Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

50 Book Challenge 2019 Part Five

991 replies

southeastdweller · 09/05/2019 22:08

Welcome to the fifth thread of the 50 Book Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2019, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, it’s not too late to join, and please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read.

The first thread of the year is here, the second one here, the third one here and the fourth one here.

OP posts:
whippetwoman · 21/05/2019 21:22

@KeithLeMonde I have read A Child of All Nations and I thought it was excellent. She does feature in the book as Roth's lover and she obviously led an interesting life.

BookWitch · 22/05/2019 09:39

Have fallen off this thread and after a good start to my reading year, I have had a run of duds and really got out of the reading habit. Would love to find something really really good. The last thing I read that I would recommend to anyone was The Hearts Invisible Furies back in March. Have managed a couple of light Audible listens but am barely reading my Kindle at the moment.

The last couple of weeks though, I've managed the following:

  1. Notes from a Big Country by Bill Bryson I read Notes from a Small Island last year, which I quite enjoyed but not as much as I thought I would. I listened to Notes from a Big Country on Audible, and I preferred it. Notes from a Small Island was about him as a young American adjusting to life in Great Britain and observations of the idiosyncrasies of the British people. Notes from a Big Country was observations on American life after Bryson and his English wife and kids move back to the USA. The USA has changed in many ways while Bryson has been in the UK (consumer helplines and the US immigration system are a particular bugbear of his), but some things, like baseball games and old fashioned diners and motels take him right back to his childhood).

A very amusing read and some great insights into modern American life.

  1. Artemis by Andy Weir Like many other reviews of this, I was disappointed after reading the Martian. It's set in a future where there is a permanent city on the moon, and Jazz is a petty criminal smuggler who gets involved in a major crime with various parties trying to gain control of the city. It was marginally entertaining but definitely not the quality of The Martian. Over-complex plot and highly improbable. Long extended action scenes that were hard to visualise so I lost what was going on (Probably written with movie rights in mind)

A short, quick read won't make any of my best lists

bibliomania · 22/05/2019 09:51

A quick read - The Drop, by Mick Herron. Advertised as a Slough House novella, although Slough House itself doesn't feature, and the only character that carried across was the poisonous Lady Di.

It's a tale of espionage and double-agents carried out between modern-day Germany and the UK, so the stakes are low (rising slightly higher with Brexit) and it's almost a game to the players. It's very post-Le Carre: the characters aren't disillusioned because they never had any illusions in the first place. They are career civil servants thinking about how events will play out on their CVs, but it all goes wrong for some. This is worth reading if you already like the Slough House books, but not the best place to start on the series.

I'm now reading The Silence of the Girls, by Pat Barker. So far, it's all as wooden as a Trojan horse, but I'll see if it grows on me.

Piggywaspushed · 22/05/2019 17:12

Book number 30 of 2019 eventually turned up one worth reading, although I think I remember remus being disappointed. This was Samantha Harvey's The Western Wind.

Such a clever clever book. Difficult to summarise in any way without spoilers as it is told backwards. But I disagree with some reviewers on Amazon : it absolutely does have an end and it is very cunning : the last section completely pulls the rug out form under the reader : al previous notions are revised.

I did find it hard going at first; she writes very well but is very verbose and it is a bit tortuous . The themes, however of redemption, loss, sin, atonement, responsibility and suffering are very well done. The most likeable (living) character is the narrator. I won't say more on that one.

If you do like clever, literary books this is an altogether far better and more intriguing read than, say that Evelyn Hardcastle (?) one or that other one lots of use read last year about the girl who goes missing Reservoir 13. But kind of similar.

Piggywaspushed · 22/05/2019 17:14

Aaargh! Just lost my whole review of The Western Wind because of MN site issues! It was an excellent review and very lengthy!

To summarise :
it's told backwards
it's clever
it makes you revise absolutely everything you believed
remus didn't like it?
I did.

Piggywaspushed · 22/05/2019 17:14

Oh ... whoops.

Bloody MN.

Piggywaspushed · 22/05/2019 17:15

Apologies for over emphasising the wondrousness of my review in my rage.....Grin

Sadik · 22/05/2019 18:07

40 The Pueblo: A Mountain Village on the Costa del Sol by Ronald Fraser
I've been re-reading this as a bedside book the last few weeks. I don't generally bother counting/reviewing multi-re-reads, but I think this one is worth mentioning as it's really excellent and not well known.

It's an oral history of the village of Tajos, near Malaga, published in 1973. The author lived in the village from the late 1950s, and the book is made up of interviews with a whole range of inhabitants of Tajos and it's surroundings. I lived in Andalucia for a while from the 90s, and this book captures the feeling of the region and the people so well. The late 60s/early 70s was the perfect time to take a snapshot of that area - tourism had developed enough that interviewees have perspective on the past, but the old economy of subsistence agriculture was only just coming to an end.

(As a side note, a nice benefit to writing this review is that I've looked up the author, & discovered he wrote various other books about Spain.)

