Boiledegg thanks for your review of Svetlana Alexievich. I have her on my radar for this year!
5. Hazards of Time Travel – Joyce Carol Oates
A bit of a mixed bag. Joyce Carol Oates can certainly write, and there are whole sections of this book which are just sublime. However, the structure of the book, which is basically a sci-fi thriller didn’t work for me and felt distracting.
The protagonist, 17 year old Adriane Strohl lives in the near future in the totalitarian North American States (NAS) and is just about to graduate from high school as the most promising student in her year. She is arrested for the crimes of “Treason Speech” and “Questioning Authority” on the basis that the graduation speech she has written is critical of the regime. So far, so 1984. She is found guilty without trial of being a subversive and her punishment is to be sent back in time to 1959, and a mediocre University in a fictional town in the American Midwest.
Oates lovingly re-creates 1959 college life replete with manual typewriters, red lipstick, girdles, everyone smoking their heads off and rampant misogyny. Adriane is lost and unhappy in this archaic world, and longs to see her family again. She meets and tries to connect with post graduate student and kindred spirit Ira, who may or may not be a fellow time traveller. He longs to escape the narrow, suffocating world of 1959 Wisconsin aka “the happy place”, which I imagined as kind of like an episode of Fargo crossed with an episode of Madmen. Adriane longs with equal force to return to the totalitarian regime of the future, her family and her friends.
The story builds towards a surprising conclusion which was either a stroke of genius or plain daft, I couldn’t really make my mind up.
The sections set in the 1950’s were completely convincing for me and it felt like Oates was in her comfort zone here. The totalitarian regime of the future was not as vividly realised. Having said that, the more I think about this book, the more I remember the clever, incisive writing and the less the slightly odd plot annoys me. Would I read another book by this writer? Yes, but not if it was a sci-fi thriller.