Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

50 Book Challenge 2019 Part Five

991 replies

southeastdweller · 09/05/2019 22:08

Welcome to the fifth thread of the 50 Book Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2019, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, it’s not too late to join, and please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read.

The first thread of the year is here, the second one here, the third one here and the fourth one here.

OP posts:
KeithLeMonde · 09/07/2019 21:08

Pepe my friend's daughter hardly reads but engaged enthusiastically with Caitlin Moran's book about feminism and Girl Up by Laura Bates - they seemed to draw her in in a way that fiction doesn't at the moment.

ScribblyGum · 09/07/2019 21:28

Pepe I have a 14 year old Sims and Love Island addict/reading refusenik. The only things she will willingly read now are graphic novels (Umbrella Academy got the thumbs up), Manga and literature pertaining to Stranger Things.

Terpsichore that interesting about Gordievsky and Private Eye. Impossible to know if it’s true without further verification from the Russians, and that ain’t never going to happen. Gordievsky (if Macintyre's book it to be believed) was a trusted and reliable source of info on who the KGB had in its pay, but he is, so far, the only source.
Still, it made for a good “what have you been reading then” chat with dh in the pub. He too responded with several bloody hells.

summerofladybird · 09/07/2019 21:37

My DS came home with Hunger Games at age 11 and said his teacher had asked my permission for him to read it because she thought he'd engage with it. I had a chat with her and then told DS that he was not allowed to read it. He couldn't put it down Grin

PepeLePew · 09/07/2019 21:47

Thank you all, some very sensible suggestions here. I think pushing the books I and the school think she should be reading isn't the right thing to do so we had a chat tonight where I said "I'll stop worrying about what you read and you tell me what you do want to read, then I will give you those books, and you can see if they get you back into reading".

She's asked for variations on Crazy Rich Asians and Malala's autobiography, so I have given her Karamo Brown's book (not quite Malala Grin) and Lace to be going on with (told her my mother strongly discouraged me from reading it at her age and she jumped on it so the banned shelf may well be the right approach) from my Kindle downloads and said we will go to a bookshop at the weekend where she can pick what she wants.

She claims to hate audio books but I think I may suggest Michelle Obama for the upcoming holiday as I think she will enjoy that and she gets car sick if she looks at a screen. And I think she would really enjoy Caitlin Moran as well as she does seem to quite like non fiction when she is in the mood. We shall see.

Any other ideas for a Crazy Rich Asians/Malala mash up very welcome!

ScribblyGum · 09/07/2019 21:48

Oh yes, and she's also listening to Twilight because “OMG yeah because it’s so bad it's hilarious, I mean, like, OMG, Bella is such a complete embarrassment, I'm so embarrassed for her, and Edward OMG just OMG” , and I nod and make vague agreeing feminist noises and then when she's left the room dd1 whispers “SHE TOTALLY LOVES IT. SHE TOTALLY SHIPS BELLA AND EDWARD.”
Snort

ScribblyGum · 09/07/2019 21:50

Grin Grin Grin at Lace. Prepare to field questions about the goldfish scene...

summerofladybird · 09/07/2019 21:53

I let my teenagers read whatever they want.

MegBusset · 09/07/2019 22:05

Got a bit behind in my reading over the past few weeks due to some General Shitness going on in real life so not quite over the halfway mark yet, but very much enjoyed the latest:

  1. I'm Not With The Band - Sylvia Patterson A highly enjoyable and surprisingly moving account of the music journo's life, taking in a tricky upbringing, working at Smash Hits in its poptastic heyday, NME as it started its slide to closure, and lots of other much-loved mags. Disclaimer: I worked at one of these mags so partly read this for the gossip about old colleagues but I'd recommend this to anyone who grew up with and loved "ver Hits" and the music press.
PepeLePew · 09/07/2019 22:20

I’ve never stopped her reading anything. I read all sorts of inappropriate and odd things at her age and think it’s all part of working out what you like and what you don’t. The issue is when she says “I’m not reading because I don’t have a good book and I’m bored of the ones I have” I try to give her things I think she should be reading. So then she’s even more bored, because inevitably the ones I give her aren’t to her taste. She can read whatever she likes - I think she has just temporarily forgotten how.

