Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

50 Book Challenge 2019 Part Six

998 replies

southeastdweller · 24/07/2019 12:23

Welcome to the sixth thread of the 50 Book Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2019, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, it’s not too late to join, and please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read.

The first thread of the year is here, the second one here, the third one here, the fourth one here and the fifth one here.

OP posts:
FortunaMajor · 29/08/2019 09:36

In fairness, I must be at least double the age of the intended audience but by god it was awful. I have since discovered she writes for Buzzfeed, so I really only have myself to blame for selecting books blindly. It does make you wonder how people get book deals.

SatsukiKusakabe · 29/08/2019 10:39

Ha ha Fortuna. It probably appeared on Buzzfeed as 100 Nasty Women - What they look like now will totally shock you!

FortunaMajor · 29/08/2019 14:27

Satsuki Grin

Tanaqui · 29/08/2019 15:53
Grin

Cote, I read it when I was about 15, so don't hold it against me if my judgement was off! I certainly read all the Wyndham I could get my hands on, but I should have a look and see if he wrote stuff that never made it to the library or jumble sales near me. I always find it so that odd how easy it is to get books these days compared to when I was a voraciously reading teen with loads of time but limited material!

MegBusset · 29/08/2019 16:06
  1. House of Leaves - Mark Z Danielewski

An antidote to the sun and heat with a reread of this thoroughly chilling haunted-house-with-a-difference horror. Featuring stories within stories (and, indeed, stories) with occasionally challenging typography and a shitload of footnotes, it would likely annoy the heck out of anyone after a straightforward ghost story, but it layers creepiness upon creepiness in a way I found genuinely spooky and compelling.

Piggywaspushed · 29/08/2019 16:31

I think Flowers For Algernon disappeared about 15 years ago,round about the same time as The Pigman and The Chocolate War did. And Holes may well then have appeared, as it were...

KeithLeMonde · 29/08/2019 16:39

I feel like all I do at the moment is drop off this thread, come back, apologise, dump a load of reviews and then disappear again! I will try harder as I love the discussion here and all the excellent suggestions that I have picked up.

This is the second instalment of the books that I managed to read on holiday:

68. The Farm, Joanne Ramos

This has had a bit of a mixed reception but I enjoyed it. It's not a dystopia (comparisons to The Handmaids Tale don't do it any favours IMHO) but a scary exaggeration of things that are already happening - a dark and almost true-to-life depiction of the world as it is. Ramos tells us about a "gestational retreat" - a surrogacy facility where the super-rich can pay for other women to gestate their babies. The surrogates are overwhelmingly poor and brown-skinned - they're exchanging their liberty and their bodies for a stay in a luxury facility, good food and a potentially life-changing pay-out. Some people have complained that the book is weak, that it fudges things and doesn't go the whole hog, but I appreciated Ramos's subtlety - neither the facility's (female, ambitious, second-generation immigrant) director nor the (absent) rich clients are painted as being monsters, and the surrogates have agency and choices. But she adds the convincing and devastating context - the limited choices available to the women, the precariousness of their employment, the tiny daily humiliations that they experience at the hands of their employers.

Lots to think about, a good book to read alongside Leila Slimani's Lullaby

69. Mary Ann Sate, Imbecile, Alice Jolly

Where to start to convince you all to read this one? Maybe with the arresting, Hardy-esque opening scene: a coach stops on a deserted country road and a small child is put down at the side of the road. Some of the passengers protest but the driver retorts that these were his instructions. The coach drives off, and the child is left alone on the dark road. This is Mary Ann.

The story of what happens to her is partly the story of a tumultuous time in English history (and one I wasn't familiar with, to my shame - the book isn't dense but I did find myself reaching for Wikipedia quite often to fill in gaps in my knowledge). The Napoleonic Wars are over (the children in the school yard play a game involving "Mr Bonny Part"), common land is being enclosed, tenants and craftsmen are losing their living and their homes and looking to jobs in the new mills and factories that start to spring up. Mary Ann is a servant - firstly on a small farm, then later in the house of a widowed gentleman and his sons - and she is an observer of, and participant in, much of this change. The book can be painfully beautiful describing the Gloucestershire countryside and the changes that happen to it during Mary Ann's life. It reminded me vividly of the poems of John Clare (which I haven't looked at since I did my degree but found myself going back to)

The style is challenging - the text is framed as a "found document" written by Mary Ann herself, and she writes in short lines like verse, using idiosyncratic grammar and local dialect - but it works, or at least it did for me. You really hear Mary Ann's voice in your head.

That the first time I see poetry writ down
It does all go from left to right
I see now it must

But not all the space is filld up
The words have their own pattern
Make a picture on the page
The space that is writ
Speak as loud as the space that is not

I cannot read them right but I like to see
The spaces and all that lie in them

Soon soon I will read them correct
I see the path ahead long and steep
Rising through many tight knit trees
Lit all the way with bright lanterns
So one may step on boldly
I must work and work

If this all sounds very challenging and worthy, and full of history and poetry, it is, but there's a good plot here too, about two brothers who are good men with flaws, who love each other but are rivals. While the writing is poetic and the book is long, the plot goes along at a good crack and keeps you reading till the end - the story has some good twists and turns to keep you reading.

I highly recommend this one, it was beautiful and left me with a cracking book hangover which meant that I struggled to pick up anything of any substance for a while after finishing it.

70. Ten Arguments for Deleting your Social Media Accounts Right Now, Jaron Lanier

Jaron Lanier was a silicon valley pioneer, and (according to his author bio anyway) one of the tech visionaries who was there when the internet as we know it today really started to take off. I read an interview with him last year in which he explained how the use of algorithms, which mindlessly make decisions on what content to show us on social media based on maximising engagement and time on the platform, are making our use of Facebook, Instagram etc increasingly negative and frustrating. People interact more with content that irritates or frustrates them, so bots keep showing us this stuff because it's how they have been programmed.

This book goes into this in more detail, looking at the ways in which social media is programmed and funded means that its influence on both individuals and society is often a negative one. An interesting exploration by someone who understands the tech and who is not instinctively anti-social media. Unfortunately Lanier is not a great writer and despite my interest in what he was saying, and the fact that this is a relatively short book, it wasn't an easy read.

71. Relative Fortunes, Marlowe Benn

Think this was a kindle monthly giveaway. Utterly silly though readable historic fiction about a beautiful, clever and well-connected woman in 1920s New York trying to solve a murder mystery and claim back her inheritance from her half-brother.

72. The Woman Who Met Her Match, Fiona Gibson

Another sunlounger read. I like Fiona Gibson and she makes me laugh even if all of her books have the same plot - tired, unconventionally attractive single mum (insert multiple references to unruly hair and greying knickers) almost has big Hollywood-style romance with handsome charmer before realising that her oldest male friend is actually the one for her and HAS BEEN UNDER HER NOSE THE WHOLE TIME (not literally, that would be weird).

InMyOwnParticularIdiom · 29/08/2019 17:04
  1. Everywoman: One woman's truth about speaking the truth - Jess Phillips

Outspoken Labour MP's guide to what she's learnt so far about being a woman, especially a woman in politics. This was a birthday present and not something I would have chosen myself, but it was an enjoyable, quick read. You can hear Phillips chatting away to you in her characteristic Brummie idiom. There is some naivety in her 'say it as I see it' stance and a lot of self-justification in this book, but her political views are broadly aligned with mine and her passionate commitment to feminism is clearly very genuine. I was inspired by her willingness to acknowledge herself as a successful woman, and to help others up the ladder behind her.

  1. Language Families of the World (Great Courses) - John McWhorter

Series of linguistics lectures on Audible covering the groupings of language families across the world. I lap this stuff up and have a massive intellectual crush on McWhorter, but this is probably only for the seriously nerdy 🤓

UtterlyPerfectCartoonGiraffe · 29/08/2019 18:53

InMyOwnParticularIdiom I adore linguistic/nerdy stuff (it’s my job too, luckily!) & John McWhorter is such a good mix of intelligent, enthusiastic and over excited about linguistics. Have you read “Our Magnificent Bastard Tongue”? The part about where the do/did/does in English comes from is surprising but really obvious on reflection. It was a great read for an slightly alternative view on the history of the English language.

Tarahumara · 29/08/2019 20:01

I loved your review of the Mary Ann book, Keith.

KeithLeMonde · 29/08/2019 20:56

Thank you Tarahumara - it's one of, if not the, best book(s) I have read this year. But sounds utterly unappealing on paper: 650 pages long, written in strange verse and set in rural C19th Gloucestershire Grin I wanted to do it justice by trying to capture why it was such a lovely read.

Thank you to the posters who have reviewed Once Upon a River , The Unseen World and The House of Broken Angels which have all gone onto my TBR list.