PepeLePew · 22/05/2019 19:49

I liked your review(s), Piggy Grin

59 Casanova's Chinese Restaurant by Anthony Powell
Book 5 of Dance To The Music of Time, and the best so far. Nick's social circle shifts focus to a group of musicians and the emphasis on marriage and love becomes much more pronounced. And real life events such as the Abdication and the Spanish Civil War also play a much bigger role. Playing less of a role, disappointingly, is Widmerpool. To those of you worried you may be the Widmerpool of your group, if you can have the self-awareness needed to ask that question, you can't be Widmerpool.
I am loving these. I'm pacing myself as I don't want to run out of them too quickly.

Piggywaspushed · 22/05/2019 19:56

OK... I have to ask because I am needy did you notice I wrote the second review backwards...?

grimupnorthLondon · 22/05/2019 21:50

Thanks for the reassurance on widmerpool issues @PepeLePew and for the recommendation @KeithLeMonde - will definitely try that one.

In exciting news - for me at least - I see that Hilary Mantel's third book in the Wolf Hall trilogy now has a publication date. March 2020. Let the countdown begin!

Terpsichore · 23/05/2019 09:00

Perhaps try it in a different language next time, piggy

Maybe Elvish? GrinGrin

bibliomania · 23/05/2019 10:18

I hadn't noticed, piggy, but when you said it, I went back and re-read and was suitably admiring.

Finished The Silence of the Girls, by Pat Barker. I didn't hate it, but I didn't love it either. I didn't think it was a radical new telling from a female perspective - having read modern-day accounts of sexual violence in war, I think she soft-pedalled it if anything. There were a few scenes I quite liked, but as I said previously, overall the characters seemed wooden to me rather than people I believed in.

TheCanterburyWhales · 23/05/2019 10:21

I have added the Pueblo to my wishlist.
Thank you Sadik!

Piggywaspushed · 23/05/2019 14:19

Thanks bibliomania ! Grin

Piggywaspushed · 23/05/2019 14:20

Will duly learn Elvish!

KeithLeMonde · 23/05/2019 16:32

I shouldn't have waited so long to write these reviews - I suspect I am not going to do them justice, especially the ones I read a couple of weeks ago!

38. The Finishing School, Muriel Spark

Disappointing. I haven't read any Muriel Spark since I was a teen and I keep hearing people talk about how wonderfully witty and cutting she is. This was a book about unpleasant people doing very little and while apparently other people found it funny, I didn't. Apologies to any MS fans on the thread!

39. East of Hounslow, Khurrum Rahman

I heard the author speaking on the radio a while back and was interested to seek this out. It's a fairly bog standard thriller, but our hero, Jay, is a young Muslim man living in contemporary London. At the start of the book he's living with his mum, attending mosque on a Friday and selling drugs to finance his flashy car. Events in his local neighbourhood lead him to become more involved with a charismatic man who he meets through the mosque. But other people also have their eye on Jay and he gets an approach from the security services who want his help in infiltrating a jihadi group.

The story isn't hugely original and of course it's suspend your disbelief stuff. But Jay's voice and the setting are well done, they feel authentic. I hope the book gets a wide audience as Rahman has done a good job of portraying the pressures on young Muslim men in a very human way - if you only know Muslims from reading the tabloids this would hopefully be an eye-opener.

40. Winter, Ali Smith

I liked Autumn and I really liked this. It's superficially more conventional than Autumn, with a clear narrative focus - the story of a man going home to spend Christmas with his mother. He's promised to bring his girlfriend, but they've rowed and he thinks he'll lose face showing up alone, so he gets talking to a young woman he meets and asks her to come with him. A small cast of characters, a Christmas setting, a mystery, maybe a bit of romance - but of course, this being Ali Smith, the story roves all over the place, through art,
and history, and politics, and feminism, and nature and all kinds of other stuff. There's a nice link between this and Autumn though I had to read a few reviews before I found one that confirmed my suspicions. In that review (by Neil, on Goodreads), I also found this line, which I think is a perfect summing up:

'It seems to me that one of the things Smith is trying to do in her quartet is ground or embed the events and attitudes of our current time in their underlying history. She wants to unite “now” and “then” because “now” means very little unless you understand “then”.'

41. Foolish Mortals, Jennifer Johnston

I can only say, I read this, I liked it well enough and I have already forgotten almost everything about it. A middle aged man has an accident and loses his short term memory. As his relatives and loved ones visit him and talk to him, he (and the reader) start to piece together his rather complicated family relationships.

I do remember thinking that it reminded me of Colm Toibin's Blackwater Lightship, in being a sideways look at social changes in Ireland through the lens of a family drama - but I preferred the Toibin.

42. Old Baggage, Lissa Evans

Most of you have probably read this by now. I loved this. Set in the late 1920s, it's the story of two former Suffragettes, sharing a house together in Hampstead. Both are clever, capable, and brave - neither really has a suitable role to play in society. Women have fought for the vote, and won, but does it really mean anything? Are there not more battles to come?

I loved this because it's genuinely funny, warm-hearted (though not quite sentimental - certainly don't expect happy endings all round) and clever. A joy to read.

43. To Throw Away Unopened, Viv Albertine

I only picked this up becuase of the reviews here. I'm the least punk person in the world - I'm a conformist, a rule-follower. I thought I would dislike Viv Albertine, and if I'm honest I didn't really like her that much, but not for the reasons I expected.