PepeLePew · 09/07/2019 22:30

I left a stack of books out this evening for her to look through - no pressure, just “see if any of those appeal and if not we’ll get some others”. All rejected as dull apart from The Bad Seed. Which is an odd choice for someone who said she wanted Crazy Rich Asians, but who am I to judge?

whippetwoman · 09/07/2019 22:39

@PepeLePew my reluctant 17 yr old reader surprised me by suddenly reading We Were Liars, which she loved and has just read One by Sarah Crossan, which is sort of a poetry form. I saw her eyeing up Rupi Kaur in the bookshop too. I don't know if any of those would help at all?

whippetwoman · 09/07/2019 22:49

I've finally finished 68. Acceptance by Jeff I don't really know what I'm writing about Vandermeer. So my advice is not to read this, unless being monumentally confused is something that you enjoy. I had to keep reading the Wikipedia page to follow the plot. Such a shame as Annihilation is genuinely a good read (way superior to the film of the same name) and I love the concept of Area X and all the missions there. Great idea that went downhill with each book.

Welshwabbit · 10/07/2019 01:07

46. Home Fire by Kamila Shamsie

Now that's more like it. A welcome change from turgid SF.

You've probably all read this already but it you haven't, it's fantastic and lives up to all the hype. Apparently a modern reworking of Antigone (I have no classical education and only know Greek plays in which Kristin Scott Thomas has appeared on the London stage...), this is a beautifully written, short (hurrah!) novel about a young man who joins ISIS, and the consequences that ripple out around him. Well, that's the plot, but like all good novels it's about much more than the basic story. Exploring family and romantic love and duty in all its forms, it also has a bloody good ending. Which I appreciate after the debacle of my last entry.

Not much in the way of boobs, though.

noodlezoodle · 10/07/2019 01:42

Pepe I loved Lace as a teenager, plus Jilly Cooper and Judith Krantz! I think Whippet's suggestion of We Were Liars is a great choice.

I wonder if she might enjoy some of the Terry Pratchett books? I love all the witch ones and the 'Guards' series. Very funny but also very cleverly done. Or Good Omens perhaps?

My other teenage classic that I still love to this day is Dodie Smith's I Capture The Castle but it may be a bit old fashioned for her.

Tarahumara · 10/07/2019 07:08

Pepe - from your mention of Malala and Crazy Rich Asians, it sounds like she may be interested in books set overseas? How about The Kite Runner?

The Handmaid's Tale for the feminist aspect?

At her age I loved The Pursuit of Love and The L-Shaped Room (as well as I Capture The Castle mentioned above). And I remember reading The Bell Jar but was probably a bit older by then.

Has she read To Kill a Mockingbird?

Palegreenstars · 10/07/2019 08:19
  1. Fall of Giants Ken Follett A telling of the political motivations of WW1 through the eyes of 5 families across the world. I’ve not really read much historical fiction and I found it fascinating and will definitely read the next in the series. I was however, gobsmacked to learn that it was written in 2010 as I assumed from the style it was older. Some of the language felt unnecessarily out dated (not just Busty Bingo). For a global narrative that is covering more of the 20th Century in the trilogy I was disappointed with his decision to not include any families who weren’t white.

I’m about to DNF number 39 after 200 pages, The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo Taylor Jenkins Read.

Just utter trash. Like reading a copy of heat magazine with less insightful writing.

Probably mentions the size of the main characters breasts every 5th page and so far the storyline is completely vacuous. The narrator is supposed to be a journalist but she has zero investigative skills (I think I would of preferred the story just from Evelyn’s point of view, really getting inside her character).

I skipped ahead and was right on both plot twists but have no investment in these characters. Such a shame as a novel set in the time of big studios sounded great. I bought Daisy Jones and the Six in the 99p deal but not sure I can be bothered now.

bibliomania · 10/07/2019 09:25

Pepe, if you think non-fiction might do the trick for your dd, then I'll Have What She's Having, by Rebecca Harrington is funny and enjoyable. She throws herself into celeb diets, and shows how ludicrous they are.

Just finished How to Treat People, by Molly Case, the latest nursing memoir. I think I have uncovered the true source of the NHS staffing crisis: they're all in writing workshops. I didn't like this as much as The Language of Kindness, by Christie Watson. Not bad, but not the best of its type.

Also read Duty Free, by Moni Mohsin. This was a random pick at the library, and an unexpected delight. The cover promised chicklit, but the twist is that it's set in Pakistan, and our narrator is reluctantly dragged into schemes for marrying off her male cousin to a socially-acceptable family. The author has immense fun with Lahore's social elite and with our narrator's distinctive use of English ("His mother said he's a turd or a nurd or one of those words for bookwormy children"). It doesn't pretend to be literature, but there are depths underneath the surface froth. Pure enjoyment, and an interesting riff of some of Jane Austen's themes.

KeithLeMonde · 10/07/2019 12:30

54. The Blank Wall, Elizabeth Sanxay Holding

Psychological thriller written in the 1940s and reprinted by Persephone. ESH seems to have a bit of a cult following amongst lovers of noir fiction and lovers of forgotten female writers - Raymond Chandler was a huge fan apparently. Lucia is a suburban American housewife. Her husband is away in the army (the book is set during WW2) and she lives with her elderly father and two demanding teenage children (interesting that this is before the concept of "teenagers" was established, but the behaviour of the children is so teenager-ish that we can see that teenagers have always teenaged, before we had a word for them). Lucia's student daughter is having an affair with an unsuitable older man who she has met in New York, and who comes to the family house wanting to see her. Lucia is trying to get him to leave them alone. Before the end of the night, there's a dead body to be hidden and so begins an incredibly tense psychological thriller in which Lucia tries to protect her family and keep herself together while the police and the associates of the dead man pay them increasing attention.

I'm not sure I would recommend this book other than as a fascinating period piece. Chandler said about ESH "For my money she's the top suspense writer of them all. She doesn't pour it on and make you feel irritated". My reading experience was the opposite - while not much happened in terms of action, the tension is ratcheted up to 10 all the way through, not least by the children who are constantly popping up saying "Mother? What are you doing? Mother! I need you!". The claustrophobia is recognisable to anyone who's been stuck at home with a needy child, even if you're not trying to hide a body or evade the attention of the police. Lucia's inability to get away from the home for even a short time without her family noticing and questioning her is very marked and the book paints an interesting picture of the life of the respectable 1940s housewife. I just found it too stressful, too tense, too (I hate to use this word but can't think of a non-gendered alternative) hysterical.

55. Take Nothing With You, Patrick Gale

Typical gentle offering from Patrick Gale about a sensitive musical teenager discovering his own sexuality and the secrets of the adults around him. You know where you are with Gale and he does this stuff well - if you've been a sensitive, slightly lonely, musical teenager then you'll know how well he captures that experience. Unfortunately the book was marred for me by the snobbery that runs throughout - Eustace's longing to go away to public school and his horror at the thought of the local comp, which is mirrored by the adults around him who obviously view the prospect of going there as some kind of disastrous tragedy. To some extent this is character voice rather than authorial voice, but when Eustace does get to the comp, he finds that his classmates are kind but stupid, he has to hide his cleverness, the lessons are uninspiring and no-one is musical. I'm afraid that once this started pissing me off I lost sympathy with the book as a whole, which is a shame as otherwise it's a very nicely told and sweet story.

56. A Visit from the Goon Squad, Jennifer Egan

This was THE book to read a few years ago if I remember correctly, and I didn't read it then. Set mainly in New York and San Francisco, though in other places as well, it takes the form of a series of standalone chapters, each describing an episode from the lives of a group of interconnected characters. The narrative focus shifts back and forward, each chapter has references to other chapters so an incident will be mentioned in passing in one chapter then fleshed out later from another perspective. I wasn't blown away by this but it was enjoyable enough.

57. An American Marriage, Tayari Jones

I know this has been much reviewed and discussed and I think I might have enjoyed it more if I'd stumbled across it before the hype. I know others here liked it a lot. Some slight spoilers in my review below so beware if you haven't read it before.

Roy and Celestial are an ambitious young black couple living in Atlanta. They've been married just over a year when Roy is arrested for a crime that he didn't commit, convicted and sent to jail for 12 years. It's both about the impact of wrongful incarceration, and also not about it. Roy's arrest and time in prison are deliberately kept surprisingly small within the narrative - we hardly hear of his time awaiting trial or about the trial itself - and the book explores wider issues about identity, race and relationships. But Roy's prison experience - and the experience that he has of being seen as something that he is not, of being regarded as a criminal when he is an innocent man - are never not present, even when the focus seems to be on something else.

I really enjoyed the first part of the book. However, the later part of the novel is given over to the (to me) over-long and convoluted question of how their broken marriage will resolve itself once Roy is free. I just thought that Jones raised so many interesting points, and the question of whether Celestial would end up with Roy or with the third person in the love triangle was by far the least interesting of these.

bibliomania · 10/07/2019 12:40

The claustrophobia is recognisable to anyone who's been stuck at home with a needy child, even if you're not trying to hide a body or evade the attention of the police.
Love the review, Keith!

FranKatzenjammer · 10/07/2019 12:47

Keith, I recently got Take Nothing With You out of the library: you make it sound even better than I thought it would be! I think I'll read it next.

Work is manic: I've been reading and listening, but haven't updated for a while. I will do so soon.

FranKatzenjammer · 10/07/2019 14:45

I managed to take a long lunch break to update MN!:

103. Rosa Parks- Hourly History This was a good introduction to Rosa Parks’ story and the related civil rights issues. The book began to plug a gap in my knowledge, but I still need to read a lot more.

104. The Secret Diary of Adrian Mole Aged 13 3/4- Sue Townsend I loved the book as a teenager, so I bought this in the Audible sale. It is still very funny: my favourite joke is that Adrian is happy to receive The Ragged-Trousered Philanthropists as a gift because ‘I am quite interested in stamp collecting’. The narrator was a little irritating, but that was probably the point.

105. Confessions of an English Opium-Eater- Thomas de Quincey This was a bit disappointing: I was hoping for something like Coleridge’s Kubla Khan but my expectations were obviously far too high!

106. Nerdy, Shy and Socially Inappropriate- Cynthia Kim As someone just on the edge of the autistic spectrum, and with a beloved nephew with Asperger’s Syndrome, I have read a large number of books relating to autism. This didn’t add a vast amount to my knowledge, although the chapter on executive functioning was very good. I was hoping for some more general insights into Asperger’s in women, but Cynthia Kim (perhaps inevitably, due to the nature of the condition) mainly concentrates on her own experiences. I think I’ll read Women From Another Planet?, as recommended by someone on MN recently, to get a wider picture of women on the spectrum.

107. Northern Lights- Philip Pullman I found the eaudiobook on Borrowbox: it was beautifully read by Philip Pullman and others, but I should have read the book first, as I think I missed quite a lot of detail. I now plan to read all three books before listening to any more of the audiobooks. My favourite parts were the bits about Oxford, the daemons, and Original Sin.

108. Inside Black Mirror- Charlie Brooker and Annabel Jones, with Jason Arnopp This is a sumptuous, coffee table-style hardback with lovely photos and plenty to read. The text is in the form of interviews with Charlie Brooker, Annabel Jones and several cast and crew members from Black Mirror (though, unfortunately, not my favourites Domhnall Gleeson and Maxine Peake). It contains a wealth of information about the background to, and the making of, each episode. Although it is not quite up to date now, I thought it was fantastic and I’m sure I will buy a copy (having initially reserved it at the library).

109. My Sister, the Serial Killer- Oyinkan Braithwaite Unlike all those who got this on the Kindle Daily Deal, I bought it on the Audible Daily Deal, a snip at £1.99. It was enjoyable but a bit short. Perhaps I’m missing the point (that being the relationship between the sisters etc.) but I would have liked to know more about the actual murders.

110. Nothing is Real- David Hepworth Another Hepworth book (see number 95), this time a short collection of articles, some of which were about the Beatles. It was all well written and interesting, but there was nothing particularly groundbreaking. I would have liked to know the original publication dates- for example, one article said something like ’Oasis have recently done X’ but it wasn’t 100% clear what Hepworth was referring to and I’m pretty sure the dates weren’t included anywhere.

111. All the Light We Cannot See- Anthony Doerr Another book I should have read sooner- I’m so glad I’ve got back into reading fiction after a long gap. This was very competent, but at times I wondered what all the fuss was about. For some reason I was much more interested in the French characters than the German ones (though I much prefer Germany as a country and I am studying the language). I read the paperback of this novel and found the print a bit too small even when wearing my specs or contact lenses.

InMyOwnParticularIdiom · 10/07/2019 14:45

Not relevant to books but I'm telling everyone - just passed my driving test on 6th attempt! GrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrin

Tarahumara · 10/07/2019 16:09

Well done!!! Grin

SatsukiKusakabe · 10/07/2019 16:22

palegreenstars was going to give Taylor Jenkins Reid another chance after Daisy but, ah, maybe not.

SatsukiKusakabe · 10/07/2019 16:24

inmyownparticularidiom congratulations! Great feeling.

Swipe left for the next trending thread