InMyOwnParticularIdiom · 29/08/2019 21:42

UtterlyPerfect - yes I listened to Our Magnificent Bastard Tongue earlier this year. I learnt some Welsh at school so was really fascinated by the Celtic influence on all the 'did' business in English (and was silently cheering that Welsh managed to embed itself so deeply in the language of the Anglo-Saxon incomers).

nowanearlyNicemum · 29/08/2019 23:21

Thanks for your answer Piggy. I've never heard of The Pigman or The Chocolate War but have read Holes - thanks to DD1 reading it at school a couple of years ago.

UtterlyPerfectCartoonGiraffe · 30/08/2019 00:03

Idiom I have a Welsh nanna and dad, so my Welsh side was definitely joining in with that cheer! Smile There are some brilliantly structured sentences in Welsh English (as in, English spoken by Welsh people - my actual Welsh is awful!) like “I’ll do it now in a minute.” (Er, which one??) and It’s over by there.” I would love to improve my Welsh enough to work out if that’s a direct translation from the Welsh, or a kind of spontaneous dialect. If there are any Welsh speakers on here, please feel free to put me out of my misery!

I will definitely add “Language Families of the World” to my tbr pile Smile

PepeLePew · 30/08/2019 08:01

Language Families of the World sounds great - I too have added it to my Audible list. I’m struggling through Fleischman is in Trouble on Audible at the moment which is surprising as I thought it would be right up my street but it certainly isn’t grabbing my attention, and I keep defaulting back to podcasts about Brexit when I’m out walking. For my own sanity I should probably try something different!

Last holiday of the summer so have been able to do some serious reading - we’re staying in a small town on the coast where the teens are happy to frolic on the beach and go off to the amusement arcade together so I have been able to sit in the window reading and drinking tea for the last few days. It’s been lovely and I don’t want it to end.

94 The Soldier’s Art by Anthony Powell
Book number 8 in the series, with the war front and centre. This was more sombre than previous books and despite a pleasing amount of Widmerpool, it was not such an easy read. I am really loving this series though - happy it’s my 2019 reading project and enjoying seeing what others think too.

95 Life Moves Pretty Fast by Hadley Freeman
This is a slightly oddly put together ode to 80s movies - I am not sure it quite works as a whole but I (like Hadley) love these movies so each individual chapter/anecdote/list/reflection was a delight. It spurred me to rewatch The Breakfast Club and I was delighted it is still as good as I remember it being.

96 Our Lady of the Nile by Scholastique Mukasonga
I’m trying to read more contemporary fiction in translation this year and this was on the list, picked up from an article I read earlier this year. It’s set in a Catholic girls’ school in the Rwandan mountains in the years before the genocide. It’s a mix of boarding school novel and horrific warning of what is to come, and shows how embedded the dislike and distrust between Tutsi and Hutu was. I think that fiction can sometimes be more effective at conveying a sense of history and emotion around such events than non fiction and certainly stays with me, at least, for longer. This was haunting and funny and sad and horrifying. And I would highly recommend it to anyone in search of something different and beautifully written.

97 Aurora by Kim Stanley Robinson
Hard sci-fi, which is still a genre I'm getting acquainted with. It’s narrated by the AI of a starship sent from earth to colonise another planet in another system. There’s a lot of exposition and a slightly flimsy plot, and I see it divided opinion on Goodreads on the basis of some allegedly dodgy science. As a relative newcomer to the genre I was reasonably entertained until the last chapter which was a long boring meander. I am told some of his other books are better than this and on the basis of this would seek those out.

98 Outer Order, Inner Calm by Gretchen Rubin
Disappointing. I like Rubin and think she does a good job on the self-help with humour front but this was very flimsy. If you are tidy and organised there is nothing for you to learn here and if you aren’t, you need more than this. Feels like something she threw together to satisfy a book deal rather than giving it any real thought or time. But it did make me think I could usefully tidy some cupboards when we get home.

Piggywaspushed · 30/08/2019 08:06

Pigman and The Chocolate War are great! They may seem a bit dated now, I guess but they were always very popular at the time, especially The Pigman. All more year 9, rather than KS4, I'd say which is probably why they have vanished with the current obsession with starting GCSE in year 9. Also vanished are The Cay and Roll Of Thunder, Hear My Cry. To Kill A Mockingbird (and , famously, Of Mice and Men) have gone because they commit the Goveal sin of being American!! (as are Chocolate War and Pigman).

www.amazon.co.uk/Pigman-Red-Young-Adult-Books/dp/0099184311/ref=sr_1_1?s=gateway&keywords=Pigman+Zindel&tag=mumsnetforu03-21&qid=1567148624&sr=8-1

Piggywaspushed · 30/08/2019 08:09

Oh and Stone Cold and The Outsiders! Ah, those were the days...