She's been a famous musician but this isn't a vain pop-star autobiography - she's very much a living, breathing, human being (not averse to telling you about her bowel habits and other bodily details). She can write like a demon but she's a complete drama queen and if the incident at the centre of the book is actually true then she is capable of appalling behaviour. But then I read

"I've got thirty years left, if I'm lucky, and the thing I most look forward to is all the books I can read in that time"

Or

"It [her bed] is the best piece of furniture in the house and I spend too much time in it. I even talk to it: 'See you later', I say, and pat it as I leave my bedroom. I smile when I see it again at the end of the day......... I'd rather lie in my bed and stare at the wall than go to a party".

And then I think we have huge amounts in common, Viv Albertine and me.

This is mainly a horribly sad family memoir, told with a heartbreaking bravado. Her parents had a dreadful marriage, they messed up their daughters emotionally, and both girls carried that forward into adulthood. Albertine views both of her parents with compassion, and, like with the Ali Smith, she knows that to understand the present you must understand the past. She's brilliant writing about women of her mum's generation and about the complex relationships between men and women.

I still can't work out if I would like or hate Albertine if I met her, but I am so glad I read this.

BakewellTarts · 23/05/2019 21:07

Been very busy IRL so haven't been Mumsnetting recently. Still been reading though.

#46 Murder in the Caribbean a Death in Paradise mystery a classic locked room murder. Very like the TV series. Easy reading.

#47 The Calculating Stars a wonderful alternative history of the space race. In 1952 a meteor hits DC destroying a large part of the USA and causing catastrophic damage to the planet. Space colonisation is now essential for the continuation of the human race. It's told from the viewpoint of a woman who wants to be an astronaut. In spite of the divergence from our timeline I think it's a good reflection of the times the misogyny and racism feel very real. It is Hugo nominated and has just won this years Nebula. Very well deserved.

#48 The Amazing Maurice and his Educated Rodents The Pied Piper of Hamlin on The Discworld, classic Sir Terry and huge fun.

Sadik · 23/05/2019 21:58

Good to read your review of The Calculating Stars Bakewell, it's been on my wishlist for a while.

Tarahumara · 23/05/2019 22:10
  1. Touching Distance by James Cracknell and Beverley Turner. Cracknell is famous for winning two Olympic gold medals for rowing (in the 2000 and 2004 Olympics) and going on to complete various televised endurance challenges. In 2010 he was hit by a petrol tanker during an attempt to cycle, row, run and swim across America, and suffered life-changing brain injuries, including personality changes such as short temper and lack of empathy. This book is written jointly by Cracknell and his wife Beverley, two years after the accident. The couple are honest about the strain the injury put on their marriage, and I was sorry to find out that they did eventually separate last year. It's an interesting story, but there's no doubt that Cracknell is a better athlete than he is a writer.
FiveGoMadInDorset · 24/05/2019 06:51

Sorry this thread has dropped off my radar for a while, life got in the way plus a 700 page Lynley Mystery.

24 The Punishment She Deserves by Elizabeth George

I have never read a Lynley book and I did really enjoy this one despite its length! Dodgy dealings are going on in Ludlow culminating in the suicide of the local deacon. His influential father is adamant that her wouldn't commit suicide and despite an IPCC investigation the Met are sent up to investigate. On first impressions nothing is out of the ordinary but something is niggling and Havers and she and Lynley are given a further 10 days to investigate.

I did enjoy this, enough to look for the first one in the series. I was mildly irritated by the use of the words cop not police but the author is American, I can see the teenagers using it but not Inspector Lynley.

Will update my read list after the school run

ChessieFL · 24/05/2019 06:55
  1. Amateurs In Eden by Joanna Hodgkin

Thank you to whoever recommended this - sorry, can’t remember who it was! The author is the daughter of Nancy Myers who was Larry Durrell’s first wife, and this is a biography covering Nancy’s childhood and her marriage to Durrell. I am very interested in the Durrells, and found this fascinating. Corfu is idyllic but the problems with their marriage are evident from the start. Neither had what you would consider happy conventional childhoods - on the surface Nancy’s was but she did not have a happy time at school or a good relationship with her parents, and Larry was sent away to school at age 11 and didn’t see much of his parents after that until he left school by which time his father had died. It’s good to get another perspective of their time in Corfu - Nancy isn’t even mentioned in My Family And Other Animals, which has Larry living with the rest of the family. Recommended reading if you are interested in the Durrell family.

ChessieFL · 24/05/2019 06:57

Just realised my review might confuse people - My Family And Other Animals is of course written by Larry’s brother Gerald about the family’s four years living on Corfu.

PepeLePew · 24/05/2019 07:40

Keith, I felt just like you about Viv Albertine. I don't think she particularly wants us to like her and she certainly doesn't care if we do (punk!) but she writes so well, so honestly and so passionately about being a middle aged woman, which I just loved. Such a very good memoir.

SpacePlusTime · 24/05/2019 07:42

What a fantastic idea! Joining the thread and seeing how many I can do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread