqueraders who came up with them. As he demonstrates, the solutions often say more about the people devising them than about the puzzle itself : many of them were led down the wrong track by their pet obsessions and were forced to justify increasingly tenuous links when the evidence wouldn't fit their theories. The capacity of the human mind for self-deception is enormous - as its capacity for apophenia. Some of the stories were sad - the man who ended up in therapy because of his overwhelming desire to solve the puzzle - and some of them are happier - the families who were brought together by a common challenge, and whose researches led them to discover more about science, art, mythology, history and cartography.

Bamber Gascoigne was chosen to be the "celebrity witness" when the hare was buried, and he and Kit Williams were the only people who knew its exact location: "It was agreed in the Cape offices that the perfect witness would be either the Archbishop of Canterbury or the Governor of the Bank of England. But there was considerable doubt as to whether either would say yes. And so, less famous for my probity but far more available, I was laid on." His narration is a delight: warm and humane and often gently humorous.

The story ended in February 1982 when "Ken Thomas" (later discovered to be a pseudonym) sent Kit Williams a drawing showing the rough location of the hare. He subsequently dug it up, but was never able to account for how he had solved the puzzle. His letter to Williams was crossed in the post by one from John Rousseau and Mike Barker, two physics teachers who had managed to recreate the perfect solution to the puzzle, but who had not managed to find the hare when they dug for it (Ken Thomas arrived a day later and discovered the hare in their discarded piles of earth). Gascoigne's book was published in 1983, 5 years before Thomas' cheating was revealed (although he does express some doubts about him in the book). I'm retrospectively livid about how Rousseau and Barker were cheated, but their "perfect solution" is reproduced in the back of the book, so at least they did get some credit for that.

I've put a couple of links to interesting articles in my review, and there's a good summary here if you want to read even more about it!

26. Masquerade by Kit Williams
After that, I had to go back and read the original! Still captivated by the detail in the paintings and by the dreamy, mythical quality of the story and settings Smile.

27. Vermeer to Eternity by Anthony Horowitz
Barely counts as it's a Kindle Single - just a short story, really. But I'm trying to mop up all the unread books on my Kindle, so this was next in line. Characteristically twisty story about a woman who has found an unknown Vermeer among her husband's effects ... or has she? Very entertaining but also a bit silly.

28. Wine and Punishment by Sarah Fox
Mediocre cosy mystery novel about the owner of a "literary themed pub" in Vermont whose ex-partner comes to town and is promptly found murdered. I only chose it because I was looking for something easy to listen to on my commute to work, and the title looked promising. Unfortunately, that was the best thing about it. There were dozens of paper-thin characters whom I could barely differentiate, the protagonist was an irritating Nancy Drew-style busybody who wouldn't leave anything to the police and kept getting into scrapes as a result, and there was a ridiculous subplot involving the handsome owner of the brewery, whom she starts off hating and inevitably falls for - saying things like "It was ridiculous to want him to be innocent because he was attractive. Besides, I didn't even like the guy, so what did I care if he was good looking, and why did I care if he was innocent or not?" Hmm The writing was pedestrian and there were So. Many. Pointless. Details. My first real turkey of the year.

bettybattenburg · 05/03/2020 16:46

I finished Trustee from thr Toolroom yesterday. I'm pleased to say it stood up to a re-read and has aged well, in fact I'd say it has aged better than a Town like Alice did when I re-read that last year.

I didn't much enjoy On the beach but there are many Shute books I've not read so recommendations welcome.

ChessieFL · 05/03/2020 17:01

mackerella the Bamber Gascoigne book sounds good so I just went to amazon to add it to my wish list but it’s £75! Will have to see if my library has it. I wasn’t aware of Masquerade at the time but DH had a copy.

Sadik · 05/03/2020 17:41

I also loved Masquerade as a child (though I never tried to solve the puzzles, I just liked the pictures!) - shame that the Bamber Gasgoigne book isn't available.

mackerella · 05/03/2020 18:23

I went through the same process as you, Chessie but managed to order it from the county library, luckily. It was due back today and I was tempted for a moment to pretend that I'd lost it, as the maximum charge is £5 Blush. I did the right thing, anyway, so any of you who are in the same county as me will also be able to borrow it

Piggywaspushed · 05/03/2020 18:49

Anyone get their Mantel today?? That's quite the doorstop!

Palegreenstars · 05/03/2020 19:10

879 pages!

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 05/03/2020 19:18

Loved Masquerade as a kid. Does anybody also remember a beautifully illustrated version of The Butterfly Ball too? The two tangle up in my mind into a blur of gorgeous images.

Nearly finished Trustee of the Tool Room, which I'm thoroughly enjoying.