FranKatzenjammer · 30/08/2019 10:26

A quick update- unfortunately no reviews, as I'm still ill:

153. Holes- Louis Sachar

154. Daughters of Jerusalem- Charlotte Mendelson

155. The Thorn Birds- Colleen McCullough

156. Notes from a Small Island- Bill Bryson

157. Auggie and Me- RJ Palacio

158. Pet Semetary- Stephen King

nowanearlyNicemum · 30/08/2019 10:58

Thanks Piggy you've given me (and hopefully my DDs!) some 'new' titles there. I'm only familiar with To Kill a Mockingbird and Of mice and Men from your list. Holes is by an American author, isn't it?? We all read that recently and loved it.
We don't live in the UK but are very lucky to have an Anglophone section in our local state school. There are more American than British authors in the set books studied but that's just widening our/my reading pool so all good there. DD1 (and I) read The Outsiders this year, as well as Steinbeck's The Pearl. She is a pretty reluctant reader and loved both choices (possibly also due to having a fabulous English teacher!)

medb22 · 30/08/2019 11:00
  1. A Life's Work: On Becoming a Mother by Rachel Cusk. This is a short book of essays on Cusk's feelings on motherhood, arranged sort of chronologically from late pregnancy through her child's first year or so. It's quite dark - she's quite ambivalent about motherhood. I sought this out deliberately as an antidote to another book about motherhood I re-read recently, Anne Enright's Making Babies. I recognised a lot of Cusk's conflicting emotions about motherhood in my own experience, particularly the oppressive narrative of idealised motherhood - primal, innate, utterly fulfilling, happy to sacrifice everything including your own self - that tends to dominate our thinking about becoming a mother. I found Enright's book too sentimental this time (I originally read it while I was pregnant with my first child), and found Cusk's writing closer to my own feelings. Plus, having had two non-sleepers, I was irritated by Enright's smug "I wrote so much while the baby slept on and on" schtick. It is dark, though not dreadfully so, and also slightly repetitive in places.

On to John Boyne's Ladder to the Sky, which I am already regretting buying since I didn't really like The Heart's Invisible Furies all that much.

Piggywaspushed · 30/08/2019 11:05

I got so excited nearly that I went and bought them! Be warned, The Chocolate War is quite explicit iirc in places.

I think Roll Of Thunder would be a good place to start : it's a race relations book on a simpler level then Mockingbird. but actually written by a black person.

Piggywaspushed · 30/08/2019 11:05

Oh, and if she hasn't read Wonder, it's amazing.

Piggywaspushed · 30/08/2019 15:21

Now finished Sal , a very simple read , quite like Curious Incident , I guess, in its voice. I think I read about this in the paper but bought it because of its Scottish setting. Destined to become a school set text, I think, it concerns Sal and her sister, Peppa who are on the run, for reasons I won't divulge but which are drip fed to us in the first five chapters or so. The very simple style can grate and lots of the story stretches credibility. However, lots of it is also very shocking and visceral, so it's not a kid's book. I also enjoyed the flashes of warmth and humour. Mick Kitson who wrote it is actually originally Welsh, living in Fife, so I wasn't always convinced by the idioms. He was in an 80s band called The Senators...anyone?

It's worth a read , not amazing , but decent and I like it's compassion. You can tell he was also a teacher as he does seem to understand 13 year olds.

StitchesInTime · 30/08/2019 21:20

I read The Chocolate War years and years ago when I was a teenager.

The bullying depicted, and the extremes it reaches towards the end of the book, was something that I found very disturbing at the time. But I guess that’s kind of the point.

nowanearlyNicemum · 30/08/2019 21:41

Haha Piggy, don't hold me responsible for any purchasing frenzies!! I reserved Roll of Thunder from our library on your recommendation. Unfortunately they don't seem to have any of the others.
Yes, both DDs (and myself) have read Wonder and loved it. Have you read Auggie & Me? I read the summary and wasn't sure what it was going to add to his story... I see Frantz has just read it but is sadly too poorly to review. Flowers

Swipe left for the next trending thread