Sadik · 05/03/2020 19:34
  1. The World I Fell Out Of by Melanie Reid Much reviewed on here, so I won't repeat, other than to say (I think in agreement with everyone else) that it is brilliant and unmissable.
noodlezoodle · 05/03/2020 19:36

Another one coming to say I was about to buy Quest for the Golden Hare when I found it was 75 pounds (and curiously $260 on US Amazon).

I'll be keeping an eye out for it in second hand shops!

DesdamonasHandkerchief · 05/03/2020 20:15

I got The Mirror and the Light on Audible, over 38 hours! I may be some time!

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 05/03/2020 20:19

I paid for the Audible with my Kindle purchase. I'll probably half and half that is if ever fucking finish The Fucking Wings Of The Fucking Dove AngryAngryAngry

mackerella · 05/03/2020 20:30

Apparently, there has been a sales boom in novels about fictional epidemics, thanks to coronavirus no mention of Station 11, though

mackerella · 05/03/2020 20:35

I hadn't come across The Butterfly Ball before, but I've just spent an enjoyable half hour finding out about it - there are some lovely pictures reproduced here

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 05/03/2020 20:53

Mackarella - it's a beauty, isn't it? I used to spend hours with it.

Have been talking about Captain Tripp for weeks. Poor Stephen King. He must despair sometimes at how life imitates his art.

FortunaMajor · 05/03/2020 21:03
  1. Three Things About Elsie - Joanna Cannon Reluctant care home resident Florence has three things she needs to tell us about her friend Elsie, but sadly due to dementia she is struggling to remember them. A new resident who looks like someone she used to know sparks a desperate attempt to get to the bottom of things.

Quite a poignant tale dealing with age, dementia and loss. Sad and quite sweet all at the same time. The bulk of the twist won't be a surprise for most, but getting there is worth the while.

  1. Dear Edward - Ann Napolitano Loosely inspired by real events. Edward is the 12 year old sole survivor of an airline crash in which he lost his parents and brother. Now adopted by his aunt and uncle and moved across the country he needs to find a new way to exist in a world he is not sure he deserves to be in.

Moving coming of age.

  1. Djinn Patrol on the Purple Line - Deepa Anappara 3 primary aged children from the slums of an Indian city turn detective when one of their friends goes missing. While most around them assume he has run away, the children are not so sure and worry a bad spirit is involved.

Vibrant picture of life in India dealing with class, religion, poverty and the horrible plight of so many street children who go missing at the rate of 180 per day. The author, now living in the UK, draws on her years as a journalist to paint a very real picture of life for those who are often invisible to society at large. Heartbreaking story told through the eyes of the children. This will stay with me for a long time as the innocent viewpoints as events unfold almost mask the seriousness of what is happening until you can't escape the very real and devastating truth.

FortunaMajor · 05/03/2020 21:17

Mack & Remus Someone touted the Dean Koontz Corona/ Wuhan conspiracy at book club this week that caused a bit of a flurry about buying it until I pointed out it was a hoax. I did suggest The Stand as a viable alternative, as I couldn't in good conscience let them read DK.

Enjoying the Masquerade info. Such a brilliantly bonkers British thing and so sad that the winner cheated.

I'm not counting books, but I have been measuring every spare bit of wall to see where I can squeeze a few extra book shelves in. I am also clinging on to uni text books as many are useful reference books that the internet has completely made obsolete. Still I am convinced that 3 dictionaries each for 4 different languages are worth the shelf space. And you'd have to prise the 501 conjugated verbs books out of my cold dead hands.

RubySlippers77 · 05/03/2020 21:38

@PegHughes I loved The Ghost of Thomas Kempe when I was younger! It is a sad testament to how little freedom children have these days, though.

@mackerella I've had Clarissa on my TBR list for many years Blush possibly something to do with the Sean Bean adaptation but now you're telling me it's not worth ploughing through?! Shock

DP hates 'clutter' and we have no bookcases in the house Sad all my books are in boxes in the loft. Means he can't see how many I have though

A couple of undemanding reads for me:

  1. Maskerade - Terry Pratchett
  2. Carpe Jugulum - Terry Pratchett

Two of the 'Witches' series of Discworld novels. Classic Pratchett (but then I prefer the early books to the later ones).

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 05/03/2020 22:11

Having read a DK last week, I can confirm he's not a patch on our Steve.

Trustee from the Toolroom - loved it. A gentle, old fashioned book, with gentle, old fashioned and kind characters. Just what I needed.

StitchesInTime · 05/03/2020 22:17

I’ve got a copy of The Stand on my bookshelves. It’s looking at me now 👀

I went through a Dean Koontz phase some years ago (King is definitely the better writer), and was momentarily tempted when I saw some Facebook posts about The Eyes of Darkness, but decided against it.

Welshwabbit · 05/03/2020 22:26

I loved The Stand (although I don't think I'd want to read it right now) and specifically I thought Randall Flagg was the most fantastic character. I was a bit pissed off that there wasn't more of him in The Dark Tower.